Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Premises & Operations

Handle a special measures order for your higher-risk building

A special measures order puts a manager in charge of the accountable persons' building safety duties under the Building Safety Act 2022 for an occupied higher-risk building in England, apart from applications and appeals to the First-tier Tribunal. Before the Building Safety Regulator applies for an order, you can make written representations.

Construction & Property England

Under Part 4 of the Building Safety Act 2022, the First-tier Tribunal can appoint a special measures manager for an occupied higher-risk building on the Building Safety Regulator's application.

Check whether an order can apply to your building

A special measures order can be made only for an occupied higher-risk building. A higher-risk building is in England and has at least 2 residential units. It is at least 18 metres high or has at least 7 storeys. Regulations exclude some buildings, including one that consists entirely of a care home, a hospital, a secure residential institution or a hotel. A building is occupied once residents live in more than one residential unit.

You are usually an accountable person if you hold a legal estate in possession in any part of the common parts. You are not one on that basis if each long lease you grant puts the repairing obligation for all those common parts on one person who holds no legal estate in any part of the building, or if all your repairing obligations for them are functions of a right to manage company. You are also an accountable person if you hold no legal estate in any part of the building but have a relevant repairing obligation for any part of the common parts. On commonhold land, the commonhold association is the accountable person.

Understand when the Regulator can seek an order

The Tribunal may make an order if satisfied that an accountable person for the building has seriously failed, or has failed on two or more occasions, to comply with a duty under Part 4 of the Building Safety Act 2022 or its regulations. The order then covers all the accountable persons for the building, not only the one who failed.

The Regulator's enforcement policy statement says it will consider seeking a special measures manager where an accountable person is repeatedly failing to manage building safety risk, is taking no action to comply with duties, and residents are put at risk of serious harm. It says this can be in addition to prosecution. That is the Regulator's policy and not the legal test.

Regulator guidance gives the grounds as a serious failure to comply with a duty, or at least two failures under the Building Safety Act. The Act is narrower. Both grounds count only failures to comply with a Part 4 duty.

Make representations before the Regulator applies

When the Regulator proposes to apply for an order, it must first give an initial notice of the proposal to:

  • each accountable person for the building
  • each resident of the building aged 16 or over
  • each owner of a residential unit in the building
  • any managing agent for the building or any relevant part of it
  • any recognised tenants' association for the building or any part of it
  • any manager appointed under section 24 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 for the building or any part of it
  • the fire and rescue authority for the area
  • the local housing authority for the area
  • the Regulator of Social Housing, where any accountable person is a registered provider of social housing
  • each responsible person under article 3 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, where part of the building has premises occupied for business

In this notice, an owner is whoever receives the rackrent of the premises, whether on their own account or as agent or trustee for someone else, or would receive it if they were let at a rackrent. A rackrent is a rent of at least two-thirds of the rent the property could reasonably be expected to let for from year to year, free of the usual tenant's rates and taxes and net of the average annual cost of the repairs, insurance and other expenses needed to keep it in a state to command that rent. A relevant part of the building is any part except premises occupied for business. A managing agent is a person appointed to discharge another person's obligations to manage part of the building. That other person must hold a freehold, or a lease granted for more than 21 years, in that part of the building.

The Regulator does not have to give a notice to a person it is not aware of, if it has taken all reasonable steps to find out who they are.

The initial notice must state the proposal, the address of the building and the reasons for the proposal. It must set out the terms the Regulator proposes to ask the Tribunal for, including the name and address of the proposed manager. It must give a period for representations and a postal or email address to send them to.

You can make representations in response to the notice. They must be in writing, sent to the address in the notice within the period it gives.

Financial management proposal

Where the proposed terms require an accountable person to pay the manager, the Regulator must send a financial management proposal with the initial notice. It must also send one with the final notice, if the terms in the final notice require an accountable person to pay the manager. The proposal sets out:

  • an estimate of the expenses the Regulator expects the manager to incur, including a reasonable amount for contingencies
  • the measures those expenses relate to
  • where there is more than one accountable person, the Regulator's proposed split of the expenses between them and its reasons, including any calculation

Final notice

After the representation period ends, the Regulator must decide whether to apply. It must give a final notice of its decision to the people the initial notice must go to. The final notice must state whether the Regulator intends to apply, and give its reasons.

If the Regulator intends to apply, the final notice must also set out the terms it will ask for, including the proposed manager's name and address. The Regulator must give the final notice before it makes the application.

See what the order can contain

The manager carries out the functions of all the accountable persons for the building under Part 4 and its regulations. The order can also appoint the manager as receiver for commonhold building safety assessments, which means income raised from commonhold unit-holders.

The order can make provision about:

  • payments by an accountable person to the manager for the expenses the manager incurs or will incur in carrying out their functions for the building
  • any other matter about how the manager exercises their functions
  • any incidental or ancillary matter

An order cannot make provision for payments by an accountable person to the manager for a building on commonhold land. An order continues in force until the Tribunal discharges it.

Know what changes while the order is in force

Every Part 4 function of an accountable person is treated as the manager's function. The exceptions are functions about making an application to the Tribunal or an appeal to the Tribunal, which stay with you.

Any Part 4 compliance notice for the building stops having effect when the order is made. You remain liable for a contravention of a compliance notice that happened before the order was made.

If the accountable person changes

While the order is in force, an accountable person may stop being responsible for all or part of the building. The order then stops applying to them for that part. It applies instead to whoever is then an accountable person responsible for it. Where the law requires interests or charges affecting land to be registered, the order applies to the new person whether or not it is registered.

The outgoing person stays liable under the order for anything they became liable for before they stopped being responsible.

Payments to the manager

An order can require an accountable person to pay towards the manager's expenses only if it includes a payment term. Where an order requires payments, the manager must hold them, with any income on them, on trust:

  • first, to pay the manager's expenses for the building
  • after that, for the accountable person or persons for the building for the time being

With one accountable person, they are entitled to what remains of the fund. With several, they share what remains as they agree in writing, or as the Tribunal directs if they do not agree. The Regulator, an accountable person or the manager can apply to the Tribunal for that direction.

The Regulator may give the manager financial assistance by way of loans or grants.

Contracts and legal claims

A contract passes some of an accountable person's rights and liabilities to the manager only if:

  • the contract is in force on the date the order is made
  • an accountable person is a party to it
  • the accountable person's rights or liabilities under it relate to a Part 4 function for the building
  • the order specifies the contract, or a description of contracts it falls within
  • the manager gives the parties written notice that the rules apply, stating which rights or liabilities are affected

The manager can bring, continue or defend a legal claim of an accountable person only if:

  • the claim arose, for or against an accountable person, before the date the order was made
  • it relates to a Part 4 function of that person for the building
  • the order specifies the claim, or a description of claims it falls within
  • the manager gives written notice to anyone the manager considers has an interest in the claim

Where the manager must pay damages because of these rules, for something done or not done before their appointment by or on behalf of an accountable person, that accountable person must reimburse the manager the amount paid.

Managers appointed under section 24

A section 24 order under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 cannot give a manager a function that the special measures order gives to the special measures manager. The Tribunal can amend an existing section 24 order to remove such functions.

The special measures manager can apply to the appropriate tribunal for a section 24 manager for premises with 2 or more flats. Before applying, they must serve a notice under section 22 of that Act, unless the tribunal dispenses with it for a person on whom it is not reasonably practicable to serve one. The notice goes to the landlord, to any other person who owes tenants obligations to manage the premises, and to each accountable person.

Display notices in the building

While an order is in force, the notice about accountable persons must still be displayed in a conspicuous position in the building, together with any relevant compliance notice.

A person who breaches the display duties without reasonable excuse commits an offence and is liable:

  • on summary conviction, to imprisonment for up to 12 months, a fine, or both
  • on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for up to 2 years, a fine, or both
  • in either case, on summary conviction, to a further fine of up to level 1 on the standard scale for each day the default continues after the first conviction

Work out leases and service charges

Recovering the manager's costs through the service charge

A lease takes effect as if the service charge covered building safety measures taken by or for a relevant person, only if the lease:

  • is of a dwelling in a higher-risk building
  • was granted for a term certain (a fixed term) of 7 years or more, whether or not it can end earlier by notice from the tenant or by re-entry or forfeiture
  • makes the tenant liable to pay a service charge
  • is not a relevant social housing tenancy

A relevant person is the landlord, where the landlord is an accountable person, or a special measures manager. Where the landlord is not an accountable person, a relevant person is any superior landlord who is an accountable person, or a special measures manager.

Building safety measures are the Part 4 tasks that section 30D of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 lists, such as assessing building safety risks and keeping information and documents. They do not include steps that involve carrying out works to the building.

Legal and other professional fees, fees payable to the Regulator and management costs count as part of a building safety measure when they are incurred in connection with it. Where the lease uses different methods to apportion different costs, any cost the tenant pays only because of this rule is apportioned in the same way as insurance costs.

Costs that cannot go into the service charge

For a lease of a dwelling in a higher-risk building, excluded costs are not relevant costs in working out the service charge. This applies where the lease was granted for a term certain of 7 years or more, makes the tenant liable to a service charge and is not a relevant social housing tenancy. It does not apply to a tenant owned or run building, which is a building or part of a building:

  • where tenants have exercised the right of first refusal or the right of compulsory acquisition under Part 1 or Part 3 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987
  • where tenants have exercised the right to collective enfranchisement
  • whose freehold is solely owned by its tenants, through a corporate structure or otherwise, where neither of those rights has been exercised
  • for which a resident management company has obligations under a lease for Part 4 duties
  • for which there is a right to manage company

A resident management company is a body corporate that is party to a lease of the building and is either limited by guarantee with leaseholders as its members, or has a majority of its shares held by leaseholders.

Where the rule applies, excluded costs are costs incurred in connection with Part 4 or its regulations by or for a relevant person, where they are:

  • incurred solely as a result of a penalty or enforcement action by the Regulator
  • legal costs of special measures order proceedings
  • incurred through the negligence, breach of contract or unlawful act of that relevant person, or of someone acting for them
  • of a description the Secretary of State prescribes by regulations, incurred by an accountable person or special measures manager in taking building safety measures

Special measures order proceedings are proceedings about making, varying or discharging an order, or about directions in relation to an order. They include any appeals in those proceedings. Enforcement action means action to secure compliance with Part 4 or its regulations, or to impose a sanction for contravening them.

Change the order, ask for directions or appeal

Route Who can apply Limit
Directions The Regulator, an accountable person or the manager Available while the order is in force
Variation or discharge The Regulator, an accountable person or the manager. Only the Regulator can apply to change who the manager is, unless the Regulator, the manager and every accountable person agree The Tribunal's test applies unless the Regulator, the manager and every accountable person agree
Appeal against a decision of the Tribunal A party to the case On a point of law only, and only with permission

Directions

While the order is in force, the Tribunal may give directions to the manager or any other person. The directions can cover how the manager exercises their functions and any incidental or ancillary matter.

Varying or discharging the order

The Tribunal may vary or discharge an order on an application. In deciding, it must have regard to how likely it is that variation or discharge would lead to a recurrence of the circumstances that led to the order, and to whether it is just and convenient in all the circumstances.

That test, and the rule that only the Regulator can apply to change who the manager is, do not apply where the Regulator, the manager and each accountable person agree. The manager's agreement is not needed if the manager lacks capacity to agree.

Appeals

Schedule 7 to the Building Safety Act 2022 gives no separate right of appeal against a special measures order. To change an order later, apply to vary or discharge it.

A party to the case can appeal to the Upper Tribunal on a point of law, only with permission from the First-tier Tribunal or the Upper Tribunal. The right does not cover decisions that the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 excludes.

The deadline for asking for permission to appeal depends on the procedure rules of the chamber that decided the case. Take legal advice on it as soon as you receive the decision.

Regulator reviews and notices

While the order is in force, the Regulator must review, from time to time and at least once every 12 months:

  • the measures the manager has taken in exercising their functions
  • the expenses the manager has incurred in taking those measures
  • any payments accountable persons have made to the manager for those expenses
  • any amounts the manager has received by way of commonhold building safety assessments

If the Regulator considers on a review that a term of the order should be varied, it must apply to the Tribunal to vary it. Before any application by the Regulator to vary an order, it must give an initial notice to the same categories of people as before the original application. The notice states the reasons, the proposed terms and a period for written representations. The Regulator then decides whether to apply and gives a final notice of its decision, before making the application.

The Regulator must take all reasonable steps to notify the people who must receive an initial notice when an order is made, varied or discharged.

When the order is discharged

When the Tribunal discharges an order, it must direct the manager to prepare a reconciliation account. The manager must give a copy to the Regulator and to each accountable person. The account compares the manager's receipts and expenses with the credits to and debits from the accounts that held payments from accountable persons or commonhold building safety assessments. It also explains any differences.

The Tribunal can direct a payment between an accountable person and the manager, either when it discharges the order or later.

Complaints about the manager

The Regulator operates a system for investigating complaints. It covers complaints about how a special measures manager performs the functions the order gives them.

Official guidance