Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Premises & Operations

Check who pays to fix building safety defects in England

In a relevant building in England, the Building Safety Act 2022 can bar or cap the service charge that tenants pay to fix a building safety defect. Whether a rule applies, and which, depends on the lease, its value, the landlord's net worth and any link between the landlord and the developer.

Construction & Property England

The Building Safety Act 2022 limits what a landlord can charge tenants for fixing building safety defects in relevant buildings in England. If you are a current landlord, meaning a landlord under a lease of premises in a relevant building, you must give a leaseholder, who is a tenant under a lease of a dwelling, a landlord's certificate in set circumstances, including when you demand a service charge that includes a charge for a relevant measure relating to any relevant defect. If you do not give a landlord's certificate that complies with the regulations, the developer test is treated as met for that lease, so no service charge for a relevant measure relating to a relevant defect is payable under it.

Check whether the building is a relevant building

The tenant protections apply to a relevant building. That is a self-contained building, or a self-contained part of a building, in England that contains at least two dwellings and either is at least 11 metres high or has at least 5 storeys.

A building is self-contained if it is structurally detached. A part is self-contained if it is a vertical division of the building, could be redeveloped independently of the rest, and has services provided by pipes, cables or other fixed installations that are independent of the rest or could be made so without works likely to cause a significant interruption to services for the rest.

Height runs from ground level to the finished surface of the floor of the top storey, ignoring a roof-top machinery or plant area or a storey consisting only of plant rooms. When counting storeys, ignore any below ground level. Count a mezzanine floor as a storey only if its internal floor area is at least half that of the largest storey that is not below ground level.

A building is not a relevant building if any of these applies to it.

  • tenants have exercised the right of first refusal under Part 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 or the right of compulsory acquisition under Part 3 of that Act
  • the right to collective enfranchisement has been exercised
  • the freehold is leaseholder owned, meaning it is solely owned by tenants in the building, through a corporate structure or otherwise, and none of the other exclusions applies
  • it is on commonhold land

Check whether the defect is a relevant defect

A relevant defect is a defect in the building that arises from anything done or not done, or used or not used, in connection with relevant works, including professional services, and that causes a building safety risk. A building safety risk is a risk to the safety of people in or about the building from the spread of fire or the collapse of the building or any part of it.

Relevant works are any of these:

  • works relating to the construction or conversion of the building, where the construction or conversion was completed in the relevant period
  • works undertaken or commissioned by or on behalf of a landlord under a lease of the building or any part of it, or a person party to such a lease otherwise than as landlord or tenant, completed in the relevant period
  • works undertaken after the relevant period to remedy a relevant defect

The relevant period is the 30 years ending with 28 June 2022. Conversion means conversion for residential use, wholly or partly.

Relevant steps are steps whose purpose is to prevent or reduce the likelihood of a fire or collapse resulting from the defect, to reduce the severity of such an incident, or to prevent or reduce harm to people in or about the building. Since 31 October 2024, a relevant measure for a relevant defect is a measure taken to remedy it or a relevant step taken in relation to it.

Check whether a lease is a qualifying lease

A lease is a qualifying lease if all of these apply:

  • it is a long lease of a single dwelling in a relevant building
  • the tenant is liable to pay a service charge
  • it was granted before 14 February 2022
  • at the start of 14 February 2022, the qualifying time, at least one of these was true: the dwelling was a relevant tenant's only or principal home, a relevant tenant owned no other dwelling in the United Kingdom, or a relevant tenant owned no more than two dwellings in the United Kingdom apart from their interest under the lease

A relevant tenant is a person who at the qualifying time was the tenant, or any of the tenants, under the lease. A long lease is granted for a term of years certain exceeding 21 years, whether or not it can end earlier by notice, re-entry, forfeiture or otherwise. A person owns a dwelling in England, Wales or Northern Ireland if they hold the freehold or are a tenant under a long lease of it.

Where a dwelling was let at the qualifying time under two or more leases that were each a long lease of a single dwelling with a service charge, a lease superior to another is not a qualifying lease. A connected replacement lease, as section 119A of the Act defines it, is a qualifying lease. A lease of commercial premises is not a qualifying lease.

A long lease of a single dwelling in a relevant building, with a service charge, granted before 14 February 2022, is treated as a qualifying lease unless the landlord under the lease has taken all reasonable steps, and any prescribed steps, to obtain a qualifying lease certificate from a tenant under it and none has been provided to the landlord. A qualifying lease certificate is a certificate, complying with any prescribed requirements, that at the qualifying time the dwelling was a relevant tenant's only or principal home, or that a relevant tenant owned no other dwelling in the United Kingdom, or no more than two apart from their interest under the lease.

See which costs cannot be charged to tenants

Schedule 8 to the Act bars a service charge for a relevant measure relating to a relevant defect outright in some cases and caps it in others. These rules came into force on 28 June 2022.

The developer test

Under a lease of any premises in a relevant building, residential or commercial, no service charge for a relevant measure relating to a relevant defect is payable if a relevant landlord is responsible for the relevant defect or is associated with a person responsible for it. A relevant landlord here is the landlord under the lease at the qualifying time or any superior landlord at that time.

A person is responsible for the defect in these cases:

  • for an initial defect, which is a relevant defect arising from construction or conversion works completed in the relevant period, if the person was the developer, was in a joint venture with the developer, or undertook or commissioned works relating to the defect
  • for any other defect, if the person undertook or commissioned works relating to the defect

The developer is the person who undertook or commissioned the construction or conversion of the building, or part of it, with a view to granting or disposing of interests in it. A joint venture includes a partnership.

A partnership or body corporate is associated with another person in these cases:

  • a partnership is associated with a person who was a partner in it, other than a limited partner, at any time in the 5 years ending at the qualifying time
  • a body corporate is associated with a person who was a director of it at any time in that period
  • a body corporate is associated with another body corporate if a person was a director of both at any time in that period, or if at the qualifying time one controlled the other or a third body corporate controlled both
  • where a person's interest in the building was held on trust at the qualifying time, a partnership or body corporate that was a beneficiary of the trust then is associated with that person

A body corporate controls a company if it holds or is entitled to acquire at least half of its issued share capital, votes, distributable income or assets on a winding up or in any other circumstances. It controls a limited liability partnership if it holds a majority of the voting rights, or is a member and can appoint or remove a majority of the other members or controls a majority of the voting rights alone or by agreement with other members. It controls another body corporate if it can, directly or indirectly, secure that the other's affairs are conducted as it wishes. Rights held through a nominee or a controlled body corporate count as its own.

The contribution condition

Under a qualifying lease, no service charge for a relevant measure relating to a relevant defect is payable if the landlord under the lease at the qualifying time met the contribution condition. The condition is met if the landlord group's net worth at the qualifying time was more than N x £2,000,000. N is the number of relevant buildings in which a member of the landlord group was, at that time, a landlord under a lease of the building or any part of it.

The landlord at the qualifying time under a qualifying lease is treated as having met the contribution condition unless the landlord under the lease gives the tenant a certificate, complying with any prescribed requirements, that the landlord at the qualifying time did not meet it.

The landlord group is that landlord and anyone associated with it. For this test only, a person is not in the group if the only link is a directorship (a director and the body corporate they directed) or a director common to two bodies corporate. The test does not apply if the landlord at the qualifying time was a private registered provider of social housing, a local authority, a government department, an arm's length body, the Crown, or an NHS foundation trust.

Where the landlord is a private or public limited company, net worth is total assets minus total liabilities minus intangible assets, taken from the group's most recent accounts audited or filed after 14 February 2017 and before 14 February 2022. Where audited accounts are not available, the landlord may use the accounts most recently filed at the companies' registry for the country where the company is registered. Amounts not in sterling are converted at the Bank of England daily spot rate on 14 February 2022. For an individual landlord, net worth is assets minus liabilities, including those of a spouse or civil partner at the qualifying time.

Low-value leases

Under a qualifying lease, no service charge for a relevant measure relating to a relevant defect is payable if the lease's value at the qualifying time was less than £325,000 where the premises demised are in Greater London, or less than £175,000 elsewhere. For a shared ownership lease with a total share below 100% at that time, the value is worked out as if the share were 100%.

The value is the price paid at completion on the most recent disposal of the lease on the open market, if that was after 31 December 2020. If that open-market disposal was on or before 31 December 2020, the value is that price multiplied by the multiplier for the year of sale in Schedule 2 to the Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections) (England) Regulations 2022. If the price cannot be identified, the value is that of the qualifying lease of the dwelling in the same building most recently disposed of on the open market, ignoring any dwelling whose internal floorspace is more than 15% larger or smaller.

Cladding remediation

Under a qualifying lease, no service charge is payable for cladding remediation. That means removing or replacing any part of a cladding system that forms the outer wall of an external wall system and is unsafe.

Legal and professional costs

Under a qualifying lease, no service charge is payable for legal or other professional services relating to the liability, or potential liability, of any person incurred as a result of a relevant defect.

The bar does not apply to the extent that the charge is payable to a resident management company or a right to manage company for legal or other professional services provided to it in connection with an application, or possible application, by it for, or relating to, a remediation contribution order. This exception covers only services provided on or after 24 July 2024. A resident management company is a body corporate party to a lease of the building that is limited by guarantee with leaseholders as members, or has a majority of its shares held by leaseholders.

Reserve funds and relevant costs

Where the developer test, the contribution condition, the low-value rule, the cladding rule or the legal costs rule bars a service charge, the costs do not count as relevant costs for service charge purposes and must not be met from a relevant reserve fund. Any necessary adjustment to the amount payable under the lease, or met from a relevant reserve fund, must be made by repayment, by reducing later charges or otherwise. The reserve fund rule also applies to leases of non-residential premises in a relevant building. A relevant reserve fund is a trust fund under section 42 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987, an express trust of the kind that section describes, or any other fund of payments by the tenant and others held to meet costs of the building or part of it.

Caps on other costs

Under a qualifying lease, a service charge for a relevant measure that no other rule bars is payable only if, and so far as, it and the earlier relevant service charges together do not exceed the permitted maximum. Earlier relevant service charges are those for relevant measures relating to any relevant defect that fell due before the charge in question and either fell due on or after 28 June 2022 or fell due in the period starting 5 years before 28 June 2022 (or, if later, on the day the tenant at that date became the tenant under the lease) and ending on that date. The permitted maximum depends on the lease value at the qualifying time:

Lease value at the qualifying time Permitted maximum
Up to £1,000,000, premises in Greater London £15,000
Up to £1,000,000, premises elsewhere £10,000
More than £1,000,000 and up to £2,000,000 £50,000
More than £2,000,000 £100,000

For a shared ownership lease with a total share below 100% at the qualifying time, the lease value used in the table is worked out as if the share were 100%, and the permitted maximum is the tenant's total share of what it would otherwise be. A relevant service charge under a qualifying lease is also payable only if, and so far as, it and the relevant service charges that fell due in the 12 months ending on the day it fell due together do not exceed one tenth of the permitted maximum.

No shifting of costs between tenants

If the Schedule would make a tenant of premises in a relevant building pay more than the tenant would have paid without it, the lease has effect as if the original amount were payable. A covenant or agreement, whenever made, is void so far as it purports to exclude or limit any provision made under the Schedule.

Check government funding for the work

Homes England's Cladding Safety Scheme overview says the scheme meets the cost of addressing life safety fire risks associated with cladding on residential buildings in England, and that an applicant must have a Fire Risk Appraisal of External Walls. It says an application can be made by the person or organisation legally responsible for the building's external repairs, or their representative. That person, the Responsible Entity, may be the freeholder or head leaseholder, a registered provider of social housing, a management company, a section 24 manager (or an earlier-appointed manager responsible for building safety, or a special measures manager), or a right to manage company that has primary responsibility for repair. Homes England says it will not accept applications from leaseholders, unless they are the head leaseholder acting as the Responsible Entity. It also says it will not fund work on a building if a developer has agreed, under the Developer Remediation Contract, to remediate it or pay for the remediation.

Homes England says the scheme will not offer funding for buildings where works started on site before 10 January 2022, for social sector housing units where works contracts were signed before 11 June 2025 (except where funding was agreed before that date), or for non-residential buildings, including buildings with no residential leaseholders or affordable housing tenants. For a private building, it checks that there is at least one lease of a single residential dwelling that restricts the property to residential use and was granted at a premium, before 25 July 2023, originally for 21 years or more. Homes England says funding is available towards eligible costs that residential or commercial leaseholders would bear, whether or not they benefit from protections against paying service charges for equivalent cladding works. It expects applicants to check who developed the building and, where a developer that has not signed the contract is still trading, to take reasonable steps to get it to fix the cladding. It tells applicants not to apply if they do not intend to use taxpayer funding, and that all other routes should have been considered. GOV.UK says the window for buildings under 11 metres closed on 9 October 2026 and that the Building Safety Fund closed to new applications on 1 September 2025.

GOV.UK says the Developer Remediation Contract requires developers who sign it to take responsibility for all necessary work on life-critical fire-safety defects arising from the design and construction of buildings of 11 metres and over in height that they developed or refurbished in England in the 30 years ending on 4 April 2022. GOV.UK publishes the list of signatories and says eligible developers who refuse to sign or fail to comply face significant consequences.

Official guidance