Check whether the building is a relevant building
Remediation orders and remediation contribution orders under the Building Safety Act 2022 apply to a relevant building. That is a self-contained building, or a self-contained part of a building, in England that contains at least two dwellings and either is at least 11 metres high or has at least 5 storeys.
A building is self-contained if it is structurally detached. A part is self-contained if it is a vertical division of the building, could be redeveloped independently of the rest, and has services provided by pipes, cables or other fixed installations that are independent of the rest or could be made so without works likely to cause a significant interruption to services for the rest.
Height runs from ground level to the finished surface of the floor of the top storey, ignoring a roof-top plant area or a storey consisting only of plant rooms. Ignore storeys below ground level. Count a mezzanine floor as a storey only if its internal floor area is at least half that of the largest storey that is not below ground level.
A building is not a relevant building if any of these applies to it:
- tenants have exercised the right of first refusal under Part 1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 or the right of compulsory acquisition under Part 3 of that Act
- the right to collective enfranchisement has been exercised
- the freehold is leaseholder owned, meaning it is solely owned by tenants in the building, through a corporate structure or otherwise, and none of the other exclusions applies
- it is on commonhold land
Check whether the defect is a relevant defect
A relevant defect is a defect in the building that arises from anything done or not done, or used or not used, in connection with relevant works, including professional services, and that causes a building safety risk. A building safety risk is a risk to the safety of people in or about the building from the spread of fire or the collapse of the building or any part of it.
Relevant works are any of these:
- works to construct or convert the building, completed in the relevant period
- works undertaken or commissioned by or on behalf of a landlord under a lease of the building or any part of it, or a person party to such a lease otherwise than as landlord or tenant, completed in the relevant period
- works undertaken after the relevant period to remedy a relevant defect
The relevant period is the 30 years ending with 28 June 2022. Conversion means conversion for residential use, wholly or partly.
Relevant steps are steps whose purpose is to prevent or reduce the likelihood of a fire or collapse resulting from the defect, to reduce the severity of such an incident, or to prevent or reduce harm to people in or about the building.
Check who counts as associated
The qualifying time is the start of 14 February 2022. For a remediation contribution order, a partnership or body corporate is associated with another person in these cases:
- a partnership is associated with a person who was a partner in it, other than a limited partner, at any time in the 5 years ending at the qualifying time
- a body corporate is associated with a person who was a director of it at any time in that period
- a body corporate is associated with another body corporate if a person was a director of both at any time in that period, or if at the qualifying time one controlled the other or a third body corporate controlled both
- where a person's interest in the building was held on trust at the qualifying time, a partnership or body corporate that was a beneficiary of the trust then is associated with that person
A body corporate controls a company if it holds or is entitled to acquire at least half of its issued share capital, votes or distributable income, or rights to at least half of its assets on a winding up or in any other circumstances. It controls a limited liability partnership if it holds a majority of the voting rights, or is a member and either can appoint or remove a majority of the other members or controls a majority of the voting rights alone or by agreement with other members. It controls another body corporate if it has the power, directly or indirectly, to secure that the other's affairs are conducted as it wishes. Rights held through a nominee or a controlled body corporate count as its own.
Apply for a remediation order
If you are an interested person, you can apply to the First-tier Tribunal for a remediation order. The Tribunal may make one requiring a relevant landlord, by a specified time, to remedy specified relevant defects in a specified relevant building, to take specified relevant steps in relation to a specified relevant defect in it, or both.
The Building Safety Act 2022 names these interested persons: the Building Safety Regulator, the local authority for the area in which the building is situated, the fire and rescue authority for that area, and a person with a legal or equitable interest in the building or any part of it. It also covers any other person prescribed by regulations. The Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections) (Information etc.) (England) Regulations 2022 prescribe the Secretary of State and the Homes and Communities Agency.
The order is made against a relevant landlord, which for a remediation order is a landlord under a lease of the building or any part of it, including a person party to the lease otherwise than as landlord or tenant, who is required under the lease or by an enactment to repair or maintain anything relating to the relevant defect. The application must state that it is made under section 123 of the Act, identify the building and the defects, and identify the landlord the applicant considers responsible for repairing or maintaining anything relating to those defects.
A decision of the First-tier Tribunal or Upper Tribunal made under or in connection with section 123, other than one ordering the payment of a sum, is enforceable with the permission of the county court in the same way as an order of that court. In proceedings for a remediation order, a direction by the First-tier Tribunal requiring a relevant landlord to provide or produce an expert report counts as such a decision. An expert report is a report or survey relating to relevant defects, or potential relevant defects, in the building, or to relevant steps taken or that might be taken in relation to a relevant defect. The changes made on 31 October 2024, which added relevant steps and expert report directions, apply to proceedings pending on that date as well as to proceedings started later.
GOV.UK guidance says:
- an application must be made on form BSA1 and sent to the First-tier Tribunal regional office for the building's area
- an applicant is expected to send the respondent a letter before making a claim
- proceedings are generally cost neutral, with each party paying its own legal costs
Apply for a remediation order (form BSA1) (opens in a new tab)
Apply for a remediation contribution order
If you are an interested person, you can apply to the First-tier Tribunal for a remediation contribution order for a relevant building. The Tribunal may make one if it considers it just and equitable to do so. The order requires a specified body corporate or partnership to make payments to a specified person to meet costs incurred or to be incurred in remedying, or otherwise in connection with, relevant defects relating to the building or specified relevant defects.
The Building Safety Act 2022 names these interested persons: the Secretary of State, the Building Safety Regulator, the local authority for the area, the fire and rescue authority for the area, and a person with a legal or equitable interest in the building or any part of it. It also covers any other person prescribed by regulations. The Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections) (Information etc.) (England) Regulations 2022 prescribe the Homes and Communities Agency, and the named manager, resident management company and right to manage company for the building. A named manager is a person named in a lease as the party with managing and repairing obligations who is a separate legal person from the freeholder and any landlord. A resident management company here is a body corporate party to a lease of the building that is limited by guarantee with leaseholders as members, or has a majority of its shares held by leaseholders.
Only a body corporate or partnership can be ordered to pay, and only if it is:
- a landlord under a lease of the building or any part of it
- a person who was such a landlord at the qualifying time
- a developer in relation to the building, meaning a person who undertook or commissioned its construction or conversion, or that of part of it, with a view to granting or disposing of interests in it
- a person associated, in the sense of section 121 of the Act, with a landlord under a lease of the building or any part of it, a person who was such a landlord at the qualifying time, or a developer in relation to the building
Costs within an order include costs of relevant steps, costs of an expert report, and temporary accommodation costs of a decant, meaning the cost of the accommodation and other resulting costs such as removal, storage and reasonable travel. The Act expressly covers a decant that took place or is to take place to avoid an imminent threat to life or of personal injury from a relevant defect, because works relating to the building, to remedy a relevant defect or take relevant steps, created or are expected to create circumstances in which a dwelling's occupiers cannot reasonably be expected to live there, or for another prescribed reason connected with relevant defects or works.
The order can require payment of a specified amount. Where it specifies no amount, it can determine that a specified body corporate or partnership is liable for the reasonable costs of specified things done or to be done. It can require payment at a specified time, or on demand after a specified event. The changes made on 31 October 2024, including relevant steps, expert reports, decant costs and costs otherwise in connection with relevant defects, apply to proceedings pending on that date, to proceedings started later and to costs incurred before as well as after it.
Regulation 4 of the Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections) (England) Regulations 2022 applies section 124 to a building that would be a relevant building but for the exclusions in section 117(3), such as a leaseholder-owned building. For such a building an order cannot name a landlord company owned in part or in full by a majority of the building's residential leaseholders, a person who was such a landlord at the qualifying time, or a commonhold association. A special measures manager, within the meaning of paragraph 4(2) of Schedule 7 to the Act, is also an interested person for such a building.
GOV.UK guidance says:
- applications are made on form BSA2
- a party with a point of law can ask the First-tier Tribunal for permission to appeal to the Lands Chamber of the Upper Tribunal
- the process is cost neutral, but the Tribunal can order costs against a party who acted unreasonably
- the county court can enforce an order as an order for payment under section 27 of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007
Apply for a remediation contribution order (form BSA2) (opens in a new tab)
Apply for a building liability order
The High Court may make a building liability order if it considers it just and equitable to do so. The order provides that a relevant liability of a body corporate, the original body, relating to a specified building is also a liability of a specified body corporate, or the joint and several liability of two or more specified bodies corporate. It is not limited to a relevant building. The section that creates the order, section 130, does not say who may apply for it.
The liabilities an order can cover are those listed in section 130(3). A relevant liability is one incurred, whether before or after 28 June 2022, under the Defective Premises Act 1972 or section 38 of the Building Act 1984, or as a result of a building safety risk. Here a building safety risk is a risk to the safety of people in or about the building from the spread of fire or structural failure.
A body corporate may be specified only if it is, or at any time in the relevant period has been, associated with the original body. The relevant period starts when the works in relation to which the liability was incurred began and ends when the order is made. Two bodies corporate are associated if one controls the other or a third body corporate controls both, with control having the meaning given in section 131. Where a person's interest in the building is held on trust, a body corporate that is a beneficiary of the trust is regarded as associated with that person.
An order can be made in respect of a liability of a body corporate that has been dissolved, including one dissolved before 28 June 2022, and it continues to have effect if the body corporate is dissolved after the order is made.
Bring a claim under the Defective Premises Act 1972
Under section 1, a person taking on work for or in connection with the provision of a dwelling, by erecting it or by converting or enlarging a building, owes a duty to see that the work they take on is done in a workmanlike or professional manner, with proper materials, so that as regards that work the dwelling will be fit for habitation when completed. The duty is owed to the person who ordered the dwelling, if it was provided to anyone's order, and to every person who acquires a legal or equitable interest in it. If you are one of those people, you can bring a claim for breach of the duty.
A person who arranges for another to take on the work, in the course of a business of providing or arranging dwellings or installations in dwellings or in exercising a statutory power to do so, is treated as having taken it on. A person who takes on the work on terms that it is done in line with the client's instructions discharges the duty to the extent they do it properly in line with those instructions, unless they owed the client a duty to warn of defects in the instructions and did not. A client is not treated as giving instructions merely because they agreed to the work being done in a specified manner, with specified materials or to a specified design. No action may be brought by a person having or acquiring an interest in the dwelling for breach of the section 1 duty where, in connection with the dwelling's provision or first sale or letting for habitation, an approved scheme confers rights in respect of defects on such a person and an approved document states that the scheme's design or construction requirements have, or appear to have, been substantially complied with.
Under section 2A, a person who, in the course of a business, takes on work in relation to any part of a building consisting of or containing one or more dwellings owes a duty to see that the work is done in a workmanlike or professional manner, with proper materials, so that as regards the work the dwelling is fit for habitation when the work is completed. The duty is owed to the person for whom the work is done and to each person who holds or acquires a legal or equitable interest in a dwelling in the building. The duty does not apply to a dwelling if the work is for or in connection with the provision of the dwelling, which section 1 covers, or if the dwelling is expected to cease to be a dwelling or to exist on completion. It applies only to work completed after section 134 of the Building Safety Act 2022 came into force on 28 June 2022. A person who, in the course of a business of carrying out or arranging such work, arranges for another to take it on is treated as having taken it on. As under section 1, a person who takes on the work on terms that it is done in line with the client's instructions discharges the duty to the extent they do it properly in line with those instructions, unless they owed the client a duty to warn of defects in the instructions and did not. A client is not treated as giving instructions merely by agreeing to the work being done in a specified manner, with specified materials or to a specified design. If you are the person for whom the work was done, or you hold or acquire a legal or equitable interest in a dwelling in the building, you can bring a claim for breach of the section 2A duty.
Any term of an agreement that purports to exclude or restrict, or has the effect of excluding or restricting, the operation of any provision of the Defective Premises Act 1972, or any liability arising under it, is void.
Time limits
No action under section 1 or section 2A may be brought after 15 years from the date on which the right of action accrued. Where a section 1 right of action arose before 28 June 2022, the period is 30 years. A cause of action under section 1 accrues when the dwelling was completed, and one under section 2A when the work was completed. If the person who did the work later does further work to rectify it, a cause of action in respect of that further work accrues when it is finished.
Only sections 1, 28, 32, 35, 37 and 38 of the Limitation Act 1980 apply to these actions. That includes the extension for disability in section 28 and the postponement for fraud, concealment or mistake in section 32. Under section 135 of the Building Safety Act 2022, the amendment that inserted section 4B of the Limitation Act 1980, as it applies to section 1 actions, is treated as always having been in force. A revived action is one that would have been barred by the Limitation Act 1980 but for that provision. A court hearing a revived action must dismiss it in relation to any defendant if satisfied that this is necessary to avoid a breach of that defendant's Convention rights, as the Human Rights Act 1998 defines them. The rules in section 135 do not apply to a claim that, before 28 June 2022, was settled by agreement or finally determined by a court or in arbitration.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations