Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Compliance & Legal

Answer a regulator's request for information

A regulator's request is usually either a formal notice that names a statutory power, sets a time and states what follows if you do not comply, or an informal ask that relies on cooperation. Read it first, answer accurately, keep the records it covers, and take advice before withholding anything.

UK-wide

Read what the letter says it is

A formal notice usually cites its statutory power, says what the regulator wants and why, sets a time and says what follows if you do not comply. An informal request relies on cooperation.

CMA guidance (CMA8, December 2024) says the CMA may ask for information informally at the initial assessment stage, relying on voluntary cooperation, but is unlikely to do so where that may prejudice the investigation, for example in a suspected cartel. It says its formal requests are called section 26 notices, are sent in writing, tell the recipient what the investigation is about, describe what is required and set out the offences or sanctions that may apply.

An informal request does not remove the need to be accurate. Under the Competition Act 1998 s.44, providing information to the CMA in connection with its functions under Part 1 of that Act is an offence if the information is false or misleading in a material particular and you know it is or are reckless as to whether it is.

Regulator and power Who can be required What the statute says about the notice
Information Commission (formerly the ICO), Data Protection Act 2018 s.142 A controller or processor, for information or documents the Commission reasonably requires. Any person, for a suspected failure of a type in s.149(2), a suspected offence under the Act, or whether processing is purely personal or household Written. It must say which of those grounds it is given under and why the Commission requires the information, and give the consequences of failure and the appeal rights. It may set the time, form and place
CMA, Competition Act 1998 s.26 Any person, for a specified document or information the CMA considers relates to any matter relevant to an investigation under s.25 In writing. It must indicate the subject matter and purpose of the investigation and the possible consequences of failing to comply. It may specify the time, place, manner and form
Consumer law enforcers, Consumer Rights Act 2015 Sch 5 para 14 A person. An enforcer may use the power only for the purposes and in the circumstances in para 13, and a domestic enforcer may use it to ascertain a breach only if an officer reasonably suspects one, unless it is a market surveillance authority using the power for market surveillance In writing. It must specify the purpose, the time and manner for compliance, the form, and the circumstances in which a monetary penalty may be payable. It may require documents to be created
Ofcom, Online Safety Act 2023 ss.100 and 102 The persons in s.100(5), including providers of the services described in s.109(7). Ofcom must use the power proportionately It must describe the information, say why Ofcom requires it, specify the form and manner and when it must be provided, and set out the consequences of not complying
FCA or PRA, Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s.165 An authorised person. Under s.165(7) the power also reaches others, including a person connected with an authorised person and a person who provides any service to an insurance or reinsurance undertaking A notice in writing requiring specified information or documents within a reasonable period, at a specified place. An officer with written authorisation from the regulator may require an authorised person to provide or produce them without delay. Only information and documents reasonably required in connection with the regulator's functions can be required or, for the PRA, reasonably required by the Bank of England for its financial stability objective

Under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 s.20, an inspector acting to carry into effect the relevant statutory provisions within the field of the enforcing authority may require a person they have reasonable cause to believe can give relevant information to answer questions and sign a declaration of the truth of the answers. They may also require production of documents that must be kept under those provisions or that they need to see for an examination or investigation. These inspector powers do not extend to Northern Ireland.

Find the power and the deadline

Look in the letter for the statute it relies on, the purpose it gives and the time it sets. The statute decides what you can be required to do and what follows if you do not. Some deadlines carry conditions.

  • A Commission notice cannot require you to provide information or documents before the period for appealing against it ends. If you appeal, you need not provide the information until the appeal is decided or withdrawn.
  • The bar on providing information before the appeal period ends, and the pause while an appeal is decided, do not apply where the notice states the Commission's opinion that the information is required urgently and gives reasons. Even then, the notice cannot require provision within 24 hours of the notice being given.
  • An Ofcom notice under the Online Safety Act that requires steps so that Ofcom can view systems remotely in real time must give at least 7 days' notice before the steps are required.

Keep the records the request covers

The rules against destroying records start at different points. Some apply as soon as you know or suspect an investigation, before any request arrives, and each also covers altering or hiding records. Stopping routine deletion of anything a request or investigation may cover as soon as you know of it, and not altering or hiding it, helps you avoid breaching them.

Regulator and provision When it applies What it prohibits
CMA, Competition Act 1998 s.25B You know or suspect that a CMA investigation under s.25 is being or is likely to be carried out, or that the CMA is or is likely to be assisting an overseas regulator Falsifying, concealing, destroying or otherwise disposing of a document you know or suspect is or would be relevant, or causing or permitting that
CMA, Competition Act 1998 s.43 You have been required to produce a document under s.26, 27, 28 or 28A Intentionally or recklessly destroying, disposing of, falsifying or concealing it, or causing or permitting that
The Commission, Data Protection Act 2018 s.148 You have been given an information notice Destroying, disposing of, concealing, blocking or falsifying the information or document, or causing or permitting that, with intent to prevent the Commission viewing it or being given it. It is a defence to prove it would have happened without the notice
Ofcom, Online Safety Act 2023 s.109 An information notice has been given to the provider of a user-to-user service, a search service or an internet service on which regulated provider pornographic content is published or displayed, and relates to that service. Any person can commit the offence Suppressing, destroying or altering the information or document the notice requires, or causing or permitting that, intending to prevent Ofcom being provided with it. Providing information encrypted so that Ofcom cannot understand it, intending to prevent that, is a separate offence
FCA or PRA, Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s.177 You know or suspect that an investigation under Part XI is being or is likely to be conducted Falsifying, concealing, destroying or disposing of a document you know or suspect is or would be relevant, or causing or permitting that, unless you show you had no intention of concealing from the investigator facts the document discloses

The CMA may impose a penalty where it considers you have, without reasonable excuse, failed to comply with s.25B or a requirement under provisions including s.26. It cannot do so for an act for which you have been found guilty of an offence under ss.42 to 44. In the other direction, you are not guilty of an offence under s.43 or s.44 for an act for which the CMA has proceeded against you under s.40ZE(1).

Give accurate information

A false statement in response to a formal request is usually an offence.

  • Under the Data Protection Act 2018 s.144, it is an offence to make a statement in response to an information notice that you know to be false in a material respect, or recklessly to make one.
  • Under the Online Safety Act 2023, a person given an information notice has a duty to ensure the information provided is accurate in all material respects. Knowingly or recklessly providing information that is false in a material respect in response to an information notice is an offence under s.109, where the notice relates to, and is given to the provider of, a user-to-user, search or provider-pornography service.
  • Under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 s.33, it is an offence to make a statement you know to be false, or recklessly to make one that is false, in purported compliance with a requirement to furnish information.
  • Under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s.177(4), knowingly or recklessly providing information that is false or misleading in a material particular in purported compliance with a Part XI requirement is an offence.

Failing to comply has consequences that include the following.

  • The Commission may give a penalty notice where it is satisfied you have failed to comply with an information notice. The maximum is £17,500,000 or, for an undertaking, 4% of total annual worldwide turnover in the preceding financial year if higher.
  • A CMA penalty for failing to comply with s.25B or a requirement under provisions including s.26 may be a fixed amount, a daily rate or both. On a person who is not an undertaking it must not exceed £30,000 as a fixed amount or £15,000 per day. On an undertaking it must not exceed 1% of turnover as a fixed amount or, for each day, 5% of daily turnover. A penalty for destroying or falsifying a document the CMA required you to produce, or for giving the CMA information that is false or misleading in a material particular, without reasonable excuse, must be a fixed amount (s.40ZE(1)(c) to (e)).
  • A consumer law enforcer that considers you have, without reasonable excuse, failed to comply with a paragraph 14 notice may apply to the court. If the court finds that failure, it may order a monetary penalty of up to £30,000 or, if higher, 1% of turnover as a fixed amount, or £15,000 or, if higher, 5% of daily turnover per day.
  • Where the CMA gave the paragraph 14 notice and has reasonable grounds to believe you have failed to comply, it may give you a provisional enforcement notice inviting representations. If it is then satisfied of the failure, it may by final enforcement notice impose a penalty within the limits in paragraph 16C, which are the same as the court's, only if the failure is without reasonable excuse, or give directions to secure compliance. You may appeal to the High Court (the Outer House of the Court of Session in Scotland) within 28 days beginning with the day the notice was given to you, and the court may extend that period.
  • Under the Online Safety Act 2023 s.109, failing to comply with a requirement of an information notice is an offence where the notice relates to, and is given to the provider of, a user-to-user, search or provider-pornography service. It is a defence that it was not reasonably practicable to comply at the time required and you have since taken all reasonable steps.

Penalties on conviction depend on the Act and the nation.

  • Data Protection Act 2018 ss.144 and 148: a fine and no imprisonment. The summary fine is up to the statutory maximum in Scotland and Northern Ireland, with no cap in the Act in England and Wales.
  • Online Safety Act 2023: failing to comply carries a fine only. False, encrypted, suppressed, destroyed or altered information carries imprisonment, a fine or both: on summary conviction up to the general limit in a magistrates' court in England and Wales, 12 months in Scotland and 6 months in Northern Ireland, and on indictment up to 2 years. The summary fine is unlimited in England and Wales and up to the statutory maximum elsewhere.
  • Competition Act 1998 ss.43 and 44 and Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s.177(3) and (4): up to 2 years, a fine or both on indictment, and a summary fine that is unlimited in England and Wales for offences committed on or after 12 March 2015 and up to the statutory maximum in Scotland and Northern Ireland. The s.177 offences also carry imprisonment on summary conviction: up to the general limit in a magistrates' court in England and Wales for offences committed on or after 2 May 2022 (6 months for earlier offences), and up to 6 months in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
  • Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 s.33(1)(e) (contravening an inspector's requirement) and (k) (false statements): up to the general limit in a magistrates' court or an unlimited fine, or both, in England and Wales on summary conviction, and up to 12 months or a fine up to £20,000, or both, in Scotland. On indictment, up to 2 years, a fine or both.

In England and Wales, a fine for an offence that was punishable on summary conviction by a fine of £5,000 or more on 12 March 2015 is unlimited for offences committed on or after that date, which makes the summary fines for the Competition Act and Financial Services and Markets Act offences unlimited. Earlier offences keep the old cap. The statutory maximum on summary conviction is £10,000 in Scotland and £5,000 in Northern Ireland, or the sum an order substitutes.

Privilege and incriminating answers

Most of these statutes protect legally privileged communications, and each sets its own scope.

  • A Commission notice does not require disclosure, to the extent that disclosure would result in it, of a communication between a professional legal adviser and client, or someone acting for the client, made in connection with giving legal advice about obligations, liabilities or rights under data protection legislation. Nor does it require disclosure of a communication between the adviser and client, or between either of them and another person, made in connection with or in contemplation of proceedings under or arising out of that legislation and for the purposes of those proceedings.
  • Under the Competition Act 1998 s.30, you cannot be required under that Part to produce or disclose a privileged communication: one between a professional legal adviser and client, or made in connection with or in contemplation of legal proceedings and for their purposes, that would be protected in the High Court on grounds of legal professional privilege (in Scotland, the Court of Session and confidentiality of communications).
  • A consumer law notice under paragraph 14 does not require information or documents you would be entitled to refuse to provide in High Court proceedings on grounds of legal professional privilege, or in Scotland Court of Session proceedings on grounds of confidentiality of communications.
  • The Online Safety Act s.100 power does not include power to require information for which a claim to legal professional privilege, or in Scotland confidentiality of communications, could be maintained in legal proceedings, or processing of personal data that would contravene data protection legislation, taking the duty the notice imposes into account when deciding that.
  • The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 s.20 does not compel production of a document you would be entitled to withhold on grounds of legal professional privilege.
  • Under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 s.413, you may not be required to produce, disclose or permit the inspection of protected items, which are legally privileged communications and items enclosed with or referred to in them. An item held to further a criminal purpose is not protected.

Protection against incriminating yourself varies. These are examples.

  • A Commission notice does not require information or documents if providing them would, by revealing evidence of an offence, expose you to proceedings for that offence. The protection does not cover offences under the Data Protection Act 2018 or the false-statement offences listed in s.143(7). For a notice to an Article 27 representative, exposure of the controller or processor counts. A statement you make in response may not be used against you on a prosecution for an offence under the Act, other than s.144, unless you give inconsistent evidence and evidence or a question about the statement is brought by or for you.
  • For information you provide in response to a consumer law notice under paragraph 14, including in a document you create, the prosecution in criminal proceedings against you may not adduce evidence or ask a question relating to it. That does not apply if you do so yourself, or in proceedings for obstruction or for false statements under s.5 of the Perjury Act 1911 or its equivalents in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
  • Under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 s.20(7), no answer you give in pursuance of a s.20(2)(j) requirement is admissible in evidence against you or your spouse or civil partner in any proceedings.
  • CMA guidance says the CMA cannot force a business to give answers that would require an admission that it has infringed the law, though it can ask about existing documents or facts. It says anyone required to provide information should seek independent legal advice if in any doubt about the privilege or how it may apply.

Take legal advice before withholding anything on grounds of privilege or self-incrimination, because the protection depends on the statute behind the notice.

Know who can see what you provide

Current and former members, staff and agents of the Commission must not disclose non-public information obtained for its functions that relates to an identifiable individual or business, unless they have lawful authority, for example consent, necessity for the Commission's functions, the public interest or proceedings. A knowing or reckless breach is an offence under s.132(3).

Under the Enterprise Act 2002 s.237, specified information relating to an individual's affairs or an undertaking's business must not be disclosed during the individual's lifetime or while the undertaking exists, unless Part 9 of that Act permits it or another power or duty to disclose applies. That information includes information that comes to a public authority, such as the CMA, in connection with its functions under the Competition Act 1998 or the consumer laws listed in Schedule 14 to that Act, which include Chapters 3 and 4 of Part 3 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. Information already made public lawfully is not restricted. Nothing in that Part authorises disclosure that contravenes data protection legislation.

Other regulators have their own disclosure rules and publication powers.

Ask for clarification or more time, or challenge the notice

If the letter is unclear on scope or the deadline looks unachievable, write to the regulator before the deadline and give reasons. CMA guidance says a recipient who thinks it cannot meet the deadline should tell the CMA as soon as possible and give reasons when asking for an extension, that the CMA considers the reasons and the need to minimise delay, and that queries about scope or time should be raised with the case team as soon as possible.

CMA guidance says a recipient with a complaint about the deadline should raise it as soon as possible with the senior responsible officer and, if it is unresolved, may refer the matter to the Procedural Officer.

A statutory appeal exists where the statute gives one. A person given a Commission information notice may appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) under the Data Protection Act 2018 s.162. The notice of appeal must be received within 28 days of the date notice of the decision was sent, unless the Tribunal extends the time. The Tribunal Rules set no different time for information notices. Take legal advice on any other notice, because whether it can be appealed depends on its statute.

Official guidance