Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Tax & Finance

Prepare for an HMRC VAT compliance check

HMRC can start a VAT check by information notice, visit or call. A taxable person must keep VAT records and produce what a notice reasonably requires. Failing to comply can bring penalties. An inaccurate return can bring a penalty that telling HMRC early reduces. Most decisions can be appealed, usually within 30 days.

UK-wide

How a VAT compliance check starts

Most of HMRC's information and inspection powers for VAT are in Schedule 36 to the Finance Act 2008. A compliance check is how HMRC checks your tax position.

HMRC says its VAT officers can visit your business to inspect your VAT records, and that it also calls about VAT. It says it may ask for information, documents, an optional meeting or a visit, and that some checks are by phone, in which case you can ask it to write instead.

HMRC says you cannot ignore an information notice or an inspection notice. It asks you to keep sending returns and making payments during the check if they are due.

HMRC says you have the right to be represented and can appoint anyone to act for you, but you must still take reasonable care over what your adviser sends HMRC.

What HMRC can require you to provide

HMRC may give you a written information notice requiring you to provide information or produce a document if it is reasonably required to check your VAT position.

You must comply as the notice reasonably specifies, within its period, at its time, and by its means and in its form. For documents, the place is one you agree with HMRC or one HMRC reasonably specifies, which cannot be a place used solely as a dwelling.

You may produce a copy unless the notice requires the original or HMRC later asks you in writing for it. You must then produce the original within the period HMRC reasonably requests.

An information notice does not require you to:

  • produce a document that is not in your possession or power
  • produce a document that wholly originates more than 6 years before the date of the notice, unless an authorised officer of HMRC gives the notice or agrees to it
  • provide information that relates to the conduct of a pending appeal about tax, or produce the part of a document containing it
  • provide privileged information or produce a privileged document
  • provide journalistic material, or information in it
  • provide personal records, such as medical records, though HMRC may ask for them with the personal information removed

A notice also does not require a tax adviser to provide information about communications between the adviser and a client made to give or get advice about the client's tax affairs. That protection does not cover information explaining a document the adviser, as tax accountant, helped a client prepare for HMRC.

Notices to third parties

HMRC may not give a third party notice, for example to a supplier or software provider, without either:

  • your agreement
  • the approval of the tribunal

HMRC must copy the notice to you unless the tribunal disapplies that requirement.

Statutory records are the information and documents you are required to keep and preserve under the Taxes Acts or another enactment relating to a tax. They stop being statutory records when the period for which you must preserve them has expired.

The need for agreement or approval does not apply to a notice that refers only to statutory records relating to the supply of goods or services, or the importation of goods, in the course of a business.

HMRC may also give a financial institution, such as a bank, a notice about you without your agreement or the tribunal's approval, if an authorised officer gives or agrees to it. The notice must name you, and the information must be reasonably required to check your tax position and, in the officer's reasonable opinion, not onerous for the institution to provide. HMRC must give you a copy and a summary of its reasons. The tribunal can disapply the naming requirement and the copy and reasons requirement.

Appealing an information notice

You may appeal against an information notice or any requirement in it. Give written notice of appeal, stating your grounds, to the HMRC officer who gave the notice before the end of 30 days beginning with the date the notice is given. If you and HMRC do not settle it, you can ask the tribunal to decide it. The tribunal can confirm, vary or set aside the notice or requirement, and its decision is final.

You cannot appeal:

  • against a requirement to provide information or documents that form part of your statutory records
  • where the tribunal approved the giving of the notice
  • against a notice that refers only to statutory records relating to the supply of goods or services, or the importation of goods, in the course of a business

The appeal follows the Taxes Management Act 1970 process for an income tax assessment appeal. HMRC may offer a review, which you have 30 days beginning with the date of the offer document to accept. If you do not accept, HMRC's view is treated as a written settlement unless you notify the appeal to the tribunal within those 30 days. After that, you need the tribunal's permission.

What HMRC can inspect and when

An HMRC officer may enter your business premises and inspect the premises, business assets and business documents on them, if the inspection is reasonably required to check your tax position. Premises include any building, land and means of transport. On this inspection, business documents are limited to documents that relate to the carrying on of a business and form part of any person's statutory records.

HMRC may also enter premises it has reason to believe are used in connection with the supply of goods under taxable supplies, if it has reason to believe that goods to be supplied, or documents relating to them, are on the premises. It may inspect the premises, the goods and documents that appear to relate to the supply. The limit to statutory records does not apply to this power. The limits on what a notice can require also apply to documents HMRC inspects.

Neither power includes the right to enter or inspect any part of the premises used solely as a dwelling.

HMRC may carry out these inspections only:

  • at a time the occupier agrees
  • at any reasonable time, if the occupier has had at least 7 days' notice of the time of the inspection, in writing or otherwise
  • at any reasonable time, if an authorised officer of HMRC carries out the inspection or agrees to it, when 7 days' notice is not needed but written notice is

That written notice must state the possible consequences of obstructing the officer.

HMRC says it normally visits with your agreement and will usually give at least 7 days' notice, and that you can ask it to delay a visit. It says an unannounced inspection comes with identification, a notice of inspection authorised by a senior officer and a factsheet, and that it will not delay the inspection while you seek advice. It says it will normally only visit your home if you run your business from there.

Tribunal approval

HMRC may ask the tribunal to approve an inspection. The tribunal may not approve unless an authorised officer applies or agrees and the tribunal is satisfied the inspection is justified. Its decision is final.

Copies and removal of documents

HMRC may take copies of, or extracts from, any document produced to it or inspected by it. It may remove a document at a reasonable time and keep it for a reasonable period, if it appears necessary. On request, you may have a free receipt and, where you reasonably require the document, a free copy.

Keep the records HMRC asks to see

Every taxable person must keep the records HMRC requires by regulations. The VAT Regulations 1995 require you to keep, for the purpose of accounting for VAT, records that include:

  • business and accounting records
  • the VAT account
  • copies of all VAT invoices issued and all VAT invoices received
  • documentation relating to importations and exportations

HMRC may add to the list, for a described trade or business or for a scheme, by a published notice.

HMRC says its view of business records is wide and includes bank statements, cash books, till rolls and relevant business correspondence. It says it normally specifies the records it wants ahead of a visit, and those records must be available.

How long to keep them

The law lets HMRC require VAT records to be preserved for a period not exceeding 6 years, as it specifies in writing, and different periods may be specified for different cases. You may preserve the records, or the information in them, in any form and by any means, subject to any digital record rules that apply to you and to any conditions or exceptions HMRC specifies in writing.

HMRC says you generally must keep all your business records for VAT for at least 6 years, and records used for other taxes may need to be kept longer. It says it may allow a shorter period for some records if the 6-year rule causes serious storage problems or undue expense. It says you must still keep VAT records for the required period after you deregister. GOV.UK says to start keeping records when you register, and to keep them for 10 years if you use the VAT One Stop Shop scheme or used the VAT Mini One Stop Shop scheme.

Penalties for not complying

Information notices and inspections

You are liable to a £300 penalty if you fail to comply with an information notice, or deliberately obstruct an officer during an inspection the tribunal has approved. If the failure or obstruction continues after HMRC imposes the penalty, you are liable to further penalties of up to £60 for each subsequent day.

You avoid these penalties for missing a deadline if you act within any further time HMRC has allowed. You also avoid them if you satisfy HMRC or, on appeal, the tribunal that you had a reasonable excuse. HMRC gives serious illness, a close bereavement and losing documents in a fire or flood as examples. Under Schedule 36:

  • not having enough money is not a reasonable excuse unless events outside your control caused it
  • relying on another person is not a reasonable excuse unless you took reasonable care to avoid the failure
  • if your excuse ended, you are treated as still having it only if you remedied the failure without unreasonable delay after it ended

If you give inaccurate information, or produce a document containing an inaccuracy, in complying with a notice, you are liable to a penalty of up to £3,000 for each inaccuracy. This applies only if one of these is true:

  • the inaccuracy is careless or deliberate
  • you knew of it when you gave the information or document and did not tell HMRC then
  • you discovered it later and did not take reasonable steps to tell HMRC

An inaccuracy is careless if it is due to a failure to take reasonable care.

If the failure continues after the £300 penalty is imposed and HMRC believes the tax you have paid or are likely to pay is significantly less than it would otherwise have been, HMRC may apply to the Upper Tribunal within 12 months for an additional penalty.

Concealing or destroying documents

You must not conceal, destroy or dispose of a document, or arrange for that, in either of these cases:

  • the document is the subject of an information notice addressed to you
  • HMRC has told you the document is, or is likely to be, the subject of an information notice

Where a notice requires the document, the duty ends once you have produced the document to HMRC, unless HMRC has notified you in writing that it must stay available for inspection. If you produced a copy, it ends 6 months after you did so, unless HMRC asked for the original within that time.

Where HMRC has only told you a notice is likely, the duty ends once at least 6 months have passed since HMRC last told you. If HMRC gives you a notice requiring the document in that time, the duty under a notice applies instead.

Breaching the duty is a failure to comply, so you are liable to the £300 penalty, and to daily penalties if the failure continues. It is also a criminal offence if the tribunal approved the notice requiring you to produce the document. That offence ends in the same way as the duty under a notice.

It is a separate offence if HMRC told you in writing that the document is, or is likely to be, the subject of a notice addressed to you and that it intends to seek the tribunal's approval. That offence does not apply if you act at least 6 months after HMRC last told you, or after a notice requiring the document has been given.

On conviction on indictment, the maximum is imprisonment for up to 2 years, a fine, or both. The offence can also be prosecuted on summary conviction. HMRC says it may carry out a criminal investigation with a view to prosecution if you deliberately do something wrong. You are not liable to a Schedule 36 penalty for anything for which you have been convicted of an offence.

Failing to keep or preserve VAT records

If you fail to preserve records HMRC requires you to preserve, you are liable to a £500 penalty. If you fail to keep the records the law requires, the penalty is a daily rate for each day the failure continues, up to a maximum of 100 days, or £50 if that is greater. The rate is £5, £10 or £15 depending on your failures to comply with that requirement in the previous 2 years.

You avoid these penalties if you satisfy HMRC or, on appeal, the tribunal that you had a reasonable excuse. Conduct that results in a conviction, a penalty under Schedule 24 to the Finance Act 2007 or a penalty under section 60 or 63 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 (the VAT Act), or a penalty point or penalty under the late submission rules, does not also give rise to this penalty.

What a check can find

Extra VAT assessed

HMRC may assess the VAT due from you, to the best of its judgment, where:

  • you have failed to make returns required under the VAT Act
  • you have failed to keep documents and afford the facilities necessary to verify returns
  • it appears to HMRC that returns are incomplete or incorrect

HMRC may separately assess an amount that has been repaid, refunded or credited to you and ought not to have been, or would not have been had the facts been known.

An assessment must be made within the time limits in section 77 of the VAT Act. It must not be made more than 4 years after the end of the accounting period, or more than 20 years after it where the loss of VAT was brought about deliberately by you or by another person acting on your behalf. A deliberate inaccuracy in a document counts, and other cases also carry a 20-year limit.

An assessment also must not be made after the later of 2 years after the end of the accounting period and one year after evidence of facts that justify it, in HMRC's opinion, comes to its knowledge.

HMRC says it cannot use contract settlements for any VAT or VAT penalties.

Penalty for an inaccurate return or document

A penalty under Schedule 24 to the Finance Act 2007 is payable where you give HMRC a VAT return or other document it is likely to rely on without further inquiry, and both of these are true:

  • the document contains an inaccuracy that amounts to, or leads to, an understatement of a liability to tax, a false or inflated loss, or a false or inflated claim to repayment of tax
  • the inaccuracy was careless or deliberate on your part when you gave the document

For VAT, understating liability includes overstating entitlement to a VAT credit. A penalty is payable for each inaccuracy.

An inaccuracy that was neither careless nor deliberate when you gave the document is treated as careless if you discovered it later and did not take reasonable steps to inform HMRC.

The standard penalty is 30% of the potential lost revenue for a careless inaccuracy, 70% for a deliberate inaccuracy you do not conceal, and 100% for a deliberate inaccuracy you conceal, for example by submitting false evidence to support an inaccurate figure. The potential lost revenue is the additional tax due or payable as a result of correcting the inaccuracy, including amounts wrongly repaid.

Telling HMRC about errors early

HMRC must reduce the standard percentage to one that reflects the quality of your disclosure, down to a minimum that is lower if the disclosure is unprompted. For a careless inaccuracy the minimum is 15% if prompted and 0% if unprompted. HMRC says helping with the check will reduce the amount of any penalty. Disclosure means telling HMRC, giving it reasonable help to quantify the inaccuracy and allowing it access to records.

A disclosure is unprompted if you make it when you have no reason to believe HMRC has discovered or is about to discover the inaccuracy. Otherwise it is prompted.

HMRC says that once it has started a check, a disclosure can be unprompted only exceptionally, if it is about an unrelated inaccuracy you had no reason to believe HMRC could have found in the check.

HMRC says correcting an error through the VAT account is not a disclosure for penalty purposes. For a careless error corrected that way, you will not get the maximum reduction unless you also tell HMRC separately in writing. The law lets you correct errors on your VAT account only where all of these apply:

  • each error is in a return for a VAT period that ended within the last 4 years
  • the net difference between the under-declarations and over-declarations you find in a VAT period is no more than £50,000
  • where the Box 6 total on your return for the period in which you find the errors is under £5,000,000, that net difference is £10,000 or less, or no more than 1% of that Box 6 total

HMRC says deliberate errors must always be reported to it separately.

Reductions and suspension

HMRC may reduce a Schedule 24 penalty because of special circumstances, which do not include ability to pay. HMRC may suspend all or part of a penalty for a careless inaccuracy for up to 2 years by written notice, on conditions that help you avoid further careless inaccuracies. If you satisfy HMRC at the end of the period that you met the conditions, the suspended penalty is cancelled. If not, it becomes payable. If you become liable to another inaccuracy penalty during the suspension period, the suspended penalty becomes payable.

You are not liable for a careless inaccuracy by your agent if you satisfy HMRC that you took reasonable care to avoid it.

Disagree with a decision

VAT assessments and VAT penalties

You can appeal to the tribunal against a VAT assessment under section 73(1) or (2) for a period for which you made a return, and against its amount. You can also appeal against liability to a penalty under sections 60 to 69B of the VAT Act.

HMRC must offer a review of a decision that can be appealed, by notice given when it notifies you of the decision. You have 30 days from the date of the document containing the offer to accept it, and you cannot accept if you have already appealed to the tribunal.

You must appeal to the tribunal before the end of 30 days beginning with the date of the document notifying the decision. After a review, you may not appeal until the conclusion date and must appeal within 30 days beginning with it. A late appeal needs the tribunal's permission.

The tribunal will hear an appeal about an assessment or a penalty only if the VAT HMRC has determined to be payable has been paid or deposited. That does not apply if HMRC or the tribunal is satisfied that paying it would cause you hardship.

Schedule 24 penalties

You may appeal against a decision that a Schedule 24 penalty is payable, its amount, a decision not to suspend it, or the conditions of a suspension. For VAT, it follows the review offer and tribunal route. You need not pay the penalty before the appeal is determined. The penalty is otherwise payable within 30 days beginning with the day the notification is issued.

Schedule 36 penalties

You may appeal against a Schedule 36 penalty by written notice to HMRC, stating your grounds, within 30 days beginning with the date of the notification. On an appeal against whether the penalty is payable, the tribunal may confirm or cancel the decision. On an appeal against the amount, it may confirm it or substitute another amount HMRC had power to set. You must pay within 30 days beginning with the notification date or, if you appeal, the date the appeal is determined or withdrawn.

Official guidance