Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Tax & Finance

Handle an FCA investigation or information requirement

The FCA can require an authorised firm to provide information by written notice, or appoint investigators. Protected legal communications can be withheld. Destroying documents once you know or suspect an investigation is under way or likely, or giving false information, can be an offence. Ignoring a requirement risks contempt or a search warrant.

Professional & Financial Services UK-wide

The FCA can require information from an authorised firm by written notice, or through investigators it appoints. A written notice under section 165 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) requires specified information or documents. Investigators appointed under section 167 or 168 can require more, including attendance at an interview. The powers sit in Part XI of FSMA and apply across the UK. Warrants, the court that deals with a failure to comply, and the criminal penalties differ by nation.

Written information requirements

The FCA can give an authorised person a notice in writing requiring it to provide specified information or documents, or information or documents of a specified description. A person who has ceased to be authorised can still be required. The power also reaches a person connected with an authorised person, such as a member of its group or a controller.

You must provide the information or produce the documents before the end of the reasonable period the notice specifies, and at the place it specifies. The Act sets no number of days. The notice itself fixes the period.

The FCA can also authorise an officer, who can be a member of its staff or an agent, to make the same requirement. The officer needs written authorisation, and you must provide the information or documents without delay. The reasonable period applies to written notices only.

Both routes are limited to information and documents reasonably required in connection with the FCA's functions under FSMA. The FCA can reasonably require the information in a particular form. It can also require information to be verified, and documents to be authenticated, in any manner it reasonably requires.

The FCA can also, by notice in writing, require the firm to provide a report by a skilled person, or appoint one itself, on a matter about which it has required, or could require, information.

Investigations and the notice of appointment

The FCA appoints investigators for a general investigation or for a particular case:

  • A general investigation under section 167, where it appears to the FCA that there is good reason. The investigation can cover the nature, conduct or state of a firm's business, a particular aspect of it, or its ownership or control. No suspected breach is needed.
  • An investigation in a particular case under section 168, where there are circumstances suggesting a listed breach or offence.

Circumstances that can lead to a section 168 investigation include:

  • a contravention of an FCA rule
  • an individual who may not be fit and proper
  • a breach of the general prohibition
  • a contravention of section 20 in relation to a credit-related regulated activity
  • an offence under section 177 itself

A section 167 investigator who thinks it necessary can also investigate the business of a member of the firm's group, or of a partnership of which the firm is a member. The investigator must give that person written notice of the decision. For a person who has ceased to be authorised, a section 167 investigation covers only business carried on, or ownership or control, while the person was authorised.

The FCA must give the person under investigation written notice of the appointment. The notice must state the provisions under which, and as a result of which, the investigator was appointed, and the reason for the appointment. The Act sets no time limit for the notice. The FCA says it sends the notice, if appropriate, as quickly as practicable.

The requirement to give notice has exceptions:

  • No notice is needed where the investigator is appointed as a result of section 168(2), which covers listed offences, market abuse and breaches such as the general prohibition and section 20 in relation to a credit-related regulated activity.
  • No notice is needed where the investigator is appointed as a result of section 168(1), (4) or (4B) and the FCA believes that notice would be likely to result in the investigation being frustrated.

A section 167 investigation has no exception. The notice must be given. If the scope or conduct of an investigation changes and, in the FCA's opinion, the person under investigation is likely to be significantly prejudiced by not being made aware of it, the FCA must give that person written notice of the change. Both exceptions apply to that notice as well.

What investigators can require

Each type of investigator has its own powers, and each power has its own test.

Investigators' powers

Investigation Who can be required What can be required Test
General investigation under section 167 (section 171) The person under investigation and persons connected with it, for questions and information. Any person, for documents Attend and answer questions, or otherwise provide information. Produce specified documents Only so far as the investigator reasonably considers the question, information or document relevant to the purposes of the investigation
Particular case under section 168(1), (4) or (4B) (section 172) The same persons as for a section 167 investigation, and also a person who is neither the person under investigation nor connected with it All the section 171 powers. For a person who is neither the person under investigation nor connected with it, attend and answer questions or otherwise provide information For the section 171 powers, the same relevance test. For a person who is neither the person under investigation nor connected with it, only if the investigator is satisfied the requirement is necessary or expedient for the purposes of the investigation
Particular case under section 168(2) (section 173) Any person the investigator considers is or may be able to give information which is or may be relevant to the investigation Attend and answer questions, provide information, produce documents that appear to relate to a relevant matter, and give all the assistance the person is reasonably able to give The investigator considers the person is or may be able to give information which is or may be relevant

For the section 171 and 172 powers, a person is connected with the person under investigation if they are or have at any relevant time been a member of its group, a controller, a partnership of which it is a member, or a person listed in Part I or II of Schedule 15. Where the person under investigation is an FCA investment firm or a relevant parent undertaking of one, questions and information can also be required from a person who provides or has provided services to the firm or the parent, in the cases the Act lists.

Under sections 171 and 172, the time and place to attend, and the documents to produce, are specified in a notice in writing.

What you can withhold or must still give

A person may not be required under FSMA to produce, disclose or permit the inspection of protected items. This covers requirements under any part of the Act, not only Part XI. Protected items are:

  • communications between a professional legal adviser and the client, or a person representing the client, made in connection with giving legal advice to the client or in connection with, or in contemplation of, legal proceedings and for the purposes of those proceedings
  • communications between the adviser, the client or a person representing the client and any other person, made in connection with, or in contemplation of, legal proceedings and for the purposes of those proceedings
  • items enclosed with or referred to in such communications that meet the same tests and are in the possession of a person entitled to possession of them

A communication or item is not a protected item if it is held with the intention of furthering a criminal purpose. A lawyer can still be required to give the name and address of a client.

No person may be required under Part XI to disclose information or produce a document that they owe an obligation of confidence about by carrying on the business of banking, unless one of these applies:

  • the person required is the person under investigation or a member of its group
  • the person to whom the confidence is owed is the person under investigation or a member of its group
  • the person to whom the confidence is owed consents to the disclosure or production
  • the investigating authority has specifically authorised the requirement for that information or document

If a document is held by a third person, the power to require it can be used on that third person. Producing a document does not affect any lien claimed on it. The person who receives a document can take copies or extracts, and can require the person producing it, or a relevant person, to explain it. A relevant person is anyone who:

  • has been, is, or is proposed to be a director or controller of the person producing it
  • has been or is that person's auditor or employee
  • has been or is an actuary, accountant or lawyer that person appointed or instructed

A produced document can be kept for as long as the recipient considers it necessary to keep the document itself, rather than copies, for the purposes for which it was requested. If the recipient has reasonable grounds for believing the document may have to be produced for legal proceedings and might otherwise be unavailable for them, it can be kept until the proceedings conclude. A person who fails to produce a document can be required to state, to the best of their knowledge and belief, where it is.

How your statements can be used

A statement made to an investigator in compliance with a requirement under section 171, 172, 173 or 175 is admissible in evidence in any proceedings, as long as it also meets the ordinary rules on admissibility of evidence.

Use of the statement is limited. In criminal proceedings where you are charged with an offence, and in proceedings for action under section 123 against a person who may have contravened Article 14 or 15 of the market abuse regulation, the prosecution or the FCA cannot adduce evidence about the statement or ask a question about it, unless you adduce evidence or ask a question about it first.

The limit does not apply to proceedings for an offence under any of these provisions:

  • section 177(4) of FSMA
  • section 398 of FSMA
  • section 5 of the Perjury Act 1911
  • section 44(2) of the Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995
  • Article 10 of the Perjury (Northern Ireland) Order 1979

The limit does not cover replies to a section 165 notice or to an officer, which are not requirements imposed by an investigator.

Offences and penalties

A person who knows or suspects that an investigation under Part XI is being or is likely to be conducted commits an offence if they falsify, conceal, destroy or otherwise dispose of a document that they know or suspect is or would be relevant to it. Causing or permitting any of those acts is also an offence. The offence can arise before investigators are appointed. A person is not guilty if they show that they had no intention of concealing facts disclosed by the documents from the investigator.

A person who, in purported compliance with a requirement under Part XI, provides information that they know to be false or misleading in a material particular commits an offence. So does a person who recklessly provides information that is false or misleading in a material particular. The offence applies to replies to a section 165 notice as well as to answers given to investigators.

Intentionally obstructing the exercise of rights conferred by a warrant under section 176 is a separate offence. It is punishable on summary conviction only.

The document and false information offences carry up to two years' imprisonment or a fine, or both, on conviction on indictment. On summary conviction the penalties differ by nation.

Penalties on summary conviction

Nation Fine for the document and false information offences Imprisonment for those offences Obstructing a warrant
England and Wales Unlimited, for offences committed on or after 12 March 2015. The statutory maximum applies to earlier offences Up to 12 months, for offences committed on or after 2 May 2022. The Act's six months applies to earlier offences An unlimited fine, up to three months' imprisonment, or both
Scotland Up to £10,000 Up to 12 months, where the case first called in court on or after 10 December 2007 A fine of up to £5,000 (level 5), up to three months' imprisonment, or both
Northern Ireland Up to the statutory maximum under the Fines and Penalties (Northern Ireland) Order 1984 Up to six months A fine of up to level 5 on the standard scale, up to three months' imprisonment, or both

If you do not comply

If a person fails to comply with a requirement imposed under Part XI, the person who imposed it can certify the failure in writing to the High Court. If the court is satisfied that the person failed without reasonable excuse, it can deal with them as if they were in contempt. For a company, the court can deal with any director or other officer in the same way. For a limited liability partnership, an officer means a member.

A justice of the peace can issue a warrant to enter premises, if satisfied on information on oath, given by or on behalf of the FCA, an investigator or the Secretary of State, that there are reasonable grounds for believing one of these sets of conditions is met:

  • A person on whom an information requirement has been imposed, which includes a section 165 notice, has failed wholly or in part to comply, and documents or information that were required are on the premises.
  • The premises are those of an authorised person, an appointed representative or another person the section lists. Documents or information on which a requirement could be imposed are there. A requirement would not be complied with, or the documents or information would be removed, tampered with or destroyed.
  • An offence mentioned in section 168 that carries at least two years' imprisonment on indictment has been or is being committed. Documents or information relevant to it are on the premises. A requirement could be imposed, and it would not be complied with, or the documents or information would be removed, tampered with or destroyed.

A warrant authorises a constable to:

  • enter and search the premises
  • take possession of relevant documents or information, or take other steps needed to preserve them
  • take copies or extracts
  • require anyone on the premises to explain a document or say where it can be found
  • use reasonable force

People the warrant authorises to accompany the constable can use these powers, but only in the constable's company and under their supervision.

In England and Wales, sections 15(5) to (8) and 16(3) to (12) of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 govern how the warrant is executed and add safeguards. In Northern Ireland, Articles 17(5) to (8) and 18(3) to (12) of the Police and Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1989 do the same.

Where an investigation can lead

If the FCA considers that an authorised person has contravened a relevant requirement, it can impose a penalty of an amount it considers appropriate. Before it does, it must give the person a warning notice, and a warning notice about a penalty must state the amount.

A warning notice must be in writing, state the action proposed and give reasons. It must also state whether section 394 applies and, if it does, describe its effect and say whether any secondary material exists to which the person must be allowed access under it. It must give a reasonable period for representations, which may not be less than 14 days. The FCA can extend the period.

The FCA says that opening an investigation does not mean it believes misconduct has definitely occurred.

It also says that it takes into account a firm's response, including whether it self-reported, helped the FCA establish the facts and took remedial action. It says these steps may mitigate a penalty but cannot automatically lead to no sanction. It says a firm should not wait for an investigation to end before acting in a way it thinks is right.

Official guidance