Environmental regulators in England and Wales can serve notices that require action, and can impose civil penalties. The law a notice is served under decides who hears an appeal, how long you have and whether the appeal pauses the notice. Most notices to permit holders come under the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016 (the permitting regulations). The regulator is the Environment Agency, Natural Resources Wales (NRW) or the local authority, depending on the facility.
Which notice or penalty you have
| Notice or penalty | Appeal to | Time limit | Does the appeal pause the notice? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enforcement notice (permitting regulations) | Secretary of State (Welsh Ministers in Wales). No appeal against a notice that implements a direction of the Secretary of State (or the Welsh Ministers) | Not later than 2 months after the date of the notice. A late appeal may be allowed in a particular case | No (an appeal against a revocation notice does pause that notice) |
| Suspension notice (permitting regulations) | Secretary of State (Welsh Ministers in Wales). No appeal to the extent a local authority served the notice for non-payment of a subsistence charge under its charging scheme, or against a notice that implements a direction of the Secretary of State (or the Welsh Ministers) | Not later than 2 months after the date of the notice. A late appeal may be allowed in a particular case | No (an appeal against a revocation notice does pause that notice) |
| Groundwater prohibition notice (permitting regulations) | Secretary of State (Welsh Ministers in Wales). No appeal against a notice that implements a direction of the Secretary of State (or the Welsh Ministers) | Not later than 21 days after the date of the notice. A late appeal may be allowed in a particular case | No (an appeal against a revocation notice does pause that notice) |
| Revocation notice (permitting regulations) | Secretary of State (Welsh Ministers in Wales). No appeal to the extent a local authority served the notice for non-payment of a subsistence charge under its charging scheme, or against a notice that implements a direction of the Secretary of State (or the Welsh Ministers) | Before the revocation notice takes effect | Yes, until the appeal is finally decided or withdrawn. A stand-alone water discharge revocation notice that states revocation is necessary to prevent or minimise pollution is not held back, unless the appeal authority decides on your application that excluding the hold-back was unreasonable |
| Variable monetary penalty final notice (permitting regulations, England only) | First-tier Tribunal | Received by the Tribunal within 28 days of the date the notice was sent. A late appeal must ask for more time and give the reason, and is admitted only if the Tribunal extends time | Yes, until the appeal is finally decided |
| Non-compliance penalty or enforcement cost recovery notice (permitting regulations, England only) | First-tier Tribunal | Received by the Tribunal within 28 days of the date the notice was sent. A late appeal must ask for more time and give the reason, and is admitted only if the Tribunal extends time | Yes, until the appeal is finally decided |
| Civil sanction other than a stop notice under the Environmental Civil Sanctions (England) Order 2010 (Wales Order 2010 in Wales) | First-tier Tribunal | Received by the Tribunal within 28 days of the date the notice was sent. A late appeal must ask for more time and give the reason, and is admitted only if the Tribunal extends time | Yes, until the appeal is finally decided |
| Stop notice under the Environmental Civil Sanctions (England) Order 2010 (Wales Order 2010 in Wales) | First-tier Tribunal | Received by the Tribunal within 28 days of the date the notice was sent. A late appeal must ask for more time and give the reason, and is admitted only if the Tribunal extends time | No, though the Tribunal may suspend or vary it |
| Works notice served in England (Water Resources Act 1991) | Secretary of State | Within 21 days beginning with the day the notice is served | No. Neither the Act nor the 1999 Regulations pauses it |
Comply with a notice while you appeal
An enforcement notice can be served where the regulator considers that you have contravened, are contravening or are likely to contravene a permit condition. The notice must state the matters involved, the steps to remedy the contravention or stop it happening, and the period for taking them. You must take those steps within that period. They can include steps to make the operation comply with the permit conditions and steps to remedy the effects of pollution. The regulator may withdraw the notice at any time.
For a Part A installation, a waste incineration or waste co-incineration plant or a solvent emission activity (Schedules 7, 13 and 14), the regulator may also serve a notice if it considers that an incident or accident significantly affecting the environment has occurred as the result of the operation of that facility. That notice must specify the measures needed to limit the environmental consequences and to prevent further incidents or accidents.
A suspension notice stops the permit having effect, wholly or in part. The regulator may serve one where either of these applies.
- Operating the facility involves a risk of serious pollution (or the equivalent serious risk for a flood risk activity), whether or not the way you operate breaches a permit condition.
- The way you operate contravenes a permit condition and the contravention involves a risk of pollution (or the equivalent risk for a flood risk activity).
A notice served on either of those grounds must specify the risk, the steps to remove it, any contravention and the steps to remedy it, and the period for the steps. The permit ceases to have effect to the extent the notice states. You must not carry on what it covers, and you must take the steps it requires. If the suspension stops you accepting waste, the notice may require you to display signs telling the public. The regulator may withdraw a suspension notice at any time, and must withdraw it when satisfied that the specified steps have been taken.
Where a local authority is your regulator, it may also serve a suspension notice if it considers that you have not paid a subsistence charge under its charging scheme. That notice states the reason, the sum payable and the period for payment.
Failing to comply with the requirements of an enforcement notice, suspension notice or prohibition notice is an offence. An appeal does not suspend an enforcement notice, suspension notice or prohibition notice. Keep to its steps and period while the appeal is decided.
An appeal against a revocation notice holds the notice back until the appeal is finally decided or withdrawn. That does not apply to a revocation notice for a stand-alone water discharge activity that states revocation is necessary to prevent or minimise pollution. If the appeal authority decides on your application that the regulator acted unreasonably in excluding the hold-back, and the appeal is still pending, the hold-back applies from the end of that day. You may also recover compensation from the regulator for loss caused by the exclusion.
On summary conviction, the penalty is an unlimited fine, imprisonment for up to the general limit in a magistrates' court, or both. On indictment it is a fine, imprisonment for up to 5 years, or both. For a flood risk activity the maximum prison term on indictment is 2 years. Directors and other officers are also guilty where a company's offence was committed with their consent or connivance, or is attributable to their neglect.
The regulator may also go to the High Court to secure compliance with an enforcement notice or suspension notice, whether or not it has taken other steps. It may arrange steps to remove a risk of serious pollution. It may also arrange steps to remedy pollution caused, or suspected to be caused, by an offence under regulation 38(1), (2) or (3). It must tell you what those steps are at least 5 working days before they are taken. It may recover the cost of the steps from the relevant person, which means an operator, an establishment or undertaking carrying on an exempt waste operation, or a person carrying on a water discharge activity or groundwater activity. It cannot recover costs to the extent that you show they were unnecessarily incurred. For steps to remove a risk of serious pollution, it also cannot recover costs if you show there was no such risk.
Appeal an enforcement, suspension or prohibition notice
You may appeal to the Secretary of State against an enforcement notice, suspension notice or prohibition notice served on you. Give notice of appeal not later than 2 months after the date of the notice for an enforcement notice or suspension notice. For a prohibition notice the limit is 21 days after the date of the notice. Time runs from the date of the notice, not from the day you receive it. The Secretary of State may allow a late appeal in a particular case.
There is no appeal against a revocation notice or suspension notice from a local authority to the extent it was served for non-payment of a subsistence charge under its charging scheme. There is also no appeal against a notice that implements a direction of the Secretary of State (or the Welsh Ministers) to the regulator under regulation 62(1), 63(1) or 63(6), or under regulation 31(6).
Appeal by written notice. Include a statement of your grounds, a copy of the notice and the other documents the permitting regulations list. Send copies to the regulator at the same time. Either you or the regulator can ask for a hearing before an appointed person, and the appeal authority may also decide to offer one. Otherwise the appeal is decided on written representations. The Secretary of State may quash or affirm the notice, with or without modifications.
The Planning Inspectorate says its Environment Appeals Team handles these appeals in England. It says an Inspector usually decides each one for the Secretary of State, and that there is no charge for lodging an appeal.
Civil penalties and undertakings for permitting offences in England
The Environment Agency may impose a variable monetary penalty for an offence under regulation 38 of the permitting regulations that was committed in England on or after 1 December 2023. It may do so only if satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that you committed the offence. The penalty can be any amount for an offence under regulation 38(1) to (4). It cannot exceed the maximum summary fine for the offence in regulation 38(5). The Agency cannot impose one if it has already imposed one for the same act. It also cannot do so if it accepted an enforcement undertaking for that act, unless you have breached the undertaking.
The Agency must first serve a notice of intent. You have 28 days beginning with the day you receive it to make written representations and objections. If the notice is served by email, the date you receive it is taken to be the date the email was sent. You may offer a third party undertaking, which is action, including paying a sum of money, to benefit people affected by the offence. The Agency may accept or reject it, and must take an accepted undertaking into account. After the 28 days the Agency decides whether to impose the penalty, with or without modifications, and does so by final notice.
With a final notice, the Agency may require you to pay its costs up to the final notice. It must allow at least 28 days to pay. You are not liable for costs that you show were unnecessarily incurred. If you fail to comply with an accepted third party undertaking, the Agency may impose a non-compliance penalty of up to 100% of the cost of the remaining requirements, again with at least 28 days to pay. It may recover an unpaid penalty, non-compliance penalty or costs as a civil debt.
Once the Agency imposes a variable monetary penalty or accepts a third party undertaking, you cannot be convicted of the offence for the same act or omission. The exception is where the Agency imposed no penalty, accepted your third party undertaking and you then failed to comply with it. The Agency can then prosecute, with summary proceedings brought within 6 months beginning with the date it notified you of the failure.
You may appeal a final notice to the First-tier Tribunal on the grounds that it was based on an error of fact, is wrong in law, the amount is unreasonable, or it is unreasonable for any other reason. The appeal suspends the final notice until it is finally decided. You may also appeal a non-compliance penalty or an enforcement cost recovery notice, which is likewise suspended pending the appeal. The Tribunal may withdraw, confirm or vary the penalty, take any step the Agency could have taken, or send the decision back to the Agency.
The Agency may also accept a written enforcement undertaking where it has reasonable grounds to suspect an offence under regulation 38(1), 38(2), 38(4)(a) or 38(5)(a), or under regulation 38(6) as it relates to them. The facility must be a regulated or exempt facility operated in England. Failing to comply with an enforcement, suspension or prohibition notice (regulation 38(3)) is not one of those offences.
An undertaking must specify action to stop the offence continuing or recurring, restore the position so far as possible, benefit those affected, or, where the harm cannot be restored, secure an equivalent benefit or improvement to the environment. It must also give the period for completing that action. Once the Agency accepts it, you cannot be convicted of that offence for that act or omission unless you have failed to comply with the undertaking or part of it. If you do fail to comply, the Agency may prosecute. Summary proceedings can be brought up to 6 months from the date the Agency notifies you of the failure. If you complied in part, that must be taken into account in any criminal sanction imposed on you.
If the Agency is satisfied that you have complied with an undertaking, it must issue a certificate to that effect. You may apply for one at any time. The Agency must decide within 14 days of the application and give written notice, and you may appeal a refusal to the First-tier Tribunal.
The Environment Agency says in its civil sanctions policy that it is more likely to accept an offer made early and proactively. It says it will not normally accept an offer made after it issues a variable monetary penalty notice of intent, or where it has decided to prosecute.
Civil sanctions for offences outside the permitting regulations
The Environmental Civil Sanctions (England) Order 2010 lets the Environment Agency and Natural England impose civil sanctions for the offences listed in its Schedule 5. That Schedule lists no offence under the permitting regulations. Stop notices, compliance notices and restoration notices are not available for permitting offences. Which sanctions apply to an offence depends on its entry in Schedule 5.
In Wales, the Environmental Civil Sanctions (Wales) Order 2010 (WSI 2010/1821) gives NRW comparable sanctions for the offences in its own Schedule 5, which lists no offence under the permitting regulations either. Appeals go to the First-tier Tribunal.
The sanctions include fixed monetary penalties, variable monetary penalties, compliance notices, restoration notices, stop notices, non-compliance penalties and enforcement undertakings. A variable monetary penalty, compliance notice or restoration notice needs the regulator to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that you committed the offence. Under the England Order, a variable monetary penalty for an offence committed before 1 December 2023 cannot exceed £250,000, and there is no such cap for later offences. The Wales Order has no £250,000 cap. Under both Orders, where the offence is triable only summarily and punishable on summary conviction by a fine, the penalty cannot exceed the maximum amount of that fine.
A fixed monetary penalty is discharged if you pay 50% within 28 days beginning with the day you receive the notice of intent. If you made written representations or objections on the notice of intent within the time limit, you may instead discharge the final notice by paying 50% within 28 days beginning with the day you receive it. Otherwise a final notice is payable within 56 days of receipt, and late payment adds 50%. If an appeal against a final notice is unsuccessful, the penalty is payable within 28 days of the decision on the appeal, and the amount increases by 50% if it is not paid within those 28 days. A non-compliance penalty can follow a failure to comply with a compliance notice, restoration notice or third party undertaking. You have at least 28 days to pay a non-compliance penalty.
A stop notice prohibits an activity until you take the specified steps. The regulator can serve one on a person who is carrying on an activity, if it reasonably believes the activity is causing, or presents a significant risk of causing, serious harm to human health or the environment, and involves or is likely to involve an offence for which the Schedule 5 table shows a stop notice is possible. It can also serve one on a person it reasonably believes is likely to carry on an activity that will have that effect and involve that offence. When you have taken the steps, apply for a completion certificate. The regulator must decide within 14 days, and the stop notice ends when the certificate is issued.
Failing to comply with a stop notice within the time limit it specifies is an offence. On summary conviction the penalty is an unlimited fine, imprisonment for up to the general limit in a magistrates' court, or both. On indictment it is up to 2 years in prison, a fine, or both.
The regulator must compensate you for loss caused by a stop notice if it withdraws or amends the notice because serving it, or a step in it, was unreasonable. It must also do so if you appeal successfully and the Tribunal finds that serving the notice was unreasonable. It must compensate you for loss caused by a refusal of a completion certificate if you appeal successfully and the Tribunal finds the refusal was unreasonable.
Appeal to the First-tier Tribunal
The First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber) hears appeals against civil sanctions under the 2010 Orders and, in England, under the permitting regulations. It does not deal with criminal offences. The Tribunal must receive your appeal within 28 days of the date the regulator sent you notice of the decision. The 28 days run from the date it was sent, not from the day you receive it. If your appeal is late, it must include a request for more time and the reason. The Tribunal must not admit it unless it extends time.
On an appeal under the 2010 Orders, other than an appeal against a stop notice, the regulator must prove any offence in issue to the criminal standard. GOV.UK says to complete form GRC1, say clearly why the regulator's decision was wrong or unreasonable, and include supporting documents such as the regulator's decision. Send the form to grc@justice.gov.uk or to the General Regulatory Chamber, PO Box 11230, Leicester LE1 8FQ.
Environmental fines or notices: appeal against a regulator (opens in a new tab)
Works notices for water pollution in England
In England, the Environment Agency may serve a works notice on a responsible person where polluting or waste matter is, has been or is likely to be in controlled waters, or controlled waters are being or have been harmed, or are likely to be harmed. The notice must tell you of your right of appeal, including the time for appealing.
You may appeal to the Secretary of State within 21 days beginning with the day the notice is served. Send a notice of appeal with your grounds, and copies to the Agency. The appeal is decided on written representations unless a party asks for a hearing or the Secretary of State decides to hold one. The Secretary of State must quash a notice that has a material defect. Otherwise the Secretary of State may confirm it, with or without modification, or quash it.
Failing to comply with a works notice is an offence. On summary conviction the penalty is up to 3 months in prison, an unlimited fine, or both. On indictment it is up to 2 years in prison, a fine, or both. If you fail to comply, the Agency may also do the works and recover its reasonable costs.
Challenge a decision that has no statutory appeal
The Environment Agency says it runs a non-statutory regulatory appeal for decisions that carry no statutory right of appeal. You raise your concerns within 14 calendar days of the decision. If you are not satisfied with the response, you make a stage 2 appeal within 28 calendar days of the stage 1 response. It says it does not use this route where a statutory right of appeal exists, or for decisions to prosecute.
NRW says it runs a similar process. You raise concerns in writing within 15 working days, and make a stage 2 appeal within 21 working days of the stage 1 response. NRW says it does not use the process where a statutory right of appeal exists, or for decisions to prosecute.
Both regulators say they do not accept a regulatory appeal against a decision to reject an enforcement undertaking offer.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations
Official guidance
Natural Resources Wales: appeal a regulatory decision (opens in a new tab)
naturalresources.wales · Wales
Natural Resources Wales: enforcement and sanctions policy (opens in a new tab)
naturalresources.wales · Wales
Environment Agency's use of civil sanctions (opens in a new tab)
Publication · GOV.UK · England
Environment Agency enforcement and sanctions policy (opens in a new tab)
Publication · Environment Agency · England