Finding your waste fly-tipped does not by itself make your business guilty of an offence. Liability depends on what your business did or failed to do with the waste: failing to take reasonable measures over it, failing to keep or produce its waste transfer notes, or depositing it or knowingly causing or permitting its deposit.
The duty of care offence
Under s.34(1) of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, anyone who imports, produces, carries, keeps, treats or disposes of controlled waste, or controls it as a dealer or broker, must take all measures applicable to them in that capacity that are reasonable in the circumstances. The measures are those that prevent:
- any contravention by any other person of s.33
- any contravention by any other person of regulation 12 of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016 or of a condition of an environmental permit
- the waste escaping from your control or that of any other person
On the transfer of the waste, the measures are also those that secure that the transfer is only to an authorised person or to a person for authorised transport purposes, and that a written description of the waste is transferred with it that will enable other persons to avoid a contravention of s.33, regulation 12 or a permit condition, and to comply with the duty on the escape of waste.
The standard is reasonableness, not a guarantee of outcome. Waste that someone else later fly-tips does not itself show that you failed the duty. An authorised person includes a registered carrier of controlled waste and a person not required to be registered as a carrier.
Failing to comply with the duty, or with a requirement of regulations made under s.34(5) such as keeping and producing waste transfer notes, is an offence under s.34(6). The Act prints the penalty on summary conviction as a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum. That is an unlimited fine in England and Wales for offences committed on or after 12 March 2015. On conviction on indictment the penalty is a fine. The offence carries no prison term.
The statutory Code of practice on the duty of care is guidance. A court must take any provision of it that appears relevant into account. The Code says you should check whether a person or business is authorised to take waste before you transfer your waste to them. It says you can ask them for evidence of their authorisation, such as a copy of their permit or proof of their exemption registration, and that you should also use the public register to check any evidence they provide. In England that register is held by the Environment Agency. The Code also says: "Record any checks you make as you can use this as evidence that you have met your duty of care."
The Code adds: "If you suspect that someone is fly-tipping, illegally depositing, treating or disposing of waste, do not give your waste to them or take waste from them."
The deposit offence
Under s.33(1)(a) you must not deposit controlled waste in or on any land, or knowingly cause or knowingly permit it to be deposited there, unless an environmental permit authorising the deposit is in force and the deposit is in accordance with it, or the deposit is an exempt waste operation.
A business that produced the waste is caught only if it deposited the waste itself, or knowingly caused or knowingly permitted the deposit. Handing waste to a carrier who then dumps it does not meet that test on its own.
Where waste is carried in and deposited from a motor vehicle, the person who controls or is in a position to control the use of the vehicle is treated as knowingly causing the deposit, whether or not they gave instructions. That can reach a business that controls, or is in a position to control, the use of the vehicle, such as its own van.
It is a defence to a charge under s.33 for you to prove either of the following:
- you took all reasonable precautions and exercised all due diligence to avoid the offence
- the acts alleged were done in an emergency to avoid danger to human health, you took all steps reasonably practicable to minimise pollution of the environment and harm to human health, and particulars of the acts were furnished to the waste regulation authority as soon as reasonably practicable afterwards
The burden of proving a defence is yours.
On summary conviction the penalty is imprisonment for up to the general limit in a magistrates' court, an unlimited fine, or both. For an offence triable either way that limit has been 12 months since 18 November 2024. On conviction on indictment the penalty is imprisonment for up to 5 years, a fine, or both.
Where an offence under the Act committed by a body corporate is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance of, or to have been attributable to any neglect on the part of, a director, manager, secretary or other similar officer, or a person purporting to act in that capacity, that person as well as the body corporate is guilty of the offence and liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly.
Fixed penalty notices
A fixed penalty notice offers you the opportunity to discharge liability to conviction by paying a fixed penalty.
| Notice | Offence it covers | Who can give it | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deposit offence in England (s.33ZA) | The deposit offence under s.33(1)(a), and no other offence | An authorised officer of an English waste collection authority, for an offence in the authority's area | The authority sets an amount of not less than £150 and not more than £5,000, or £200 if it sets none. The upper limit of £5,000 applies from 1 September 2026. The authority may treat a lesser amount of not less than £120 as paid if you pay within a period it specifies. |
| Failure to furnish documents (s.34A) | Failing to furnish documents to the authority as required by regulations made under s.34(5), such as producing a waste transfer note. The notice offers discharge of liability to conviction for the s.34(6) offence | The Environment Agency, Natural Resources Wales or a waste collection authority | £300 |
No proceedings may be started for the offence before the end of the 14 days following the date of the notice. You cannot be convicted of the offence if you pay within that period. A notice is an offer, not an obligation to pay.
If an authorised officer proposes to give you a deposit offence notice, the officer may require your name and address. Failing to give them, or giving false or inaccurate details, is an offence punishable by a fine of up to level 3 on the standard scale.
A business can be given a s.34A notice for failing to furnish documents. If it carries waste, it can also be given a notice under s.5B of the Control of Pollution (Amendment) Act 1989 where it appears to the Environment Agency in England, Natural Resources Wales in Wales or a waste collection authority that it failed without reasonable excuse to produce its authority to transport the waste when required under s.5(2)(a) of that Act. A waste collection authority cannot use these powers against a specified person, which includes a carrier that only transports waste it produced itself, other than construction or demolition waste. That notice is also £300, with the same 14 days. The notices in ss.34ZA and 34ZB are for householders, for failing the household waste transfer duty.
The Code of practice says that in some instances a fixed penalty notice may be issued for failure to comply with the duty of care.
Defra guidance for councils says a fixed penalty notice is not an appropriate sanction for waste industry operators, repeat offenders, or those responsible for large-scale fly-tipping or fly-tipping of hazardous waste. It says those cases are for prosecution.
What an authority can require from you
Information notices
The Environment Agency in England and Natural Resources Wales in Wales may serve a written notice under s.71 on any person. The notice requires the person to furnish the information it specifies, in the form and within the period it specifies. The information must be what the authority reasonably considers it needs for its functions under Part II of the Act on waste on land. A business that is not itself suspected can be served.
A waste collection authority has this power only for its functions on searching, seizing and disposing of vehicles under ss.34B and 34C.
Failing without reasonable excuse to comply with a notice is an offence. On summary conviction the penalty is a fine, which is unlimited in England and Wales. On conviction on indictment it is a fine, imprisonment for up to 2 years, or both.
Investigation powers
Under s.108 of the Environment Act 1995, an enforcing authority may authorise in writing a person who appears suitable to it. That person exercises the powers in accordance with the terms of the authorisation, to check compliance with the authority's pollution control enactments or to carry out its pollution control functions. The enforcing authorities include the Environment Agency, Natural Resources Wales and waste collection authorities. For an English waste collection authority, pollution control functions are its functions under Part 2 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, other than collecting household waste from domestic property. A person authorised in writing may:
- enter premises at any reasonable time that they have reason to believe it is necessary to enter, or at any time in an emergency
- require anyone they have reasonable cause to believe able to give relevant information to answer questions, in the absence of anyone other than a person that person nominates and anyone the person authorised in writing allows to be present, and to sign a declaration that the answers are true
- require production of records that must be kept under the pollution control enactments, or that they need to see for an investigation, including extracts from computer records, and inspect and take copies of them
- if authorised by an English or Welsh authority, search premises and seize and remove documents or anything else found there
Except in an emergency, entry to premises used for residential purposes, or to take heavy equipment on to any premises, needs the consent of an occupier or a warrant. Except in an emergency, entry by force, where entry has been refused or is likely to be refused, needs a warrant. In an emergency, entry may be at any time and, if need be, by force.
The search and seizure power needs the consent of a person entitled to grant access to the material, or a warrant. The person may, without either, seize and remove a thing, or require electronic information, if they have reasonable grounds for believing it is evidence of a failure to comply with the pollution control enactments and that acting is necessary to prevent it being concealed, lost, altered or destroyed. Consent or a warrant is also not required for anything that another s.108 power allows without them.
Protected material is material subject to legal professional privilege, excluded material within the meaning of s.11 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, and journalistic material within the meaning of s.13 of that Act that is not excluded material. If protected material is seized or removed, it may not be used for the investigation and must be returned as soon as reasonably practicable after it is identified. Parts of a thing that are not protected material may still be used, retained or copied. Separately, nothing in s.108 compels production of a document you would be entitled to withhold on grounds of legal professional privilege.
Intentionally obstructing a person authorised in writing is an offence. On summary conviction the penalty is a fine, which is unlimited in England and Wales. Failing without reasonable excuse to comply with a requirement under s.108, or to provide facilities, assistance or information that person reasonably requires under it, is also an offence. On summary conviction the penalty is a fine, which is unlimited in England and Wales.
Waste transfer notes
Under reg 35 of the Waste (England and Wales) Regulations 2011, both the transferor and the transferee must keep the written information about a transfer of waste, or a copy of it, for at least 2 years. Each must produce it on demand within 7 days to an officer of the appropriate body or of a waste collection authority. The appropriate body is the Environment Agency in England and Natural Resources Wales in Wales. The written information may be in electronic form if the person producing it can do so in a visible and legible documentary form. The signature it needs must then be an electronic signature. Reg 35 does not apply to hazardous waste where the consignment note, and any schedule, required by the hazardous waste regulations are completed and dealt with in accordance with them.
Interviews under caution
No answer given in pursuance of a requirement under s.108(4)(j) to answer questions is admissible in evidence in England and Wales against the person who gave it, in any proceedings. An interview under caution is different. Investigators who are not police officers must, when investigating offences, have regard to any relevant provision of a PACE code (s.67(9) of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984). PACE Code C sets out the usual caution, which reads: "You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence."
Code C is written for police custody and voluntary police interviews. For a voluntary interview it says the interviewer must inform the suspect of their right to free legal advice, explaining that they may obtain free and independent legal advice if they want it, and that this includes the right to speak with a solicitor on the telephone and to have the solicitor present during the interview. Take legal advice before any interview under caution.
Clean-up costs
Where an authority uses its power in s.59(7) to remove waste deposited in contravention of s.33(1) or of regulation 12 of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016, or to take other steps to eliminate or reduce the consequences of the deposit, it may recover the cost of the removal, the steps and the disposal. It may recover that cost from any person who deposited the waste or knowingly caused or knowingly permitted the deposit. It may not recover any part of the cost that the person shows was incurred unnecessarily.
An authority may not recover its costs under s.59 if a court has made a compensation order in its favour for any part of them. That bar falls away if the order is set aside on appeal.
On a conviction for contravening s.33(1), the court may also order the offender to pay an enforcement authority a sum that appears to the court not to exceed the costs of the investigation that resulted in the conviction and of seizing a vehicle under s.34B. The costs of seizure may include the cost of disposing of the vehicle's contents. The power is in addition to the court's power to award costs against the accused under s.18 of the Prosecution of Offences Act 1985.
Vehicle seizure and forfeiture
An authorised officer of the Environment Agency, Natural Resources Wales or a waste collection authority, or a constable, may search a vehicle and seize it and its contents under s.34B. The officer or constable must reasonably believe either of the following:
- a relevant offence, or an offence under reg 38(1) or (2) of the Environmental Permitting Regulations in relation to a waste operation, has been committed, a vehicle was used in committing it and proceedings have not yet been brought against anyone
- such an offence is being or is about to be committed and a vehicle is being or is about to be used in committing it
For this power, a relevant offence is an offence under s.33 or a failure to comply with the s.34(1) duty of care. A vehicle includes a motor vehicle, a trailer and mobile plant.
To search or seize, the officer or constable may stop the vehicle, but only a constable in uniform may stop a vehicle on a road. They may also enter premises to search for or seize it. Failing without reasonable excuse to give reasonable assistance, or intentionally obstructing them, is an offence. On summary conviction the penalty is a fine, which is unlimited in England and Wales.
On conviction for depositing or disposing of controlled waste under s.33(1), the court may make an order under s.33C that deprives the offender of their rights in a vehicle used in or for the offence. It can do so only if the offender has rights in the vehicle at the time of conviction. The court must in particular have regard to the vehicle's value, the likely financial and other effects on the offender, and the offender's need to use the vehicle for lawful purposes. Where it appears that the offender's business consists wholly or partly of unlawful waste activities, the court must also have regard to whether the order is likely to stop them continuing.
-
Gather your waste transfer notes
Collect the notes for the waste concerned. Whether you were the transferor or the transferee, you must keep each note, or a copy, for at least 2 years and produce it within 7 days on demand.
-
Gather your carrier checks
Collect evidence of the carrier's authorisation and of any register check you made. The Code of practice says to record checks as evidence that you met your duty of care.
-
Answer an information notice in the form and period it sets
Furnish the information the notice specifies. Failing without reasonable excuse to comply is an offence.
-
Decide on any fixed penalty notice within the 14 days
No proceedings can start before the end of the 14 days following the date of the notice, and you cannot be convicted if you pay within that period. Check the notice for a shorter period in which a lower amount is accepted.
-
Take legal advice before an interview under caution
The caution warns that anything you say may be given in evidence. Code C, which is written for police interviews and which other investigators must have regard to, says a suspect at a voluntary interview must be told of the right to free and independent legal advice.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations
Official guidance
Environment Agency controlled waste guidance (opens in a new tab)
Environment Agency · England
Waste duty of care code of practice (opens in a new tab)
Publication · DEFRA · England and Wales
Fly-tipping: council responsibilities (opens in a new tab)
DEFRA · England and Wales
Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) codes of practice (opens in a new tab)
Home Office