A local planning authority in England may issue an enforcement notice where it appears to the authority that there has been a breach of planning control and that it is expedient to issue the notice, having regard to the development plan and any other material considerations.
Check which notice you hold
An authority has several notices it can use, and they run to different dates.
| Notice | What it does | Date or period |
|---|---|---|
| Enforcement notice | Requires the steps it specifies to be taken, or the activities it specifies to cease, by the end of the compliance period | Takes effect on the date the notice specifies, unless an appeal suspends it |
| Enforcement warning notice | May be issued where it appears to the authority that there is a breach on land in England and a reasonable prospect that planning permission would be granted if an application were made. States the alleged breach and that further enforcement action may be taken unless an application is made within the period it specifies. It requires no step | The period the notice specifies is the time to apply for planning permission |
| Stop notice | Prohibits an activity the enforcement notice requires to cease, before the compliance period ends, within the dwellinghouse and four-year limits. It can be served with the enforcement notice or afterwards, but not once that notice has taken effect | Takes effect on the date it states. That date is no earlier than 3 days after service, unless the authority considers there are special reasons for an earlier date and serves a statement of them with the stop notice, and no later than 28 days after it is first served |
| Temporary stop notice | Prohibits an activity the authority thinks amounts to a breach, within the dwellinghouse and four-year limits, and may be issued before any enforcement notice | Has effect from the time a copy is first displayed on the land. It ends after 56 days, after a shorter period the notice specifies, or when the authority withdraws it |
| Breach of condition notice | Requires the person served to secure compliance with the planning conditions it specifies. It can go to a person carrying out or who has carried out the development or, for conditions regulating use, a person with control of the land | Allows a compliance period of at least 28 days from service, as the notice specifies or as extended by a further notice |
The Planning Practice Guidance says there is no right of appeal to the Secretary of State against a stop notice, a temporary stop notice, a breach of condition notice or an enforcement warning notice, and that the first three may be challenged by judicial review. An enforcement warning notice is not an enforcement notice. It requires no step, and issuing it does not affect any other power the authority has.
What an enforcement notice must say
An enforcement notice must:
- state the matters that appear to the authority to constitute the breach, and whether the breach is carrying out development without the required planning permission or failing to comply with a condition or limitation of a permission
- specify the steps the authority requires to be taken, or the activities it requires to cease
- specify the date it takes effect
- specify the period at the end of which the steps must have been taken or the activities must have ceased
- give the reasons the authority considers it expedient to issue the notice, all policies and proposals in the development plan that are relevant to the decision, and the precise boundaries of the land
The steps may aim to remedy the breach or to remedy injury to amenity caused by it.
A notice may set different compliance periods for different steps or activities. The provision on the contents of a notice, s.173 of the Act, sets no minimum or maximum compliance period for an enforcement notice.
Every copy served must come with an explanatory note. It must include sections 171A, 171B and 172 to 177 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, or a summary of them that covers the right of appeal, how and when to appeal, the grounds, and the fee for the deemed planning application that follows from appealing on ground (a). It must also state the rule on the statement of grounds and give the names and addresses of the people served.
Who is served and when
A copy of the notice must be served on the owner and the occupier of the land. It must also be served on any other person with an interest in the land that, in the authority's opinion, is materially affected by the notice.
Service must take place no more than 28 days after the date the notice is issued and at least 28 days before the date the notice takes effect. If a copy was not served as required, that is a ground of appeal. The Secretary of State may disregard it if neither the appellant nor the person who was not served has been substantially prejudiced.
Authorities keep a register of enforcement notices, stop notices, breach of condition notices and enforcement warning notices, open to public inspection at all reasonable hours.
When it takes effect and how long you have
The notice takes effect on the date it specifies, unless an appeal suspends it. The compliance period is the period the notice specifies, at the end of which each step must have been taken or each activity must have ceased.
The authority may withdraw the notice, or waive or relax any of its requirements, including by extending a compliance period. It can do this whether or not the notice has taken effect. It must immediately notify everyone who was served with a copy, and anyone who would be served if the notice were re-issued. Withdrawing a notice does not stop the authority issuing another. The Planning Inspectorate says that if the only complaint is the compliance period, you should consider negotiating it with the authority, which may be willing to extend it, and then no appeal is needed.
Appeal against the notice
Who can appeal
A person with an interest in the land, or a relevant occupier, may appeal to the Secretary of State, whether or not a copy of the notice was served on them. A relevant occupier is someone who occupies the land under a licence on the date the notice is issued and still occupies it when the appeal is brought.
GOV.UK says that if you want to appeal against more than one enforcement notice you must make a separate appeal for each, that each person should appeal separately, and that there is no fee for appealing unless you also apply for planning permission. The fee is for the planning application you are treated as making when you appeal on ground (a). The Planning Inspectorate says a company with an interest in the land must appeal in its own name; a director or shareholder has no right of appeal on its behalf.
How to give notice of an appeal
An appeal must be made by giving written notice of it to the Secretary of State before the effective date. You can post it in a properly addressed, pre-paid letter so that in the ordinary course of post it would be delivered before that date, or send it by electronic communications so that in the ordinary course of transmission it would be delivered before that date. The Planning Inspectorate says the appeal must be received before the effective date, at the latest the day before.
If you cannot appeal online in time, the Planning Inspectorate says you may appeal by a letter or email that it receives before the effective date. It says the letter or email must make clear that it is a notification of appeal and give the appellant's name and address, the name of the authority, the address of the site and the effective date. The Inspectorate says the completed online appeal should follow immediately.
The appellant must also submit a written statement of the grounds, either with the notice of appeal or within the prescribed time. In England it must specify the grounds and set out briefly the facts relied on for each. If it is not sent with the appeal, it is due within 14 days of the date the Secretary of State sends a notice requiring it.
Grounds of appeal
An appeal may be brought on one or more of these grounds:
- Ground (a) is that planning permission ought to be granted for the matters stated in the notice as the breach, or the condition or limitation concerned ought to be discharged.
- Ground (b) is that those matters have not occurred.
- Ground (c) is that those matters, if they occurred, do not constitute a breach of planning control.
- Ground (d) is that, at the date the notice was issued, no enforcement action could be taken in respect of the breach. The time limits for enforcement usually decide this.
- Ground (e) is that copies of the notice were not served as required.
- Ground (f) is that the steps required, or the activities required to cease, exceed what is necessary to remedy the breach or any injury to amenity it caused.
- Ground (g) is that the compliance period falls short of what should reasonably be allowed.
Where the breach relates to relevant demolition, a further ground is available: that the demolition was urgently necessary in the interests of safety or health, repair or temporary support could not practicably secure safety or health, and it was the minimum measure necessary.
When ground (a) is not available
Ground (a) is not available if the enforcement notice was issued after a related application for planning permission was made. An application is related if granting it would involve granting permission for the matters the notice specifies as the breach. An application the authority or the Secretary of State declined to determine under section 70A, 70B or 70C of the 1990 Act is ignored. An enforcement warning notice does not by itself bar ground (a): the bar depends on a related application having been made before the notice was issued.
The bar does not apply if both of these are true:
- the related application has ceased to be under consideration
- the notice was issued after the end of the two years beginning with the day the application ceased to be under consideration
An application has ceased to be under consideration, on the day shown, in these cases:
- it was refused, or granted subject to conditions, and, where the authority decided it, the applicant did not appeal: the day the right to appeal arose
- the authority did not decide it within the prescribed period, the applicant did not appeal and it was not later refused: the day after that prescribed period ended
- an appeal was dismissed: the day it was dismissed
- an appeal was allowed subject to conditions, or different conditions: the day the appeal was determined
- the Secretary of State declined to determine an appeal: for an appeal against a refusal or conditions, the day the right to appeal arose, and for an appeal against non-determination, the day after the prescribed period ended
The restriction does not apply to an enforcement notice issued, and not withdrawn, before 25 April 2024. The earlier rule applies to those notices.
If you do plead ground (a), you are treated as having applied for planning permission for the matters the notice states as the breach. Where a fee is payable and the Secretary of State notifies you of the period for paying it, an unpaid fee at the end of that period means the ground (a) appeal and the application lapse. The Planning Inspectorate says the fee is stated on the notice and a lapsed ground (a) appeal cannot be restarted. The Secretary of State may grant permission on an enforcement appeal only if ground (a) is specified in the statement of grounds.
What an appeal does to the notice
When an appeal is brought, the notice has no effect until the appeal is finally determined or withdrawn. If proceedings in the High Court follow, the court may order the notice to have effect pending their final determination.
On the appeal the Secretary of State may correct any defect, error or misdescription in the notice, or vary its terms, if satisfied this will cause no injustice to the appellant or the authority. The Secretary of State may also grant permission or discharge a condition or limitation. The Secretary of State may also decide whether, on the date the appeal was made, an existing use, operations already carried out or a failure to comply with a condition or limitation was lawful, and, if it was, issue a lawful development certificate. On allowing the appeal, the Secretary of State may quash the notice. Where an authority in England issued the notice and it appears to the Secretary of State that the appellant is responsible for undue delay, the Secretary of State may give notice that the appeal will be dismissed unless the appellant takes specified steps within a stated period. That power does not apply to an appeal made before 25 April 2024 against a notice issued and not withdrawn before that date.
A decision on an enforcement appeal can be challenged in the High Court on a point of law, but only with the court's leave.
Time limits for enforcement
Unless a further-action rule or a planning enforcement order applies, no enforcement action may be taken after the end of the period that applies to the breach. The periods in England are:
| Breach | Period in England |
|---|---|
| Operations (building, engineering, mining or other) substantially completed on or after 25 April 2024 | 10 years beginning with the date the operations were substantially completed |
| Operations substantially completed before 25 April 2024 | 4 years beginning with the date the operations were substantially completed |
| Change of use of a building to use as a single dwellinghouse, on or after 25 April 2024 | 10 years beginning with the date of the breach |
| Change of use of a building to use as a single dwellinghouse, before 25 April 2024 | 4 years beginning with the date of the breach |
| Any other breach, including any other change of use and failure to comply with a condition | 10 years beginning with the date of the breach |
| Relevant demolition, as defined in section 196D of the 1990 Act | No time limit |
The limits do not prevent further enforcement action if, in the four years ending with that action, the authority took or purported to take enforcement action on the same breach. Issuing an enforcement warning notice in England counts as enforcement action. The limits also do not prevent serving a breach of condition notice while an enforcement notice on the same breach is in effect.
In England, where it appears to the authority that there may have been a breach of planning control, it may apply to a magistrates' court for a planning enforcement order. It can apply only within 6 months beginning with the date evidence sufficient, in its opinion, to justify the application came to its knowledge. The court may make the order only if both of these apply:
- it is satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the apparent breach, or any matter that makes it up, has to any extent been deliberately concealed by anyone
- it considers the order just in all the circumstances
If the court makes the order, the authority may take enforcement action on the apparent breach at any time in the enforcement year, whether or not the time limits have expired. The enforcement year begins at the end of 22 days beginning with the day the court gives its decision or, if someone applies for the magistrates to state a case for the High Court's opinion, on the day those proceedings are finally determined or withdrawn.
What follows if the notice is not complied with
The owner of the land is in breach if, at any time after the end of the compliance period, a required step has not been taken or a required activity is still being carried on. The owner is the person who is then entitled to receive the rack rent of the land, or would be if it were let at a rack rent. A mortgagee not in possession is not the owner for this purpose. An owner in breach is guilty of an offence, and it is a defence for the owner to show they did everything they could be expected to do to secure compliance.
A person with control of or an interest in the land who is not the owner must not carry on an activity the notice requires to cease, or cause or permit one to be carried on. Doing so after the end of the compliance period is an offence.
An offence may be charged by reference to any day or longer period, and a person may be convicted of a second or later offence for a later period. A person charged who was not served with a copy, and where the notice is not on the register, has a defence if they show they were not aware of the notice.
On summary conviction or conviction on indictment the penalty is a fine, with no upper limit set by the Act. In setting it the court must have regard in particular to any financial benefit that has accrued or appears likely to accrue from the offence.
If a required step is not taken within the compliance period, the authority may enter the land, take the step and recover its reasonable expenses from the person who is then the owner. Wilfully obstructing a person acting under that power is an offence, with a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale.
A person served with a breach of condition notice commits an offence if, after the compliance period, a specified condition is not complied with and the specified steps have not been taken or activities have not ceased. It is a defence to prove either of these:
- all reasonable measures were taken to secure compliance
- for a notice served on a person with control of the land, that the person no longer had control of it
On summary conviction the fine is unlimited for an offence committed on or after 25 April 2024. For an offence committed from 6 April 2012 to 24 April 2024 the cap is level 4 on the standard scale, and before 6 April 2012 it was level 3.
After you comply
Complying with a notice does not discharge it. A requirement to discontinue a use is a requirement to discontinue it permanently, to the extent that the use is in contravention of Part III of the 1990 Act (the part that requires planning permission), and resuming the use to that extent later breaches the notice. Reinstating or restoring buildings or works removed or altered in compliance with the notice, without planning permission, is an offence with an unlimited fine, and the notice is treated as applying to what is reinstated. The authority must serve notice on the owner and occupier at least 28 days before it takes steps to remove or alter what was reinstated.
If planning permission is later granted for development already carried out, the notice ceases to have effect so far as it is inconsistent with that permission. That does not affect liability for an earlier failure to comply.
If the notice could have required buildings or works to be removed or an activity to cease, but required less, and all its requirements are complied with, planning permission is treated as granted for the rest of what was built or carried on.
Stop notices and temporary stop notices
Neither kind of stop notice can prohibit the use of a building as a dwellinghouse. A stop notice cannot prohibit an activity carried on, continuously or not, for more than four years ending with service of the notice. A temporary stop notice cannot prohibit an activity carried on, continuously or not, for four years ending with the day the copy is first displayed. In each case any period when planning permission authorised the activity is ignored. The four-year limit does not protect building, engineering, mining or other operations, anything incidental to them, or the deposit of refuse or waste materials. A temporary stop notice also does not prohibit an activity prescribed by regulations.
A stop notice ceases to have effect when the enforcement notice is withdrawn or quashed, when the compliance period for the enforcement notice expires, or when the authority withdraws the stop notice. It also ceases to have effect so far as a variation of the enforcement notice means the activities it prohibits are no longer ones the enforcement notice requires to cease.
Contravening a stop notice after a site notice has been displayed or the stop notice has been served on you is an offence, and so is contravening a temporary stop notice served on you or displayed on the land. Causing or permitting a contravention counts. In each case it is a defence to prove that the notice was not served on you and that you did not know, and could not reasonably have been expected to know, of its existence. The penalty on summary conviction or conviction on indictment is a fine.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations