Work out which route applies
The penalty notice or decision letter says how to appeal and by when. The route depends on the tax.
Corporation Tax and Income Tax, including Self Assessment, are direct taxes. For a direct tax penalty, you can ask for a review or go to the tribunal only after you appeal to HMRC.
VAT is an indirect tax. HMRC offers a review in its penalty decision letter, and you can usually appeal to the tribunal without first appealing to HMRC.
Corporation Tax
Late filing penalties for a Company Tax Return are charged under Schedule 18 to the Finance Act 1998. A company is liable if it does not deliver the return by the filing date.
If the return is six months late, HMRC writes with a tax determination of the Corporation Tax it thinks is due. You cannot appeal against the determination. You must pay the Corporation Tax due and file the return, and HMRC then recalculates the interest and penalties.
Self Assessment
You can appeal a Self Assessment late filing penalty or late payment penalty. If you do not need to send a Self Assessment return, you can ask HMRC to cancel the penalty.
From the tax year you join Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, points-based late submission penalties and late payment penalties apply. They replace the earlier Self Assessment penalties. The earlier penalties still apply to returns for tax years before you joined.
The Making Tax Digital for Income Tax penalties do not apply to returns for a non-resident company, a trust or estate, or a partnership. The earlier penalties still apply to those.
Under the Making Tax Digital for Income Tax penalties, HMRC writes to you about each late payment penalty and each late submission penalty point. The letter says how to appeal. For the 2026 to 2027 tax year, there are no penalties for missing a quarterly update deadline.
VAT
The points-based late submission penalties and the late payment penalties apply only to VAT accounting periods starting on or after 1 January 2023. For periods that started on or before 31 December 2022, the penalty may be a default surcharge. You challenge a default surcharge on form WT2.
Late submission penalties do not apply to:
- a newly registered business's first VAT return
- the final return after cancelling registration
- a one-off return covering a period other than a month, quarter or year
Late payment penalties do not apply to VAT payments on account or Annual Accounting Scheme instalments.
Decide your ground of appeal
You can appeal because you had a reasonable excuse, because no penalty is payable or because the amount is wrong.
Reasonable excuse
A reasonable excuse is something that stopped you meeting a tax obligation for a valid reason. It removes a Self Assessment or VAT penalty only if you satisfy HMRC, or on appeal the tribunal, that you had one for the failure.
These may count as a reasonable excuse:
- your partner or another close relative died shortly before the deadline
- you had an unexpected stay in hospital that stopped you dealing with your tax affairs
- you had a serious or life-threatening illness
- your computer or software failed while you were preparing your online return
- HMRC online services had problems
- a fire, flood or theft stopped you completing your return
- the post was delayed in a way you could not have predicted
- a disability or mental illness you have caused delays
- you were unaware of or misunderstood your legal obligation
These are not accepted as a reasonable excuse:
- finding the HMRC online system too difficult to use
- not getting a reminder from HMRC
- a mistake on your return
For VAT and Self Assessment penalties, these rules also apply:
- not having enough money is a reasonable excuse only if events outside your control caused it
- relying on another person is a reasonable excuse only if you took reasonable care to avoid the failure
- if your excuse ended, you are treated as still having it only if you remedied the failure without unreasonable delay after it ended
For a Company Tax Return, a company that had a reasonable excuse for not filing on time is treated as not having failed to file. If the excuse ended, the company keeps that treatment only if it filed without unreasonable delay after the excuse ended.
No penalty is payable, or the amount is wrong
You can also appeal on the basis that no penalty is payable or that HMRC has worked out the amount wrongly.
A company is not liable to the flat-rate late filing penalty if all of these apply:
- the period is one for which the company must deliver accounts under the Companies Act 2006
- the company delivers the Company Tax Return no later than the last day for delivering those accounts to the registrar of companies
Special circumstances
HMRC may reduce a Self Assessment or VAT late payment penalty, or an earlier Self Assessment late filing penalty, because of special circumstances. Reducing a penalty includes staying it and agreeing a compromise. Special circumstances do not include ability to pay, or a potential loss of revenue from one taxpayer being balanced by a potential overpayment by another. HMRC has no power to reduce a points-based late submission penalty, for VAT or Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, for special circumstances.
On an appeal about the amount, the tribunal can rely on that power to the same extent as HMRC. It can rely on it to a different extent only if HMRC's decision on special circumstances was flawed on judicial review principles.
Appeal a direct tax penalty to HMRC
You usually have 30 days from the date the penalty was issued to appeal to HMRC. Your appeal must be in writing and must say why you disagree.
A person acting for you, such as an agent, can appeal on your behalf. For a penalty on a Self Assessment partnership return, only the representative partner or a successor can appeal.
You can use the appeal form that came with the penalty letter, or write to HMRC at the address on the letter. For Self Assessment, you can also appeal online, or by post on form SA370 or SA371.
A company with a reasonable excuse can appeal a late filing penalty online. Fill in the online form in one go, then print it and post it to the address on the form.
For a Company Tax Return penalty, you need:
- the company's Unique Taxpayer Reference (UTR)
- the date on the penalty notice
- the penalty amount
- the end date of the accounting period the penalty is for
- the reason the return was late
For a Self Assessment penalty, have the date the penalty was issued, the date you filed or paid, and details of your reasonable excuse. If computer problems stopped you filing or paying online, give the date you tried and details of any error message.
If you miss the 30 days, HMRC must agree to a late appeal if all of these apply:
- you ask in writing
- HMRC is satisfied you had a reasonable excuse for not appealing in time
- you asked without unreasonable delay after the excuse ended
Otherwise, a late appeal needs the tribunal's permission.
Appeal a Self Assessment penalty for late filing or late payment (opens in a new tab)
Appeal a Company Tax Return late filing penalty (opens in a new tab)
After you appeal
The caseworker who made the decision looks at your case again and aims to reach an agreement with you. They write to tell you what they decide.
If HMRC does not change its decision, or you cannot reach an agreement, it offers you a review. You can also ask for a review at any time after you appeal, without waiting for HMRC's answer, unless you have already taken the appeal to the tribunal. To ask, write to the same HMRC office you sent the appeal to.
After you appeal to HMRC, you can notify the appeal to the tribunal directly, unless HMRC has already given its view or offered a review. If you have already asked for a review, wait for its outcome.
Respond to a VAT penalty decision
HMRC tells you about a penalty point, a late submission penalty or a late payment penalty in a penalty decision letter. HMRC must offer a review at the same time as it notifies you of the decision.
You have 30 days from the date of the document containing the offer to accept the review or appeal to the tribunal. You cannot accept a review if you have already appealed to the tribunal, and HMRC will not review after you appeal.
For VAT periods starting on or after 1 January 2023, the quickest way to accept the offer is your VAT online account. You can also check your penalty details there. If you cannot use it, write to HMRC and say which penalty you are challenging and why.
You can ask HMRC to extend the deadline if you need more time, for example to gather information for the review officer. You must ask within 30 days of the offer date.
If you miss the 30 days, HMRC must review out of time if all of these apply:
- you ask in writing
- HMRC is satisfied you had a reasonable excuse for not accepting in time
- you asked without unreasonable delay after the excuse ended
If HMRC refuses to review out of time, you can appeal to the tribunal only with its permission.
Penalty points
If you appeal against a VAT late submission penalty, the review or the tribunal can also cancel the penalty points that led to it. They can do this even if the time to appeal against those points has passed. A review cannot do this for a point already upheld on an earlier appeal or review. The tribunal cannot do it for a point already affirmed on an earlier appeal.
HMRC may award a point within 12 months beginning with the day after the tribunal's decision if all of these apply:
- the tribunal cancels both the penalty and a point that led to it
- after HMRC gave that point, and before the tribunal cancelled it, you failed to file again
- at the time of that failure, you already had the maximum number of points
You cannot appeal adjustments to your penalty points made when you change your accounting period.
Get a review
A review is done by someone in a different team who was not involved in the original decision. Reviews usually take 45 days, and the review officer contacts you if it will take longer.
HMRC must tell you the conclusions of the review and its reasoning within 45 days, or within another period you agree. The 45 days begin on the day HMRC received your acceptance of its offer. Where you required a direct tax review, they begin on the day HMRC notified you of its view. For a VAT review out of time, they begin on the day HMRC decided to review.
If HMRC does not tell you within that time, the review is treated as upholding the decision, and HMRC must tell you so. The review officer otherwise upholds, varies or cancels the decision.
If the review upholds or varies the decision and you agree, you pay what you owe. If HMRC cancels the decision, you do not need to do anything.
Take the appeal to the tribunal
The First-tier Tribunal (Tax) is independent of HMRC and listens to both sides before it decides.
After a review, you can appeal to the tribunal within 30 days beginning with the date of HMRC's conclusions letter. If HMRC gave no conclusions in time, the review is treated as upholding its decision. You can then appeal from the end of the 45 days until 30 days after the date of HMRC's notice of that conclusion.
For a VAT review that you accepted, you cannot appeal to the tribunal until HMRC has given its conclusions or the review period has ended. For direct tax, the conclusions of a review are treated as a settlement unless you appeal to the tribunal.
If the deadline has passed, you can appeal only with the tribunal's permission. Your notice of appeal must include a request for permission and the reason it is late. The tribunal must not admit the appeal unless it gives permission, and a judge decides.
You can appeal online with a scan or photo of your penalty notice or review conclusion letter and your reasons for appealing. You can also appeal by post on notice of appeal form T240.
Not every case has a hearing, but you can ask for one. You usually get at least 14 days' notice of the date. A hearing may be by phone, by video or in person.
If you lose and want to appeal, you must first ask for full written reasons, unless you already have them. You must ask within 14 days of the date on the decision notice.
You can then ask the First-tier Tribunal for permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal. You must ask within 56 days of the date on the full written reasons. You can do this on a point of law. For example, the tribunal may not have applied the law correctly or fully explained its decision. If the First-tier Tribunal refuses permission, you can apply to the Upper Tribunal for permission. A company can also ask to appeal to the Upper Tribunal against the amount of a Corporation Tax late filing penalty.
Paying while you appeal
If you have appealed to HMRC against a direct tax penalty, you will not have to pay it until your appeal is settled. For a VAT penalty, the same applies once you have asked for a review or appealed to the tribunal. HMRC will not ask you to pay until that is settled.
For Self Assessment, HMRC advises you to consider paying the penalty while you appeal. If the appeal is rejected, you owe interest on the penalty from the date it was due. If it succeeds, HMRC repays what you paid with interest from the date you paid, if you have no other outstanding tax.
This applies to penalties, not to disputed tax. If you appeal a VAT tax decision to the tribunal, you usually have to pay the tax first, unless a hardship application succeeds.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations
Official guidance
File your Company Tax Return (opens in a new tab)
HMRC
Late submission and payment penalties (opens in a new tab)
HMRC
Tax appeals (opens in a new tab)
GOV.UK
Penalties for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax (opens in a new tab)
HMRC
How late payment penalties work if you pay VAT late (opens in a new tab)
HMRC