A moral payment, also called an ex gratia payment, is a payment that you and the other trustees could reasonably be regarded as being under a moral obligation to make. It can mean paying money out of the charity's funds or transferring charity property. It can also mean waiving a right to money or property to which the charity is legally entitled but has not yet received.
What counts as a moral payment
The basis for a moral payment is that the charity has been unjustly enriched and you wish to pay, even though you are under no legal obligation to do so.
A payment is a moral payment only where all of the following apply.
- You are not under any legal obligation to make it.
- The governing document has no power that can be used to make it.
- There are no other legal powers you can use.
- You cannot justify it as being in the best interests of the charity.
A payment you consider to be in the charity's best interests is not a moral payment. Examples are a retirement gift to a long-serving employee and an enhanced redundancy payment. Use a suitable power in the governing document. If it has none, you must get authority from the Charity Commission.
The Commission will authorise that type of payment only where you can show that the charity will receive a benefit. It cannot authorise anything that the governing document or the law prohibits.
When you can use the trustees' own power
You and the other trustees of a charity in England and Wales may apply charity property without authority from the Commission, Attorney General or court. You may also waive the charity's entitlement to receive property without that authority. You may do either only if all of the following conditions are met.
- The value of the property does not exceed the threshold for the charity's income.
- You have no other power to take the action, such as one in the governing document. Authority given under section 106 of the Charities Act 2011 does not count as another power.
- In all the circumstances, you could reasonably be regarded as being under a moral obligation to take the action.
The power applies from 27 November 2025. An application made to the Commission before that date stays under the earlier section 106.
Charities that cannot use the power for some property
Sixteen statutory charities, mainly national museums and galleries, cannot use the moral payment power for their excluded property. They include the British Museum, the British Library and the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. The Schedule to the Charities Act 2022 (Commencement No. 4 and Saving Provision) Regulations 2025 sets out each charity's excluded property.
These charities can still make small moral payments from other assets within the thresholds without Commission authority. They can make larger payments from those other assets with Commission authority.
Check the governing document
The trusts of the charity may restrict or exclude the trustees' power. You must apply for Commission authority if the governing document states that you cannot make this specific type of payment. You must also apply if it restricts the use of the power and you want to act outside that restriction.
A general restriction, such as only applying income and property in furtherance of the charity's purpose, does not prevent you from using the power. This does not apply to the 16 statutory charities with excluded property.
A charity may be established by legislation, or have its purposes or functions set out in legislation. The power is not disapplied only because that legislation prohibits applying charity property otherwise than as the legislation sets out.
Legislation here covers Acts of Parliament and Acts and Measures of Senedd Cymru. It also covers subordinate legislation and instruments made under them, and Measures of the Church Assembly or the General Synod of the Church of England.
Check the amount
The threshold depends on the charity's gross income in its last financial year. The value of the property must not exceed it, so a payment equal to the threshold is within it.
| Gross income in the charity's last financial year | Threshold for the value of the payment |
|---|---|
| Did not exceed £25,000 | £1,000 |
| Exceeded £25,000 but not £250,000 | £2,500 |
| Exceeded £250,000 but not £1 million | £10,000 |
| Exceeded £1 million | £20,000 |
The threshold applies to the total value of the moral payment in each case. You cannot split a payment to avoid applying to the Commission. You must get its authority before making a payment above the threshold.
A charity in the lowest income band that wants to pay one person £2,000 cannot make two separate payments of £1,000.
The Secretary of State may change these sums by regulations.
Decide who makes the decision
You can delegate to others in the charity the decision on whether the moral obligation condition is met. You and the other trustees remain ultimately responsible for all decisions that are made. The right person or group depends on the charity's circumstances. For example, you may delegate to a sub-committee of trustees, the chief executive, a legacy officer or another employee.
You may limit the delegated authority. For example, you may:
- limit the total value of moral payments the delegate can make each year
- delegate only decisions that do not need Commission authority
- delegate only decisions that are not high risk or novel
You should record the decision to delegate and who the delegate is. Give the delegate terms of reference that set out what they can and cannot do, and have clear and robust reporting and review procedures. You must make sure that the person making a decision has authority to make it.
Reach and record the decision
You, or those with delegated authority, must be satisfied that the moral obligation condition is met. You must comply with your trustee duties when making decisions. You should take legal advice if you are unsure.
Legacy cases
Your charity is required to keep all legacies it receives. You can make a moral payment out of its share if both of these apply.
- There is clear evidence of the deceased's intentions.
- You are satisfied that the moral obligation condition is met.
Assess whether the will accurately represents the deceased's intentions. Disappointed relatives are not enough on their own to justify a moral payment. Where it is claimed that circumstances changed after the will was made, or that the deceased may have tried to make a new will, consider:
- the wording of the will
- any evidence of the deceased's true intentions, such as a draft will, an unexecuted codicil, or a written statement from an independent person (for example a solicitor)
- any evidence of why the deceased could not validly update the will, such as sudden illness, and of any opportunities to do so that were not taken
A statement by a person who believes they are morally entitled to a share is not normally enough on its own. It is not impartial evidence. If no stronger evidence is available, it may be enough if supported by a statutory declaration. The declaration must be signed in the presence of a solicitor, commissioner for oaths or notary public.
Other cases
You should consider appropriate evidence. For example, a donor may ask for a gift back because their situation has changed. Consider evidence from the donor explaining how and why their circumstances have changed, for example that making the gift has created financial difficulties.
Also consider evidence from third parties, such as a doctor's note saying the donor's health has deteriorated so that they can no longer work. In all cases, you may consider returning some or all of the gift.
Recording the decision
You, or those with delegated authority, should clearly record the decision and the reasons for it. Include all the evidence and factors considered. What you record depends on who decided.
- Where the trustees decide, you should record that you reasonably regard yourselves as being under a moral obligation to make the payment. Record it in a trustee resolution or the minutes of your trustee meeting.
- Where someone with delegated authority decides, they should record their belief that the trustees could reasonably be regarded as being under a moral obligation to pay. They should share the record with you as part of your reporting and accounting arrangements.
Apply to the Charity Commission for authority
The Commission, the Attorney General or the court may give the authority. This authority has no value limit.
Trustees, those with delegated authority, or their representatives can submit the online application. You cannot apply if you will benefit from the moral payment. The files must be in PDF format, and each file can be no bigger than 10MB.
Have ready for the application
The form times out if it is left inactive, and you lose what you have entered, so have everything ready before you start.
Apply for Charity Commission authority to make a moral payment (opens in a new tab)
After the Commission decides
If the Commission gives its authority, you should keep a copy of the order as part of the charity's records. It is evidence that the payment was authorised and may be needed by the charity's auditor or independent examiner.
The Commission must refer an application to the Attorney General if it considers that desirable. In a very limited number of cases, it refers the application to the Attorney General to decide directly.
If the Commission refuses the application, you may:
- apply to the First-tier Tribunal (Charity) to review the decision. The Tribunal can quash it and, if appropriate, send the matter back to the Commission. This applies to applications made on or after 27 November 2025
- apply directly to the Attorney General for authority, at ago.correspondence@attorneygeneral.gov.uk. A refusal by the Commission does not stop the Attorney General from authorising the action on a later application by the trustees
- apply to the court for approval, which is charity proceedings under the Charities Act 2011 and needs an order from the Commission. If the Commission refuses to make that order, you can ask a High Court judge for permission to bring the proceedings
Show moral payments in the accounts
If your charity prepares accruals accounts, they must give details of all moral payments made. Check the Charities SORP, which explains the accounting rules, or get professional advice.
If your charity prepares receipts and payments accounts, they should include details of all moral payments made. For example, include why you made the payment, its amount, and the power or authority for it.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations
Browse UK legislation (opens in a new tab) legislation.gov.uk