Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Compliance & Legal

Handle a licensing review in Scotland

A Licensing Board can review a premises licence and warn, vary, suspend or revoke it. It can also revoke, suspend or endorse a personal licence at a hearing. Respond at the hearing, and appeal to the sheriff principal or sheriff within 21 days of the decision.

Food, Drink & Hospitality Scotland

A Licensing Board can review any premises licence that has effect, and a review can end in a warning, a variation, a suspension or a revocation. A personal licence holder can also face a Board hearing, after a conviction or a finding made in a premises licence review.

Every review and hearing is judged against the five licensing objectives: preventing crime and disorder, securing public safety, preventing public nuisance, protecting and improving public health, and protecting children and young persons from harm. The Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 covers Scotland only.

How a premises licence review starts

Any person may apply to the Board for a review of a premises licence that has effect. The application must rest on one of three grounds:

  • the licence holder is not a fit and proper person to hold a premises licence, having regard to the licensing objectives
  • one or more of the licence conditions has been breached
  • any other ground relevant to one or more of the licensing objectives

The application must specify the alleged ground. For a breach of conditions it names the conditions alleged to have been breached. For the third ground it names the licensing objectives concerned. For the fit and proper ground it summarises the information the applicant relies on.

The Board may also propose a review itself, on the same grounds. Its proposal must specify the alleged ground.

Licensing Standards Officer notices and applications

A Licensing Standards Officer (LSO) who believes a licence condition has been or is being breached may issue the licence holder a notice requiring the action it specifies to remedy the breach. An LSO may apply for a review on the breach-of-conditions ground only if an LSO has issued that notice and the licence holder has failed to take the action in it to the officer's satisfaction. An LSO may apply on any other competent ground without issuing a notice first.

If the Board rejects an application

The Board may reject a review application it considers vexatious or frivolous, or one that discloses no matter relevant to any ground for review. It must give the applicant notice of the decision and the reasons for it.

Reviews that follow a conviction

If you hold a premises licence and are convicted of a relevant offence or a foreign offence, you must give the Board that issued the licence notice of the conviction. You must do so no later than one month after the date of conviction. Where an offence is relevant only because a prison sentence was imposed, the month runs from the date of sentence.

The notice states the offence and the date of conviction. It encloses the licence or, if that is not practicable, the reasons why not. Failing to give notice without reasonable excuse is an offence, punishable by a fine of up to level 4 on the standard scale.

You must also give notice of the conviction of a connected person if you are neither an individual nor a council, or if the premises are used wholly or mainly for a club. A connected person is a partner, a director or person with control of a company, or a club office bearer. For any other body, it is a person concerned in its management or control.

If you are charged with a relevant offence, you must produce the licence to the court, or tell it why that is not practicable, no later than your first or next appearance. Failing to do so without reasonable excuse is an offence, punishable by a fine of up to level 2.

A relevant offence is one listed in the Licensing (Relevant Offences) (Scotland) Regulations 2007, including violent and sexual offences, or any other offence for which a prison sentence was imposed. A foreign offence is an offence under the law of a place other than Scotland that is similar in nature to a relevant offence. A conviction that is spent under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 is disregarded. For a relevant offence, being placed on probation or discharged absolutely still counts as a conviction for the premises and personal licence notice duties and the Board's conviction procedures.

On receiving notice of a conviction, the Board must notify the chief constable. The chief constable has 21 days to respond. The response either confirms the conviction, or says the chief constable cannot confirm it or that it is not a relevant or foreign offence. What the Board does next depends on that response:

  • if the chief constable confirms the conviction and recommends that the licence be varied, suspended or revoked, the Board must make a review proposal
  • if the chief constable confirms the conviction without a recommendation, the Board must either make a review proposal or decide to take no further action
  • if the chief constable cannot confirm the conviction, or says it is not a relevant or foreign offence, the Board may not take further action

The review hearing

The Board must hold a review hearing on a proposal, or on an application it has not rejected. It must give notice of the hearing to the applicant, if there is one. It must also give notice, with a copy of the proposal or application, to the licence holder and to any LSO for the area of the premises, unless the LSO is the applicant. The hearing is to be held no later than 42 days after the Board made the proposal or received the application.

An LSO who receives a copy must prepare a report for the Board before the hearing, and the Board must take it into account. The Board may obtain further information from whoever it thinks fit, and may ask people to attend and produce documents. It may take into account any information relevant to any ground for review, even if it does not relate to the circumstances alleged.

The hearing must be held at a meeting of the Board. You may be represented by another person, but the Board may decline to hear a representative who cannot produce written authority when asked. The Board may relieve you of a failure to comply with a procedural provision if it is due to mistake, oversight or other excusable cause and the Board considers relief appropriate.

Before a review is determined, a constable or an LSO may enter the premises at any reasonable time, using reasonable force if necessary. They may do so to assess the effect that alcohol sales are having on the licensing objectives. Intentionally obstructing them is an offence, punishable by a fine of up to level 3.

What the Board can decide

If the Board is satisfied that a ground for review is established, it may take such of the following steps as it considers necessary or appropriate for the licensing objectives. It may do so whether or not on the basis of circumstances alleged in the proposal or application. It may also decide to take no step.

Step What it means
Written warning The Board issues the licence holder a warning in writing.
Variation The Board changes the licence. It may provide that the variation applies only for a period it determines.
Suspension The licence is suspended for a period the Board determines.
Revocation The licence ends. A revocation for not being fit and proper takes effect at the end of 28 days beginning with the day of the decision.

Recalling a fit and proper revocation

The Board must recall the revocation if an application is made within the 28 days and the Board grants it. The application must be one to transfer the licence, or for a variation the Board considers would remove the ground. The Board may extend the 28 days while it decides such an application. The right of appeal is unaffected.

Notice of the decision and reasons

The Board must give notice of its decision to the licence holder and, where the review arose from an application, to the applicant. This covers a warning, another step, no step and a revocation for not being fit and proper.

If the Board warned, varied, suspended or revoked the licence as one of the four steps, the licence holder may require a statement of reasons by notice to the clerk of the Board. The applicant may do the same where the decision arose from the applicant's application and was one of those steps or a decision to take no step. The right to reasons does not extend to a revocation on the fit and proper ground.

Ending a variation or suspension early

If the Board has varied or suspended your licence, you may apply to the Board to revoke the variation or suspension. The Board may do so only if satisfied that, by reason of a change of circumstances, the variation or suspension is no longer necessary. This covers variations and suspensions only, not warnings or revocations. The applicant may appeal a refusal to the sheriff principal.

Hearings about a personal licence

A Board can hold a hearing about a personal licence after a conviction, a finding in a premises licence review, a report on conduct, or a third endorsement. At a hearing after a conviction or a finding, the Board must give the licence holder an opportunity to be heard. After a conviction, it must also give the chief constable that opportunity. After a finding, it gives that opportunity to other people it considers appropriate.

Trigger Does the Board have to hold a hearing
The personal licence holder is convicted of a relevant or foreign offence Yes, if the chief constable confirms the conviction and recommends revocation, suspension or endorsement. If the chief constable confirms it without a recommendation, the Board must either hold a hearing or decide to take no further action. If the chief constable cannot confirm it, or says it is not a relevant or foreign offence, the Board may not take further action.
A premises licence review finds that the holder, while working in the premises, acted inconsistently with a licensing objective Yes. The Board that made the finding must hold the hearing if the holder is working in licensed premises in its area at the time of the finding. Otherwise it must notify the relevant Board of its finding with a recommendation, and that Board must hold the hearing.
The chief constable reports conduct inconsistent with the licensing objectives Yes.
An LSO reports conduct inconsistent with the licensing objectives No. The Board may hold a hearing.
Three endorsements have been made on the licence Yes. The issuing Board must hold a hearing.

If you hold a personal licence and are convicted of a relevant or foreign offence, you must give notice no later than one month after the conviction. The notice goes to the Board that issued the licence and, if different, the Board for the area of any licensed premises where you work. Failing to give notice without reasonable excuse is an offence, punishable by a fine of up to level 4. A conviction that is spent is disregarded.

Where the chief constable confirms a conviction and recommends action, the hearing is to be held no later than 42 days after the Board received the chief constable's notice. The 42 days do not run from your own notice of conviction.

After a conviction, the hearing is held by the Board for the area of the licensed premises where the holder works as a premises manager. In any other case it is held by the Board that issued the licence. For a finding in a premises licence review, the relevant Board is the one for the area where the finding Board has reason to believe the holder works. If there is none, it is the Board that issued the licence.

What the Board can order on a personal licence

After a conviction, a finding in a premises licence review, or a report from the chief constable or an LSO, the Board may make an order if satisfied it is necessary for the purposes of a licensing objective. The order may revoke the licence, suspend it for a period of not more than 6 months, or endorse it. The Board must revoke the licence if satisfied that the holder is not a fit and proper person to hold a personal licence. Whenever the Board makes an order, it must give the holder notice of the order and the reasons for it.

An endorsement expires 5 years after it was made. The holder may then apply to the issuing Board to have it removed, and the Board must remove it. An expired endorsement is disregarded whether or not removed.

At a hearing after three endorsements, the issuing Board may suspend the licence for not more than 6 months, or revoke it. It may do so only if it considers that necessary for the purposes of a licensing objective.

Appeals

An appeal goes to the sheriff principal or sheriff of the sheriffdom where the Board's principal office is. These decisions can be appealed:

Decision Who may appeal Appeal goes to
A warning, variation, suspension or revocation on a premises licence review The premises licence holder, or the applicant where the decision was taken in connection with a review application The sheriff principal
A refusal to revoke a variation or suspension of a premises licence The applicant The sheriff principal
An order revoking, suspending or endorsing a personal licence The personal licence holder The sheriff

The Act gives no right of appeal against a Board's decision to take no step after a review hearing, or against its rejection of a review application.

An appeal can argue that the Board erred in law, based its decision on an incorrect material fact, acted contrary to natural justice, or exercised its discretion in an unreasonable manner. Against a warning, variation, suspension or revocation on a review, or an order revoking, suspending or endorsing a personal licence, it can also argue that the step taken is disproportionate in all the circumstances.

The court may hear evidence. If it upholds the appeal, it may remit the case to the Board for reconsideration, reverse the decision, or substitute a decision the Board could have made.

An appeal is made by summary application, lodged with the sheriff clerk of the sheriff court district in which the Board's principal office is situated.

Your licence while you appeal

A Board decision continues to have effect despite an appeal. There is one exception. Where the appeal is against a decision to suspend or revoke a premises licence, the sheriff principal may recall the suspension or revocation until the appeal is decided. This needs the appellant's application. The sheriff principal must be satisfied on the balance of convenience that recall is appropriate. The Act gives no equivalent power for orders on a personal licence.

Any party may appeal on a point of law to the Court of Session against the decision of the sheriff principal or sheriff.

  1. Read the notice and the copy of the proposal or application

    Note the ground alleged and the hearing date, which is to be no later than 42 days after the Board made the proposal or received the application.

  2. Prepare to answer the licensing objectives as well as the allegation

    The Board may take into account information relevant to any ground for review, even if it does not relate to the circumstances alleged. Give any representative written authority.

  3. Ask for a statement of reasons where the Act gives you the right

    Give notice to the clerk of the Board. The right does not cover a revocation on the fit and proper ground.

  4. Decide whether to appeal and lodge within 21 days of the decision

    Against a premises licence suspension or revocation, you can apply to the sheriff principal to recall it while the appeal is heard.

Official guidance