Work out which notifications apply
Separate sets of rules require you to notify the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) before work starts. The Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002 (COSHH) cover biological agents in hazard groups 2, 3 and 4. The Genetically Modified Organisms (Contained Use) Regulations 2014 cover contained use of genetically modified organisms (GMOs).
Both apply in England, Wales and Scotland and do not extend to Northern Ireland. HSE is the regulator throughout Great Britain.
Find the hazard group of your biological agent
Group 1 agents are unlikely to cause human disease and fall outside the notification duties. HSE publishes the Approved List of biological agents, which gives each listed agent its approved classification. If an agent has no approved classification, you must provisionally classify it by its risk of infection. If you are in doubt between two groups, you must assign the higher one.
If an agent with an approved classification poses a different risk of infection from the one expected, you must reclassify it in consultation with HSE.
Notify HSE before first using a Group 2, 3 or 4 biological agent
The duty applies to these activities:
- research, development, teaching or diagnostic work in laboratories involving a Group 2, 3 or 4 biological agent or material containing one
- work with animals deliberately infected with such an agent, or which are or are suspected of being naturally infected with one
- industrial processes involving such an agent
An employer must not use a Group 2, 3 or 4 biological agent for the first time at particular premises for any of those activities unless, before starting, the employer has:
- notified HSE in writing at least 20 working days in advance, or such shorter period as HSE allows
- included the particulars in the notification
- received HSE's acknowledgement
For this duty, employer includes anyone else carrying out the consignment, storage or use of the agent. The duty is premises by premises: first use at a second site needs its own notification.
HSE says that holding an agent in a culture collection usually needs notification. HSE's reason is that maintaining the collection is likely to involve growing the agent.
The notification must contain:
- the employer's name and address, and the address of the premises where the agent will be stored or used
- the name, qualifications and relevant experience of any employee with specific responsibility for the health and safety of fellow employees
- the results of the risk assessment
- the identity of the agent and, if it has no approved classification, the group you assigned
- the preventive and protective measures that will be taken
Within 20 working days of receiving the notification, HSE must either send an acknowledgement or tell you in writing which further particulars it needs. If it asks for more, it must acknowledge within 10 working days of receiving them.
CBA1 notification form and guidance notes (HSE) (opens in a new tab)
HSE's CBA1 notes say to send the form at least 20 days ahead, but the period in COSHH is 20 working days. HSE's page on safe deliberate work with biological agents speaks of obtaining clearance or consent. The COSHH duty is to notify, supply the particulars and receive the acknowledgement, and Schedule 3 sets no consent step.
Notify later use of a Part V agent
An employer must not use a Part V agent for laboratory research, development, teaching or diagnostic work, work with infected animals or industrial processes, except where its use is already covered by a first-use notification, unless before starting the employer has:
- notified HSE in writing at least 20 working days in advance, or such shorter period as HSE allows
- included the particulars required for a first-use notification
- received HSE's acknowledgement
The Part V agents are any Group 3 or 4 agent and these Group 2 agents: Bordetella pertussis, Corynebacterium diphtheriae and Neisseria meningitidis. HSE may accept a single notification covering more than one agent used by the same person.
Cases where first-use and Part V notification are not required
An employer need not notify first use of a Group 2 or 3 agent, or use of a Part V agent, if both of these apply:
- the employer's only use of the agent is to provide a diagnostic service, meaning analysing specimens or samples from a human patient or animal solely to assess the clinical progress, or assist the clinical management, of that patient or animal
- the use will not involve a process likely to propagate, concentrate or otherwise increase the risk of exposure to the agent
First use of a Group 4 agent is not exempt on this ground.
The notification duties for first use and Part V agents also do not apply to a biological agent where its use was previously notified under the Genetically Modified Organisms (Contained Use) Regulations 2000. Those Regulations are revoked and the COSHH text still names them. HSE's CBA1 notes say that no further notification under COSHH is required if you have already notified under the GMO Regulations.
Notify consignment of a Group 4 agent
An employer must not consign a Group 4 biological agent, or anything containing or suspected of containing one, to any other premises unless the employer has:
- notified HSE in writing at least 30 days in advance, or before such shorter time as HSE approves
- sent with the notification the consignment particulars
The consignment particulars are:
- the identity of the agent and the volume of the consignment
- the consignor and consignee, and the premises it will travel from and to
- the transport operator and any individual accompanying the consignment
- the method of transport, the packaging and containment precautions, the route and the proposed date
The duty applies whether or not the receiving premises are under the employer's ownership or control. For a Group 4 agent imported into Great Britain, the consignee gives the notice.
The duty does not apply where:
- the agent or material is consigned solely for diagnosis
- material is consigned solely for disposal
- the agent is or is suspected of being present in a patient or animal being transported for medical treatment
Tell HSE when the work changes
Where changes to processes, procedures or the biological agent are of importance to health or safety at work and render the original notification invalid, the employer must notify HSE in writing straight away.
Notify the premises before any contained use of GMOs
Contained use is any activity in which organisms are genetically modified or GMOs are cultured, stored, transported, destroyed, disposed of or otherwise used. Barriers limit their contact with people and the environment. It covers any premises, meaning a single building or a site of more than one building.
A larger GMO is a genetically modified organism that is not a micro-organism, such as a plant or an animal. Contained use of a micro-organism is assigned a class from 1 (no or negligible risk) to 4 (high risk).
For contained use, the 2014 Regulations treat an educational establishment providing a course of study as an employer for the general duties in sections 2 and 7 of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. A student undertaking contained use under its control counts as its employee.
Cases the 2014 Regulations do not cover include:
- genetic modification solely by mutagenesis or certain cell fusion techniques, provided no recombinant nucleic acid molecules or other GMOs are involved
- self-cloning where the resulting organism is unlikely to cause disease or harm to humans, animals or plants, on the same proviso
- GMOs that are, or are contained in, a product marketed with consent under section 111(1) of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, where the activity follows any conditions or limitations of that consent
- GMOs that are, or are contained in, a marketed veterinary medicine, authorised GM food or feed, or a marketed human medicine
For the mutagenesis, cell fusion and self-cloning cases, a user must still reduce the risks to the lowest level that is reasonably practicable.
For transport of GMOs by road, rail, inland waterway, sea or air, these duties do not apply:
- the notification, consent, change and information-request duties
- the review and record-keeping of the risk assessment
- the containment measures
The risk assessment, advice on it, emergency plan, accident reporting and the duty to reduce risks to the lowest reasonably practicable level still apply to transport.
A user must not use premises for contained use unless the premises have been notified. Before premises are used for contained use for the first time, a person responsible for the contained use must:
- submit a notification containing the Schedule 5 information to the competent authority
- have received HSE's acknowledgement of receipt
This applies whatever the class of the contained use, including class 1 and larger GMO work. HSE must send the acknowledgement within 10 working days of the competent authority receiving the notification. The same period applies to each class 2, class 3 or 4 and larger GMO notification.
The person responsible is whoever has authority to decide whether the contained use takes place, or controls its planning or conduct. That person can differ from the user, and there can be more than one. One notification can cover several premises, and the notifier nominates one principal address.
Send everything to HSE at the address on its website. The competent authority is the Secretary of State and HSE acting jointly for England and Wales. For Scotland it is the Scottish Ministers and HSE acting jointly. A notification covering premises in both Scotland and England or Wales goes to the joint competent authority.
HSE says its CU1 and CU2 forms are not a legal requirement, though they are designed to make sure the necessary information is sent. HSE's guidance also says that, after acknowledging receipt, it will give final clearance within 45 days. The Regulations require only the acknowledgement before first use and set no 45-day period for premises.
Assess the risk and get advice before contained use starts
Before any contained use involving micro-organisms starts, a person responsible must ensure a suitable and sufficient assessment of the risks to human health and the environment is carried out. For larger GMOs the assessment covers risks to human health.
A person responsible must also obtain advice on the risk assessment from a person or a genetic modification safety committee, either with expertise in risk assessment relating to contained use. Where the risk assessment classifies the contained use as class 2 or above, the advice must come from a committee.
A person responsible must review the risk assessment immediately if there is reason to suspect it is no longer valid or the contained use has significantly changed. The record of the assessment and each review must be kept for at least 10 years from the date the contained use stops. It must be made available to the competent authority on request.
Prepare an emergency plan where the assessment requires one
A person responsible must ensure a suitable emergency plan is prepared before the contained use starts where the risk assessment shows that a reasonably foreseeable accident:
- is liable to seriously affect the health or safety of people outside the premises
- for micro-organisms only, risks serious damage to the environment
The plan must include the measures to be taken in an accident and be reviewed, and revised where necessary, at suitably regular intervals. A person responsible must tell the emergency services, and any body or authority an accident could affect, what the plan and any revisions contain, and make information about them publicly available.
Notify each class of contained use and wait
Class 1 contained use needs the premises notification and no separate activity notification.
Class 2
A user must not undertake a class 2 contained use unless a person responsible has submitted a notification containing the Schedule 6 information. The user may then start:
- where the premises have not previously been notified for class 2 or a higher class, 45 days after the acknowledgement was received unless the competent authority has said the use may not be undertaken, or sooner if the competent authority agrees in writing
- where the premises have previously been notified for class 2, or already have consent for class 3 or 4, once the acknowledgement has been received
For a second or later class 2 contained use at the premises, the notifier may ask for the competent authority's written agreement. The competent authority must decide within 45 days of the date the acknowledgement was sent.
Class 3 or 4
A user must not undertake a class 3 or 4 contained use unless the competent authority has granted written consent on a Schedule 6 notification from a person responsible. The competent authority must tell the notifier in writing whether it grants or refuses consent:
- within 90 days of the date the acknowledgement was sent, where the premises have not previously been notified for class 3 or 4
- within 45 days of that date, where the premises were previously notified for class 3 or 4 and all relevant conditions of existing consents have been complied with
Before deciding, the competent authority must take into account any representations made by anyone within 30 days of the date the acknowledgement was sent. Consent can carry conditions.
Larger GMOs
A user must not undertake a contained use involving larger GMOs unless a person responsible has submitted a Schedule 6 notification. The user may then start:
- 45 days after the acknowledgement was received, unless the competent authority has said the use may not be undertaken
- sooner, if the competent authority agrees in writing
This does not apply to a contained use that results in a larger GMO posing no greater risk to humans than its unmodified parental organism. That work needs no notification of its own: the premises notification covers it.
When HSE asks for more information
A request for additional information must be made in writing. The days between HSE's request and its receipt of all the information do not count towards the 45 or 90 days. HSE must acknowledge within 10 working days of receiving all of it.
If HSE asks before the contained use starts, the user must not start until the competent authority approves in writing. If the contained use has already started, the user may not continue it until the competent authority approves, except as far as needed to store or destroy the resulting GMOs. The notifier and any user must follow any HSE instruction to stop.
The competent authority may return a notification if the information is not provided within six months and the contained use has not started. A notifier may withdraw a notification in writing only if the contained use has not started.
Keep HSE informed after you notify
Changes to the notification
The original notifier, or a person responsible for the notified premises or contained use, must immediately send the competent authority full details in writing of any of the following:
- a change to the notifier's contact details, the arrangements for advice on risk assessments or the premises address and description
- a change to the named person responsible for supervision and safety, or that person's training and qualifications
- a new building under the notifier's control added to notified premises, or additional premises used for a single contained use covered by a single notification
- notified premises no longer used for contained use, all contained use stopping for the time being and any recommencement, or a notified contained use stopping
Significant changes and new information
After notifying, a notifier must immediately send the competent authority full details in writing of any change to the premises or the contained use, or any new information, that may have significant consequences for the risks.
If the change or information does not affect the class of the contained use, no further notification is needed for the class 2, class 3 or 4 or larger GMO contained use and it is treated as a modification of the original notification.
Accidents
An accident is a significant and unintended release of GMOs during contained use that presents an immediate or delayed hazard to human health or the environment. If one occurs, a person responsible must immediately inform the competent authority and provide:
- the circumstances, and the identity and quantity of the GMOs concerned
- the information needed to assess the effects on the health of the general population and, for a micro-organism, on the environment
- the measures taken in response
Notices from the competent authority and appeals
The competent authority may at any time give written notice to:
- set a time limit or conditions for a contained use
- require a contained use to be suspended, ended or not started
- revoke or vary a class 3 or 4 consent
The notifier and any user must comply.
A person responsible who is aggrieved by a notice of that kind may appeal to the Secretary of State. The same applies to a refusal of class 3 or 4 consent, a request for more information, an instruction to stop, or a refusal of written agreement for a class 2 use. For Scotland, or where the joint competent authority made the decision, the appeal goes to the Secretary of State and the Scottish Ministers jointly. An appeal does not suspend a notice, and appeal time does not count towards the 45 and 90 days.
Fees
A fee is payable on a GMO premises, class 2, class 3 or 4 or larger GMO notification. It is also payable on a notification of a significant change or new information affecting risks. Schedule 9 of the Health and Safety and Nuclear (Fees) Regulations 2022 sets the amounts, which are re-set from time to time. Where a premises notification is made at the same time as an activity notification, only the activity fee is payable. No fee is returned if the notifier withdraws a notification or the competent authority returns it.
What a breach risks
Contravening the COSHH notification duties or the GMO Regulations is an offence under section 33(1)(c) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. In England and Wales the fine on summary conviction has no upper limit for offences committed on or after 12 March 2015. Scotland keeps a cap.
| Where | On summary conviction | On conviction on indictment |
|---|---|---|
| England and Wales | Imprisonment up to the general limit in a magistrates' court, which is 12 months, or an unlimited fine, or both. For an offence committed before 2 May 2022, the limit is 6 months | Up to 2 years in prison, or a fine, or both |
| Scotland | Up to 12 months in prison, or a fine of up to £20,000, or both | Up to 2 years in prison, or a fine, or both |
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations
Official guidance
HSE: The Approved List of biological agents (opens in a new tab)
HSE · Great Britain
HSE: GMO notification fees (opens in a new tab)
HSE · Great Britain
HSE: What work with GMOs requires notification (opens in a new tab)
HSE · Great Britain
HSE: Safe deliberate work with biological agents (opens in a new tab)
HSE · Great Britain
HSE: genetically modified organisms (contained use) (opens in a new tab)
HSE · Great Britain