Follow @guvnor.ai on TikTok (opens in a new tab)

Tax & Finance

Challenge an FCA warning, decision or supervisory notice

A warning notice from the FCA is a proposal, and you can make representations within the period it gives. A decision notice, or a supervisory notice, can be referred to the Upper Tribunal, which must receive your form no later than 28 days after notice of the decision was given.

Professional & Financial Services UK-wide

The FCA gives an authorised firm, or an applicant for permission, a warning notice, a decision notice or a supervisory notice. A warning notice is a proposal, and you answer it with representations. A decision notice records a decision, and you refer it to the Upper Tribunal if you disagree.

Work out which notice you hold

Routes, notices and rights

Route Notices the FCA gives Who may refer to the Tribunal FCA material (section 394) and third-party copies (section 393)
Refusing an application, or granting or varying permission on application with limits or requirements (section 55X) A warning notice, then a decision notice An applicant aggrieved by the determination of its application Neither applies
Cancelling a permission otherwise than at your request (section 55Z) A warning notice, then a decision notice An authorised person aggrieved by the FCA's use of its own-initiative variation power, which includes the power to cancel Both apply
Varying a permission, or imposing or varying a requirement, on the FCA's own initiative (sections 55J, 55L and 55Y) A supervisory notice (section 55Y) An authorised person aggrieved by the FCA's use of its own-initiative variation or requirement power Neither applies
Disciplinary action against an authorised person: a public statement, a penalty, or suspension of a permission or a restriction (sections 207 and 208) A warning notice, then a decision notice The authorised person Both apply

A warning notice carries no right to refer. The right to refer arises on a decision notice or on a supervisory notice. The warning notice duty for cancellation covers only cancellation otherwise than at your request, and the refusal route does not apply to applications to which section 55XA applies, which are applications about administering a benchmark.

The own-initiative variation power in section 55J includes cancellation, and section 55Y applies to an exercise of that power. Yet section 55Y(4) speaks of varying a permission and of imposing or varying a requirement. Under section 55Z, cancelling a permission otherwise than at your request needs a warning notice and a decision notice. Read the notice you hold.

Make representations on a warning notice

A warning notice must be in writing, give reasons, state the action proposed and say whether section 394 applies. It must give you a reasonable period, never less than 14 days, in which you may make representations to the FCA. The FCA may extend that period.

Once the period for representations has ended, the FCA must decide within a reasonable period whether to give a decision notice.

A disciplinary warning notice must set out the terms of any proposed public statement. If it proposes a penalty, it must state the amount. If it proposes suspension of a permission or a restriction, it must state how long that is to have effect.

Ask for the FCA's material

Access under section 394 applies only to the warning and decision notices listed in section 392. They do not include a refusal under section 55X or a supervisory notice under section 55Y.

Where it applies, the FCA must allow you access to the material it relied on in taking the decision behind the notice. It must also allow access to any secondary material that, in its opinion, might undermine that decision. Secondary material is material the FCA considered but did not rely on, or obtained in connection with the matter but did not consider.

The FCA does not have to give access to excluded material: material whose disclosure in legal proceedings section 56 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 prohibits, or a protected item as defined in section 413 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA). Nor does it have to give access to material about another person's case that it used in yours only for comparison.

The FCA may refuse access to particular material if, in its opinion, access would not be in the public interest or would not be fair. Fairness depends on the material's significance to you and the potential prejudice to someone else's commercial interests. A refusal must be in writing with reasons. If the FCA withholds a protected item, it must tell you in writing that the item exists and that it will not allow access.

If a notice about someone else names you

Where a reason in a warning notice or decision notice identifies you and, in the FCA's opinion, is prejudicial to you, the FCA must give you a copy. This applies only to the notices listed in section 392, so a refusal or supervisory notice is never copied under this rule. No copy is needed if the FCA has given you, or gives you at the same time, a separate notice on the same matter, or if it considers a copy impracticable.

A copy of a warning notice must give you a reasonable period of at least 14 days to make representations. Every copy must describe how section 394 applies to you, and you must be sent any notice of discontinuance.

Where the person who received the decision notice has a right to refer, you may refer the decision so far as it rests on the reason identifying you, or any opinion the FCA expressed about you. You may do the same, and refer the alleged failure, if you say a copy should have been given to you but was not. The decision notice referred is the one copied to you, or the one you say should have been copied.

Decision notices, discontinuance and final notices

If the FCA decides to act, it gives a decision notice. The notice must be in writing, give reasons, say whether section 394 applies, and indicate any right to refer to the Tribunal and the procedure on a reference. Where a warning notice came first, the decision notice must relate to action under the same Part of FSMA as the action proposed.

Before it acts, the FCA may give a further decision notice for different action on the same matter, but only with your consent. The right to refer carries over.

For disciplinary action, the FCA must give the decision notice without delay once it decides to publish a statement, impose a penalty or suspend a permission or impose a restriction. The penalty power in section 206 sets no upper limit: if the FCA considers that an authorised person has contravened a relevant requirement, it may impose a penalty of such amount as it considers appropriate.

If the FCA decides not to take the action in a warning notice or decision notice, it must give a notice of discontinuance. The exception is where discontinuing results in the FCA granting your own application.

If a decision notice is not referred within the time the Tribunal Rules require, the FCA must give a final notice when it takes the action. A final notice about a penalty gives a payment period of at least 14 days beginning with the date the final notice is given. An unpaid penalty is recoverable as a debt.

The FCA must not take the action in a decision notice while the period for referring is running. If you refer the matter, it must not act until the reference and any appeal against the Tribunal's decision are finally disposed of.

Supervisory notices

If the FCA proposes to vary a permission or impose or vary a requirement on its own initiative, or does so with immediate effect, it must give the firm a written notice. The grounds for the own-initiative variation power include that it appears to the FCA that:

  • you are failing, or are likely to fail, to satisfy the threshold conditions for which the FCA is responsible
  • you have failed, during a period of at least 12 months, to carry on a regulated activity to which the permission relates
  • it is desirable to use the power to advance one or more of the FCA's operational objectives

The notice must give details and the FCA's reasons. It must say that you may make representations within the period the notice specifies, whether or not you have already referred the matter to the Tribunal, and when the variation or requirement takes effect. It must also state your right to refer. The FCA may extend the period for representations.

The FCA may expressly make a variation or requirement take effect immediately, or on a specified date, only if it reasonably considers that necessary, having regard to the ground it relies on. If the notice gives no date, the variation or requirement takes effect when the matter is no longer open to review. A matter is open to review while the period for referring is running, a reference is undecided, the period for an appeal is running, or an appeal is undetermined.

After considering your representations, the FCA must give you written notice of its decision. If it goes ahead as proposed, or does not rescind a variation or requirement already in effect, the notice must state your right to refer. A notice of a different variation or requirement must give the same details, reasons and rights as the first notice.

How the FCA decides and what it says about its process

The FCA must decide its procedure so that a decision giving rise to a warning, decision or supervisory notice is taken by a person not directly involved in establishing the evidence. Two or more people may take it, if one of them was not directly involved. For a supervisory notice, the procedure may instead let a person of a set level of seniority decide, if the FCA considers that necessary in the case to advance an operational objective. The FCA must publish a statement of its procedure and follow it. A failure to follow it does not affect a notice's validity, but the Tribunal may take it into account.

The FCA says the Regulatory Decisions Committee (RDC) is a committee of its Board that takes contested enforcement decisions on its behalf. It lists the RDC's warning notices as proposals for a prohibition, a financial penalty or public censure, or a suspension or restriction, and says it may occasionally deal with supervisory notices connected with enforcement action. For a warning notice the RDC issues, the FCA says that, if you need more time, you should contact the Decision-Making Committees Secretariat before the deadline in the notice expires, say why and say how much. It also says the RDC chair or a deputy decides, that long extensions are unlikely unless the circumstances are exceptional, and that extensions are generally limited to a few days or weeks and almost never exceed 2 to 3 months.

The FCA also says that, for a warning notice the RDC issues, you can refer the matter directly to the Upper Tribunal instead of making representations. It calls this an expedited reference. The FCA says you must notify the RDC that you want one and that you waive, and will not exercise, any rights under section 387(2) of FSMA, including the right to make representations. The RDC then issues a decision notice, subject to the interests of any third parties, and the statutory right to refer arises on that notice.

What can be published

Neither the FCA nor anyone given or copied a warning notice may publish it. For most warning notices, neither the FCA nor a person given or copied the notice may publish any details of it either. For a disciplinary warning notice, the FCA may, after consulting those given or copied the notice, publish the information about the matter that it considers appropriate. A person given or copied the notice may then publish only the details the FCA has published. A person given or copied a decision notice may not publish it or any details unless the FCA has.

The FCA must publish the information about the matter that it considers appropriate when it gives a decision notice or final notice, and when a supervisory notice takes effect. It may not publish if, in its opinion, publication would be unfair to the person concerned, prejudicial to consumers' interests or detrimental to the stability of the UK financial system. These limits apply to everything the FCA publishes about a notice under section 391, including information about a disciplinary warning notice.

Refer the decision to the Upper Tribunal

You may refer a decision notice, or a supervisory notice, directly to the Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber).

The 28 days run from when notice of the decision was given. HM Courts & Tribunals Service (HMCTS) guidance counts them from the date you received the decision notice.

HMCTS says a late form must request an extension with reasons, and that unless the judge grants it the reference will not be accepted.

Form FTC3 is the reference notice. You or your representative must sign it, and it must state:

  • your name and address
  • your representative's name and address if you have one, or otherwise an address where documents can be sent to you
  • the issues you want the Tribunal to consider

Send a copy of the notice you are referring with it, unless you are a third party saying a copy was never given to you. At the same time, send a copy of the reference notice to the FCA. If the notice states that the PRA or the Bank of England decided to refuse a consent, give a conditional consent or direct another regulator, send a copy to each regulator concerned.

What the Tribunal does with a reference

After a reference, the steps and time limits are:

  • The FCA must send a statement of case, with a list of the documents it relies on and of any further material that might in its opinion undermine the decision. The Tribunal must receive it no later than 28 days after the FCA received the Tribunal's notification.
  • You must send a written reply with a list of the documents you rely on. The Tribunal must receive it no later than 28 days after you received the statement of case or an amended one.
  • The FCA must then list any further material that might reasonably be expected to assist your case. The Tribunal must receive that list no later than 14 days after the FCA received your reply.

On request, a party that has listed a document it holds must provide a copy or make it available for inspection or copying. If it does not hold the document, it must say where, to the best of its knowledge, it can be found. A protected item is not covered. A party may apply to the Tribunal, without notice to the other side, to leave a document off its list because disclosure would not be in the public interest or would not be fair. The Tribunal may extend or shorten these times.

The Tribunal may consider any evidence relating to the subject-matter of the reference, whether or not the FCA had it. On a disciplinary reference, or a third party's reference about a copy it was not given, it must decide what action, if any, is appropriate and remit the matter with any directions needed. On any other reference, including a refusal, a cancellation or an own-initiative variation or requirement, it must either dismiss the reference or remit the matter with a direction to reconsider in accordance with its findings. Those findings are limited to issues of fact or law, matters to be taken into account or left out, and procedural steps.

On a disciplinary reference or a third party's reference about a copy it was not given, the Tribunal may not direct the FCA to take action under a different Part of FSMA from the action proposed in the warning notice. The FCA must act in accordance with the Tribunal's determination and directions. A Tribunal order may be enforced as if it were an order of:

  • the county court, in England and Wales
  • a county court, in Northern Ireland
  • the Court of Session, in Scotland

In a financial services case, the Tribunal may direct that the effect of the decision you have referred is suspended until the reference is determined. It may do so only if satisfied that suspension would not prejudice the interests of people the notice is intended to protect, the smooth operation or integrity of any market it is intended to protect, or the stability of the UK financial system.

Appeal on a point of law

Any party may appeal a decision of the Upper Tribunal on a point of law, but only with permission. Some decisions are excluded from appeal, such as a decision to review, or not to review, an earlier decision or to set one aside. You apply to the Upper Tribunal first, and may ask the appeal court for permission only if the Upper Tribunal refused it. The Upper Tribunal names the appeal court: the Court of Appeal in England and Wales, the Court of Session or the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland, whichever appears to it most appropriate.

The Upper Tribunal must receive your application for permission to appeal within 14 days after the date it sent you written notice of its decision. The same period runs from notification of amended reasons or a correction following a review, or of an unsuccessful application to set the decision aside. A late application must include a request for an extension and the reason it was late, and the Upper Tribunal must refuse it unless it extends time.

Official guidance