A Gateway 2 application is a building control approval application to the Building Safety Regulator for work to build a higher-risk building or make a building into one, for a stage of that work, or for work to an existing higher-risk building. The routes for challenging the outcome apply in England only. They do not cover work for which the local authority stayed the building control authority because, before 1 October 2023, an initial notice was accepted or treated as accepted, or full plans were deposited with it.
A rejection can be reviewed and then appealed. A failure to decide in time can be taken to the Secretary of State.
A relevant day is any day except Christmas Day, Good Friday or a bank holiday in England and Wales. Weekends count towards the 21-relevant-day limits.
| What has happened | Route | Who can use it | Time limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| The regulator has rejected the application | A review by the regulator, then an appeal to the First-tier Tribunal | For the review, the person who made the application or the person on whose behalf it was made. For the appeal, the person the regulator notifies of its review decision | Review notice within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the rejection is notified. Appeal within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the regulator notifies its review decision |
| The regulator has not determined a valid application in time | An application to the Secretary of State to determine it, then an appeal to the First-tier Tribunal against that decision | The client for the work | Application no later than 6 weeks after the day the relevant period for the regulator's decision ends, after at least 2 working days' notice (not counting Saturdays, Sundays, Christmas Day, Good Friday or bank holidays in England and Wales) to the regulator. Appeal within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the Secretary of State gives the decision to the applicant |
Which notice the regulator has given
Of the decisions on a Gateway 2 application, only a rejection can be reviewed.
A rejection
The regulator must grant approval for work to build a higher-risk building or make a building into one, or a stage of that work, unless the application, or a document that accompanied it, fails one of these tests:
- it does not comply with the rules on what an application must contain, or with a direction
- it is not detailed enough to let the regulator decide whether the work would contravene an applicable requirement of the building regulations
- it shows that the work would contravene an applicable requirement of the building regulations
- it shows that the strategies, policies or procedures for the work, including those on controlled changes, mandatory occurrence reporting, competence, and information sharing and co-operation, would contravene, or be likely to contravene, the rules on changes to documents or persons, the golden thread, mandatory occurrence reporting, or dutyholders and competence
For work to an existing higher-risk building, the tests also include a failure to provide a document the regulator requested and, where the application gives details of work the client considers amounts to 15% of the work, the regulator's opinion that it does not.
If one of the tests applies, the regulator may reject the application. It may instead grant approval subject to requirements, but only with the applicant's written consent. A rejection notice must give the reasons for rejection. A notice granting approval subject to a requirement must specify the requirement.
Before starting work to build a higher-risk building or make a building into one, or a stage of that work, the client must be granted building control approval for it.
A notice that the application is not valid
Where an application is not valid, the regulator must notify the applicant and give reasons, and send a copy to the client where the applicant is not the client. The regulations treat this as a separate step from rejection. A not-valid notice is not among the decisions that can be reviewed. No application to the Secretary of State can be made once the regulator has notified that the original application is not valid.
The Building Safety Regulator says that where information is missing the regulator may ask for it or reject the application. Under the regulations, an application that lacks required content can lead either to a notice that it is not valid or to a rejection, and only a rejection can be reviewed. Check which of the two your notice says.
Approval subject to requirements
A decision to grant approval subject to requirements is not among the decisions that can be reviewed. The same is true of a decision not to approve a plan or document where approval was granted subject to a requirement that work not go beyond a certain point until it is approved. For that decision the regulator must give its reasons if asked.
The client may ask the regulator to vary a requirement by a notice in writing signed by the client. The notice must include:
- the client's name, address and telephone number, and email address if available
- a statement that the notice is given under regulation 30
- a description of the proposed variation and the reasons for it
- the name and occupation of each person, if any, whose advice was sought on the variation, and a summary of that advice
If someone gives the notice on the client's behalf, it must include a statement signed by the client agreeing to the notice being given and confirming that its information is correct.
If the regulator has not decided within 28 days of receiving the notice, or within a longer period agreed in writing, the variation is treated as refused. The client who made the request can require the regulator to review a decision to refuse it. The review notice must be given in writing to the regulator within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the decision is notified, and must contain the same information as a review notice for a rejection.
Ask the regulator to review a rejection
If you made an application, or it was made on your behalf, you may require the regulator to review its decision to reject it. The notice must be in writing to the regulator within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the rejection is notified to you. After a rejection, a review is the only way to reach the Tribunal: the right of appeal can be exercised only if the decision has been reviewed.
The Building Safety Regulator says your decision letter includes the details of how to request a review.
The review notice must contain:
- the contact details of the person giving it, and details of the building, including its address
- where it is given on behalf of another person, that person's name and address and a statement of authority
- a statement identifying the decision, with its date and reference number if there is one, and the reasons the person considers it should be reviewed
- any information available to the person that may have been relevant to the original decision but was not available when it was made
The regulator decides the nature and extent of the review. It must take account of representations and information given at a stage that gives it a reasonable opportunity to consider them. At the end of the review it must uphold or vary the decision.
The regulator must notify the outcome within 13 weeks beginning with the day after the day the review notice is given, or within another period agreed in writing. If it upholds the decision, its notice must give reasons. If it varies the decision, it must issue a new decision. It must give you a paper copy of the review decision if you ask for one.
If the regulator does not notify the outcome in time, the review is treated as concluded and the decision as upheld. The regulator must then tell you as soon as reasonably practicable.
Apply to the Secretary of State when the regulator has not decided
For a valid application, the regulator must determine it within one of these periods, beginning with the date it receives the application:
- 12 weeks for work to build a higher-risk building, to make an existing building into one (including by a change of use), or a stage of that work
- 8 weeks for other work to an existing higher-risk building
A longer period applies if the regulator and the applicant agree it in writing at any time. The relevant period is the period the regulations give for the decision, or that agreed longer period.
If the regulator has not determined the application within the relevant period, the client for the work may apply to the Secretary of State for the application to be determined. The client may do so only if the regulator has still not determined it. The client cannot do so if the regulator has notified that the application is not valid. A person acting for the client needs the client's signed statement.
The client must:
- apply in writing, on the form the Secretary of State publishes, with the documents the regulations list
- apply no later than 6 weeks after the day the relevant period ends
- give the regulator notice of the intention to apply at least 2 working days (not counting Saturdays, Sundays, Christmas Day, Good Friday or bank holidays in England and Wales) before submitting the application
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) says applicants must email hrb.non-determinations@communities.gov.uk for full instructions on how to submit a non-determination application.
Once the application to the Secretary of State is made, the regulator may not determine the original application. MHCLG says the applicant can then neither agree a new extension with the regulator nor have the application returned to it.
The Secretary of State decides the application on written representations. The regulator must be given the opportunity to make written representations, and the decision is given in writing to the applicant. The Secretary of State may appoint a person to determine the application. MHCLG says there is no statutory timeframe for the decision.
Appeal to the First-tier Tribunal
After a review, you may appeal to the First-tier Tribunal against the decision within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the regulator notifies you of its review decision. If the review varied the decision, the appeal is against the decision as varied.
A client whose application to the Secretary of State has been decided may appeal to the First-tier Tribunal within 21 relevant days beginning with the day after the day the Secretary of State gives the decision to the applicant. That appeal does not need a review first.
On either appeal, the Tribunal may allow the appeal only if the decision:
- was based on an error of fact
- was wrong in law
- was unreasonable
- was made without following the procedures set out in the Building Act 1984 or in regulations made under it
If the Tribunal allows an appeal, it may quash or vary the decision.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations