What a listed building enforcement notice says
A planning authority can serve a listed building enforcement notice under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) (Scotland) Act 1997 (the 1997 Act) where works to a listed building in its district have been or are being carried out without the listed building consent they need, or in breach of a condition of consent. It does so only if it considers a notice expedient, having regard to the effect on the building's character as one of special architectural or historic interest.
The notice states the alleged contravention. It requires works to cease, specified steps to be taken, or both. The steps can restore the building to its former state, or bring it to the state it would have been in had the terms of a listed building consent been complied with. If the authority considers restoration not reasonably practicable or undesirable, the steps can instead be further works to alleviate the effect of the works carried out.
The notice must state the date it takes effect and a period for compliance. The effective date must be at least 28 days after the date the notice is served.
The planning authority can withdraw the notice, or waive or relax a requirement in it, including by extending the period for compliance. It can do so whether or not the notice has taken effect. It must immediately notify everyone it served, or would serve if it reissued the notice.
Who can appeal and by when
You can appeal to the Scottish Ministers if the notice was served on you, or if you have an interest in the building it relates to. You do not have to be the owner.
You can appeal at any time before the date the notice gives as the date it takes effect. There is no fixed number of days to appeal. The appeal must be made before that date. An appeal made on the effective date is too late.
What an appeal does to the notice
Where an appeal is brought under the Act, the notice has no effect pending the final determination or withdrawal of the appeal. An appeal does not authorise any works. Carrying out works to a listed building, or causing them to be carried out, without the listed building consent they need, or failing to comply with a condition of a consent under which you carry out or cause works, is a separate offence under section 8 of the 1997 Act. It is punishable on summary conviction by up to 6 months' imprisonment, a fine of up to £50,000 or both, and on conviction on indictment by up to 2 years' imprisonment, a fine or both.
It is a defence to prove all of these:
- the works were urgently necessary in the interests of safety or health, or for the preservation of the building
- it was not practicable to secure safety, health or preservation by works of repair or works for affording temporary support or shelter
- the works were limited to the minimum measures immediately necessary
- written notice justifying the works in detail was given to the planning authority as soon as reasonably practicable
Take advice before assuming that an appeal against the enforcement notice affects a stop notice.
Grounds of appeal
You can appeal only on one or more of these grounds:
- (a) the building is not of special architectural or historic interest
- (b) the matters alleged to be a contravention have not occurred
- (c) those matters, if they occurred, do not contravene section 8(1) or (2) of the 1997 Act
- (d) works to the building were urgently necessary, and all of these apply:
- the works were urgently necessary in the interests of safety or health, or for the preservation of the building
- it was not practicable to secure safety, health or preservation by works of repair or works for affording temporary support or shelter
- the works carried out were limited to the minimum measures immediately necessary
- (e) listed building consent ought to be granted for the works, or a condition of a consent already granted ought to be discharged or replaced by different conditions
- (f) copies of the notice were not served as the Act requires
- (g) the requirements of the notice exceed what is necessary to restore the building to its condition before the works, except for requirements to carry out alleviating works or to bring the building to the state it would have been in had the terms of a consent been complied with
- (h) the period the notice gives for taking a required step falls short of what should reasonably be allowed
- (i) the steps required to restore the building's character to its former state would not do so
- (ia) stopping the works the notice requires to cease goes beyond what is necessary to remedy the contravention
- (j) the alleviating works the notice requires exceed what is necessary to alleviate the effect of the works carried out
- (k) the steps required to bring the building to the state it would have been in had the terms of a consent been complied with exceed what may reasonably be required
Ground (f) refers to the requirement to serve a copy of the notice on the owner, the lessee and the occupier of the building, and on any other person with an interest in the building that, in the authority's opinion, is materially affected by the notice. The person deciding the appeal can disregard a failure to serve a person if satisfied that the person has not been substantially prejudiced by it.
Only an appeal can question the validity of the notice on ground (b) or ground (f). It cannot be questioned on those grounds in any other proceedings.
Lodge the appeal
Give written notice of the appeal to the Scottish Ministers before the effective date. You can instead post it in a properly addressed, prepaid letter at a time that, in the ordinary course of post, would see it delivered before that date. You can also send it using electronic communications at a time that, in the ordinary course of transmission, would see it delivered before that date.
The Planning and Environmental Appeals Division (DPEA) of the Scottish Government says on its website that you can submit an appeal electronically through the ePlanning.scot online system, and gives 0300 244 6668 as its telephone number. Before the effective date, check with the DPEA that this route takes a listed building enforcement appeal.
Planning and Environmental Appeals Division (DPEA) (opens in a new tab)
-
Prepare the statement of appeal
You must submit a statement of appeal on a form obtained from the Scottish Ministers, at the same time as the notice of appeal. It specifies the grounds of appeal and gives all matters you intend to raise in the appeal. It also gives your name and address and a copy of the notice. It gives the name and address of your representative, if any, with whether correspondence should go to the representative instead of you. Last, it gives a note of the matters you consider require determination and the procedure, or combination of procedures, you consider the appeal should use. The appeal may be dismissed if the statement is not submitted within the prescribed time, which is the same time as the notice of appeal.
-
Attach your evidence
Accompany the statement of appeal with copies of all documents, materials and evidence you intend to rely on. After the statement of appeal, you may raise further matters only as the Town and Country Planning (Appeals) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 and the hearing and inquiry session rules allow.
-
Send copies to the planning authority
At the same time as you give notice of appeal to the Scottish Ministers, you must send the planning authority copies of the notice of appeal, the statement of appeal and the documents, materials and evidence you intend to rely on.
-
Comment on the authority's response
The planning authority must send the Scottish Ministers and you its response to each ground of appeal within 21 days beginning with the date it receives notification of the appeal. You may send comments on the matters it raises to the Scottish Ministers and the authority within 14 days beginning with the date you receive the response.
How the appeal is decided
A person appointed by the Scottish Ministers decides an appeal against a listed building enforcement notice, unless the Ministers direct otherwise. The appointed person chooses how to decide it: without further procedure, or by written submissions, hearing sessions, inquiry sessions, a site inspection or a combination. The decision is treated as the Ministers' decision and, apart from the Court of Session challenge, is final.
The decision-maker gives directions for giving effect to the determination, including where appropriate directions for quashing the notice. On the appeal, the person deciding it can:
- quash the notice
- correct a defect, error or misdescription in the notice, or vary its terms, only if satisfied that this will not cause injustice to the appellant or the planning authority
- grant listed building consent for the works the notice relates to
- discharge a condition of a consent and substitute any other condition, whether more or less onerous
- direct Historic Environment Scotland to amend the list to give effect to the determination
The appeal may also be allowed, or the notice quashed, if the planning authority misses a deadline the regulations set for it.
Challenge the decision in the Court of Session
The decision cannot be questioned in any legal proceedings except by an application to the Court of Session. A person aggrieved by the decision may apply on the grounds that it is not within the powers of the Act, or that a relevant requirement was not complied with in relation to it. The application must be made within 6 weeks from the date the decision is made. The planning authority can also apply on those grounds.
The court may by interim order suspend the decision until the proceedings are finally determined. It may quash the decision if satisfied that it is not within the powers of the Act, or that the applicant's interests have been substantially prejudiced by a failure to comply with a relevant requirement.
Stop notices and temporary stop notices
A planning authority can serve a stop notice where it considers it expedient that relevant works should cease before the period for compliance with the enforcement notice expires. The relevant works are the works the enforcement notice requires to cease, and any works carried out as part of or associated with them. The authority can serve the stop notice when it serves the enforcement notice or afterwards, but not once the enforcement notice has taken effect. The stop notice states the date it comes into effect. That date must be no earlier than 3 days after service, unless the authority gives special reasons in a statement served with the notice, and no later than 28 days from the date the stop notice is first served on anyone.
A planning authority can issue a temporary stop notice, without a prior enforcement notice, only if all of these apply:
- works to a listed building in its district have been or are being carried out
- the works involve a contravention of section 8(1) or (2) of the 1997 Act
- it appears to the authority expedient that the works, or part of them, are stopped immediately
- the authority considers it expedient to issue the notice, having regard to the effect of the works on the character of the building as one of special architectural or historic interest
A temporary stop notice takes effect when a copy is first displayed on the building. It lasts for 28 days from that day, or for a shorter period the notice states, and ends sooner if the authority withdraws it.
A person who contravenes a stop notice after the authority has displayed on the building a site notice saying that a stop notice has been served, or after the stop notice has been served on that person, commits an offence. A person who contravenes a temporary stop notice that has been served on that person, or a copy of which has been displayed on the building, also commits an offence. Contravening includes causing or permitting the contravention. A person guilty of either offence is liable on summary conviction to a fine of up to £20,000, and on conviction on indictment to a fine.
It is a defence to a charge of contravening a stop notice that both of these apply:
- the stop notice was not served on you
- you had no reasonable cause to believe that the works were prohibited by the stop notice
It is a defence to a charge of contravening a temporary stop notice that both of these apply:
- the temporary stop notice was not served on you
- you did not know, and could not reasonably have been expected to know, of its existence
A stop notice ends when the enforcement notice is withdrawn or quashed, when the period for compliance expires, or when the authority withdraws the stop notice. It also stops applying to any works that the enforcement notice, as varied, no longer covers.
If no appeal is made, or the appeal fails
If nobody appeals before the effective date, the notice takes effect on that date. If an appeal is made, the notice stays of no effect only until the appeal is finally determined or withdrawn. Take advice on how the period for compliance applies once an appeal has been determined or withdrawn.
After the end of the period for compliance, the person who is then the owner of the land is in breach of the notice if a required step has not been taken or works required to cease have not ceased. That person commits an offence. The owner includes a lessee whose lease has more than 3 years left to run. The offence can be charged by reference to any day or longer period, and a person can be convicted again for any later period after a conviction.
A person guilty of the offence is liable on summary conviction to a fine of up to £20,000, and on conviction on indictment to a fine.
It is a defence to show either of these:
- you did everything you could be expected to do to secure that all the required steps were taken, or that all the works required to cease did cease
- you were not served with a copy of the notice and were not aware of its existence
If a required step is not taken within the period for compliance, the planning authority may enter the land, take the step and recover its reasonable expenses from the person who is then the owner or lessee.
If listed building consent is granted after the notice was issued, for retaining the works or for retaining them without complying with a condition, the notice ceases to have effect so far as it requires the works to cease or requires steps that involve the works not being retained. Offences already committed are not affected.
Buildings in conservation areas
A person must not execute, or cause to be executed, works to demolish a building in a conservation area without conservation area consent. This does not apply to a listed building, an ecclesiastical building for the time being used for ecclesiastical purposes, a building in the Schedule of monuments, or a building of a description the Scottish Ministers have directed is excluded. A building used or available for use by a minister of religion wholly or mainly as a residence from which to perform the duties of the office does not count as ecclesiastical. The enforcement provisions, including the notice, the appeal and the offence, apply to such a building as they apply to a listed building, with these changes to the enforcement provisions:
- references to a listed building and listed building consent become references to a building in a conservation area and conservation area consent
- the authority serves the notice having regard to the effect on the character or appearance of the conservation area in which the building is situated
- in considering whether restoration is undesirable, the authority has regard to the desirability of preserving the character or appearance of the conservation area in which the building is situated
- the authority issues a temporary stop notice having regard to the effect of the works on the character or appearance of the conservation area in which the building is situated
- ground (a) becomes that retention of the building is not necessary in the interests of preserving the character or appearance of the conservation area in which it is situated
- ground (i) is omitted
- the person deciding the appeal cannot direct Historic Environment Scotland to amend the list
The appeal goes to the Scottish Ministers on the same terms, before the effective date, with the same statement of appeal.
Scheduled monument enforcement notices
A scheduled monument has its own enforcement regime under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979. Historic Environment Scotland, not the planning authority, serves a scheduled monument enforcement notice.
The notice must state the date it takes effect, which must be at least 28 days after service, and a period for compliance. A person served, or anyone with an interest in the monument or in the land in, on or under which it is situated, may appeal to the Scottish Ministers at any time before the date the notice takes effect. The grounds include that the monument is not of national importance. The notice has no effect until the appeal is withdrawn or finally determined.
On the appeal, the Scottish Ministers may grant scheduled monument consent, or quash the notice, and may correct or vary it if satisfied that this will not cause injustice to the appellant or to Historic Environment Scotland. Their decision is final except as section 55 of the 1979 Act provides.
After the end of the period for compliance, the person who is then the owner of the monument or of the land in, on or under which it is situated is in breach of the notice if works required to cease have not ceased or a step required has not been taken. That person commits an offence. It is punishable on summary conviction by a fine of up to £20,000 and on conviction on indictment by a fine. It is a defence to show either of these:
- you did everything you could be expected to do to secure that all works required to cease were ceased, or that all the steps required were taken
- you were not served with a copy of the notice and were not aware of its existence
Give written notice of the appeal to the Scottish Ministers before the effective date. You must also submit a written statement of your grounds, when you give notice or within any later time that is prescribed, or the appeal may be dismissed. Take advice on the rest of the procedure.
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations