Work out whether your site is an establishment
The Control of Major Accident Hazards Regulations 2015 (COMAH) apply to an establishment that is lower tier or upper tier. An establishment is the whole location under one operator's control where a dangerous substance is present in one or more installations, including common or related infrastructure and activities, at or above the lower quantity in Schedule 1 for that substance (column 2), or caught by the addition rule.
The operator is the person in control of the operation of the establishment. For an establishment that is to be constructed or operated, it is the person who proposes to control it, or, if that person is not known, the person who commissioned its design and construction in the course of a trade, business or other undertaking.
A major accident is an occurrence such as a major emission, fire or explosion, resulting from uncontrolled developments in the operation of an establishment, that involves one or more dangerous substances and leads to serious danger to human health or the environment, immediate or delayed, inside or outside it.
Schedule 1 gives each substance a lower and an upper quantity, in tonnes. A lower tier establishment has a dangerous substance at or above the lower quantity (column 2) but below the upper (column 3). An upper tier establishment has one at or above the upper quantity (column 3).
A dangerous substance is a substance or mixture named in Schedule 1, or within one of its categories, including raw material, product, by-product, residue and intermediate.
Examples of Schedule 1 quantities
Schedule 1 lists many more substances and categories.
| Substance | Lower tier (tonnes) | Upper tier (tonnes) |
|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen | 5 | 50 |
| Chlorine | 10 | 25 |
| Anhydrous ammonia | 50 | 200 |
| Petroleum products and alternative fuels (gasolines and naphthas, kerosenes, gas oils, heavy fuel oils and similar) | 2,500 | 25,000 |
How to count the quantities
- the quantities relate to each establishment, and the amount counted is the maximum present or likely to be present at any one time, including a substance it is reasonable to foresee may be generated if control of a process, including storage, is lost
- dangerous substances present only in quantities equal to or less than 2% of the relevant qualifying quantity must be ignored in the total if their location is such that they cannot act as an initiator of a major accident elsewhere at the establishment
- where a substance is both named in Part 2 of Schedule 1 and within a Part 1 category, the Part 2 quantities apply
- where a substance has more than one classification, the lowest qualifying quantity applies, and for the addition rule the lowest qualifying quantity in each hazard group (health, physical, environmental) must be used
- a substance not covered by the CLP Regulation, including waste, with equivalent major accident potential must be provisionally assigned to the most analogous category or named substance
The addition rule
Where no single substance reaches the relevant qualifying quantity, lower or upper, the establishment is still caught if the quantities add up. Divide the quantity of each substance in a group by its qualifying quantity and add the results. A sum of 1 or more using the lower quantities makes the site lower tier, and a sum of 1 or more using the upper quantities makes it upper tier. The sum is run three times, once for each group:
- health hazards: Part 2 substances in acute toxicity category 1, 2 or 3 (inhalation) or STOT SE category 1, with Part 1 entries H1 to H3
- physical hazards: Part 2 explosives, flammable gases, aerosols and liquids, oxidising gases, liquids and solids, self-reactive substances and mixtures, organic peroxides and pyrophoric liquids and solids, with Part 1 entries P1 to P8
- environmental hazards: Part 2 substances in hazardous to the aquatic environment acute category 1 or chronic category 1 or 2, with Part 1 entries E1 and E2
The Regulations apply where any one of the three sums is 1 or more.
New, other and existing establishments
- a new establishment is one of the following, on or after 1 June 2015:
- an establishment constructed or entering into operation
- a site that becomes an establishment because its inventory of dangerous substances increases or changes
- a lower tier establishment that becomes upper tier, or the reverse, because a modification changes its inventory
- an other establishment is a site that becomes an establishment, or an establishment that changes tier, on or after 1 June 2015 for reasons other than a change in inventory
- an existing establishment is one that was already within the 1999 COMAH Regulations on 31 May 2015, was in the same tier on 1 June 2015 and has not changed tier since
Where a site becomes subject to the Regulations because its inventory changes, the start of operation is the time it first becomes subject to them.
When the first-time duties fall due
| Duty | New establishment | Other establishment |
|---|---|---|
| Notify the competent authority | Within a reasonable period before the start of construction, and again within a reasonable period before the start of operation, without repeating information that is still valid | Within 1 year beginning on the date it first becomes an other establishment |
| Prepare a major accident prevention policy | Within a reasonable period before construction or operation, or before a modification that changes the inventory | Within 1 year beginning on the date it first becomes an other establishment |
| Send a safety report (upper tier only) | Within a reasonable period before the start of construction, before the start of operation, and before a modification that changes the inventory | Within 2 years beginning on the date it first becomes an other establishment |
| Prepare an internal emergency plan (upper tier only) | Within a reasonable period before the start of operation or a modification that changes the inventory | Within 2 years beginning on the date it first becomes an other establishment |
Check whether an exclusion applies
The Regulations do not apply to any of the following:
- an establishment under the control of the Secretary of State for the purposes of the Ministry of Defence, or under the control of a headquarters or organisation designated under the International Headquarters and Defence Organisations Act 1964 or a visiting force's service authorities
- hazards created by ionising radiation originating from substances, and substances that create a hazard from ionising radiation if present on a nuclear establishment
- the transport of dangerous substances in pipelines, including associated apparatus, except where that activity takes place at a site that is an establishment despite that activity
- the transport of dangerous substances, and directly related intermediate temporary storage, by road, rail, internal waterway, sea or air, including loading and unloading and transport to and from another means of transport at docks, wharves or marshalling yards, except where that activity takes place at a site that is an establishment despite that activity
- the exploration, extraction and processing of minerals in mines and quarries, including by boreholes, except onshore underground gas storage in natural strata, aquifers, salt cavities and disused mines, chemical and thermal processing operations and related storage, and operational tailings disposal facilities, where these involve dangerous substances
- offshore exploration and exploitation of minerals, including hydrocarbons, and gas storage at underground offshore sites
- waste landfill sites, including underground waste storage, except chemical and thermal processing operations and related storage, and operational tailings disposal facilities, that involve dangerous substances
Know who regulates the site
The competent authority is the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and the appropriate agency acting jointly. The appropriate agency is the Environment Agency in England, Natural Resources Wales in Wales and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) in Scotland. For a nuclear establishment, the Office for Nuclear Regulation and the appropriate agency act jointly.
The competent authority sets in writing the form of notifications and the means of sending them.
Duties at both tiers
| Duty | What the operator must do | Keeping it up |
|---|---|---|
| Take all measures necessary | Take all measures necessary to prevent major accidents and limit their consequences for human health and the environment, and demonstrate to the competent authority that it has done so. Give the competent authority the assistance it needs to perform its functions, in particular to carry out inspections and investigations and gather information | At all times |
| Notify the establishment | Send the competent authority a notification giving the operator's name and address details, the person in charge, the dangerous substances with their quantity and physical form, the activities, and a description of the immediate environment and factors that could cause or worsen a major accident | Kept current by notifying changes in advance |
| Notify changes in advance | Notify the competent authority in advance of a significant increase or decrease in the notified quantities, a significant change in the nature or physical form of the substances or the processes using them, any modification of the establishment or an installation that could have significant consequences for major accident hazards, permanent closure or decommissioning, and any change to the name and address, registered place of business or person in charge | Before each change is made |
| Prepare, retain and review a major accident prevention policy | Prepare and retain a written policy designed to ensure a high level of protection of human health and the environment, proportionate to the major accident hazards, that sets out the operator's overall aims and principles of action and management's role, responsibility and commitment to continuously improving the control of major accident hazards | Review after a significant increase or decrease in the notified quantity of dangerous substances, or a significant change in their nature or physical form or in the processes using them that could have significant consequences for major accident hazards. In any event, review no later than 5 years after the last review, and revise and retain the policy where necessary |
| Implement the policy by a safety management system | Put the policy into effect through a safety management system meeting paragraphs 1 and 2 of Schedule 2 | At all times |
| Provide public information to the competent authority | Give the competent authority the information in regulation 17(1)(a) to (e): the operator's name and the establishment's address, confirmation that the Regulations apply and that the notification required by regulation 6 and the safety report required by regulation 9 have been sent, a simple explanation of the activities, the hazard classification of the dangerous substances at the establishment that could give rise to a major accident, with a simple indication of their main dangerous characteristics, and how the public will be warned, if necessary, and how to behave in a major accident (or where that information can be accessed electronically). At upper tier, also give the regulation 17(2) information. The competent authority publishes it | Update when necessary, and answer reasonable requests for information within the period the competent authority specifies |
| Co-operate in a domino group | Using any information received from the competent authority about the group, co-operate with the operators of each other establishment in the group in putting in place arrangements to exchange suitable information so that each can take account of the major accident hazards in its policy and safety management system and, at upper tier, safety report, internal emergency plan and information to people likely to be affected. Also co-operate in informing neighbouring sites outside the Regulations of their proximity to the group and in appropriate cases giving them suitable information, in preparing the information on how the public will be warned, if necessary, and how to behave in a major accident, and in supplying the local authority with information for preparing an external emergency plan, where one is required | From the time the competent authority notifies the operator that its establishment is in a domino group |
| Inform the competent authority after a major accident | Give the circumstances, the substances involved, data for assessing the effects, the emergency measures taken, and the steps envisaged to mitigate medium and long term consequences and prevent a recurrence | As soon as practicable after the accident, with further information as it becomes available, and an update if further investigation changes it |
The competent authority may permit an operator to give information required in a notification, policy, safety report, internal emergency plan or post-accident report by reference to a document sent to the appropriate agency under environmental permitting, if it considers it expedient. The operator must tell it in writing when it relies on this and to what extent. If the competent authority decides the document does not satisfy the Regulations, the operator may not rely on it.
Extra duties at upper tier
Duties at upper tier only
| Duty | What the operator must do | Keeping it up |
|---|---|---|
| Prepare and send a safety report | Prepare a safety report containing at least the Schedule 3 data and information, identifying the organisations involved, and send it to the competent authority. Information already sent that remains valid need not be repeated | Review and, where necessary, revise no later than 5 years after it was last sent (or last reviewed, if not required to be sent). Despite that, also review after a major accident at the establishment, where new facts, technological knowledge (including from accidents and near misses) or developments in hazard assessment justify it, before a modification to the establishment, a process, or the nature, form or quantity of dangerous substances that could have significant consequences for major accident hazards, and after a safety management system change that could have significant consequences |
| Prepare an internal emergency plan | Prepare a plan specifying the measures to be taken inside the establishment, containing the Schedule 4 Part 1 information. Consult people working there, the appropriate agency, the emergency services, the health authority for the area (in England the integrated care board, in Wales the Local Health Board, in Scotland the Health Board), in England NHS England and Public Health England (the body the Regulations still name), and the local authority unless it is exempted from preparing an external plan | Review and test at suitable intervals not exceeding 3 years, taking account of changes at the establishment or in the emergency services and new technical knowledge and knowledge on responding to major accidents, and revise where necessary |
| Put the plan into effect | Take reasonable steps to ensure the internal emergency plan is put into effect without delay | If a major accident occurs, or an uncontrolled event occurs that could reasonably be expected to lead to one |
| Give the local authority the information for its external emergency plan | Provide the information the local authority needs to prepare the external emergency plan. The plan is the local authority's duty, not the operator's. The competent authority may exempt the local authority in writing, with reasons, if, from the safety report, it considers the establishment incapable of creating a major accident hazard outside it | Before the date the internal emergency plan is required to be prepared |
| Send safety information to people likely to be affected | Make sure every person likely to be in the area the competent authority has notified, and every school, hospital and other area of public use in it, is sent clear and intelligible information on safety measures and required behaviour in a major accident, without having to request it. It must include at least the public information the competent authority makes public about the establishment, including the upper tier information, and the operator must consult the local authority in preparing it | Review at intervals not exceeding 3 years, or on a modification that could have significant consequences for major accident hazards. Send again if revised after a review, and otherwise at intervals not exceeding 5 years |
Send a revised safety report
A revised report, or the revised parts, goes to the competent authority without delay, except that a revised report for a modification goes in advance of the modification. If the operator reviews the report and does not revise it, it must tell the competent authority in writing without delay.
When each duty starts
The 1-year and 2-year periods for an other establishment apply only to notification, the policy, the safety report and the internal emergency plan. Some duties have no period of their own and bind the operator from the day the site comes within the Regulations: the general duty to take all measures necessary to prevent major accidents and limit their consequences, notifying changes in advance, supplying public information, and the duties after a major accident. The information for the local authority is due before the internal emergency plan is, the information for people likely to be affected is sent once the competent authority has notified the area, and the domino group duties start when the competent authority notifies the operator.
HSE guidance (L111, paragraph 115) says an operator of an other establishment must ensure it fully complies with the Regulations from the date they first apply to it. HSE also says, as guidance, that a reasonable period before construction or operation for notification would normally be 3 to 4 months, and normally 3 to 6 months for the policy and the safety report.
Pay the fees
The operator of any establishment pays the competent authority's fee for its COMAH work. The operator of an upper tier establishment also pays for HSE or Office for Nuclear Regulation enforcement work under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 against the operator or its contractors, except where the competent authority considers the dangerous substance is present for a purpose ancillary to the main activity.
A fee may not exceed the costs reasonably incurred. It is payable within 30 days from the date of the invoice, which must include a statement of the work done and the costs, including the period. It is recoverable only as a civil debt. It may not include:
- the costs of a criminal investigation or prosecution, from the summons in England and Wales or from the report to the Procurator Fiscal or Procurator Fiscal intervention in Scotland, whichever is sooner
- the costs of an appeal under section 24 of the 1974 Act, incurred from the date a claim is presented to an employment tribunal
- the costs of functions related to regulation 13 (external emergency plans)
A local authority may charge the operator a fee for preparing, reviewing and testing the external emergency plan, on the same 30-day and cost limits.
Comply with a prohibition notice
The competent authority must prohibit, by serving a notice on the operator, the operation or bringing into operation of the establishment, or of any installation, storage facility or part of any of them, where the measures taken by the operator to prevent and mitigate major accidents are seriously deficient. It may do so where the operator has not submitted a required notification, report or other information within the specified time. The notice gives reasons and a start date. The operator must comply with it, and may appeal in the same way as against a prohibition notice under section 22 of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.
Penalties for contravening the Regulations
Contravening a requirement or prohibition imposed by or under the Regulations is an offence. The maximum penalty is:
- in England and Wales, on summary conviction, up to 3 months' imprisonment or an unlimited fine, or both
- in Scotland, on summary conviction, up to 12 months' imprisonment or a fine of up to £10,000 (the statutory maximum), or both
- on conviction on indictment, up to 2 years' imprisonment or a fine, or both
Legal basis
Primary legislation and key regulations